The shoes I'm wearing now were purchased on Zappos and the design dates back to 1966. Fashion can have staying power.
Are shoes "fashion"? I would not be able to tell the difference between a shoe from 10 years ago versus one from today (and somehow, I've accumulated a lot of shoes; running, cycling, sneakers, sandals...). I am sure some of Zappos' customers care about the latest and greatest, but many probably don't.
What zappos sells are what are labeled FMCG - fast moving consumer goods. In this instance, you want almost no inventory, but extremely effective supplier partnerships and delivery cycles. What they have is a really engaged consumer community who can help them predict what they might want to buy soon.
If they use the metrics efficiently enough, they can stock the really popular lines and get-the-numbers-right on the slower but better margined products.
If you could run zappos/amazon scale and drop ship from manufacturer... well - that's the goal. (See timbuk2 et al for more).