Re:SolarCoin cryptocurrency pays you to go green
by mushishi on Thursday February 06, 2014 @12:05PM
(#7191389)
Could you give some estimates how much energy is spent on having current fiat currencies, and how much energy would be spent if similar amount of transactions were used for cryptocurrency. I always wonder why people don't discuss this, or when do, no estimates are given.
Re:SolarCoin cryptocurrency pays you to go green
by dllthomas on Thursday February 06, 2014 @01:46PM
(#7192122)
My worry, regarding resources, is not that any are burned, but that it's an arms race where effort to attack is O(effort to defend), which means we always need to collectively burning more resources than attackers could and we don't even get the tremendous discount afforded us by crypto in other spheres (brute forcing encryption takes effort of O(2^effort to defend), for example). If we get more efficient algorithms or processes or technology in traditional finance, the resources we spend can shrink - not so, with proof-of-work.
Of course, with physical attack there is always an arms race, but bitcoin is still vulnerable to physical attack.
Re:SolarCoin cryptocurrency pays you to go green
by aninhumer on Thursday February 06, 2014 @11:43AM
(#7191237)
I think you're making a rather tenuous argument here. Just because existing monetary systems involve work, and a new alternative system also involves work, doesn't imply that such systems always must.
You can dislike cryptocurrencies for all sorts of other reasons, but that fact that some resources are consumed to keep it running really is going to be a feature of any sort of monetary system.