News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My students forged the notes. I turned them into a lesson... by anigbrowl on Thursday July 23, 2009 @03:22PM (#720166)
Does it need to be so either/or? Not everyone needs to be expert at everything, but on the other hand ignorance creates enormous barriers to entry - illiteracy being an extreme example.

If we focus on educating people as consumers and then gave them discretion on which subjects they are sufficiently interested in to become producers, we might gain more. for example, politicians and marketers abuse statistics on a regular basis, secure in the knowledge that the average person has little statistic knowledge. So we have a small set of people who understand statistics very well, a larger population that are very credulous, and a similarly sized one that think all statistics are BS, an only slightly less ignorant position. You can imagine parallels with rhetorical fallacies or logic and science.

I suggest that students need to be well-rounded enough to assess the quality of information they're likely to encounter or use frequently and then follow their interests from there. So we should probably be teaching financial numeracy, basic statistics and perhaps geometry/trigonometry much earlier, because those are massively important life skills. Algebra, maybe not so much.

When I look at verbal political debates, they seem to me to center around the 8th grade level or even a bit lower. Written debates (eg newspaper editorials) seem to float in the 6th-12th grade level. Then again, I can't help noticing the existence of a TV quiz show called 'Are you smarter than a 5th grader' :-/

There are no comments on this comment yet.