News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by jacquesm on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @06:40PM (#718710)
This is the same kind of 'loss' that the RIAA claims every time somebody downloads an mp3, money that you didn't earn is not a 'loss', it's a missed opportunity.
Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by pg on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @07:49PM (#718784)
The title isn't claiming they suffered a loss, more that they lost out. Those are different senses of the word.

And they did lose out, if they had convertible debt and asked for the money back instead of converting it. That is an exceptionally rare outcome. No VC does a convertible debt deal expecting it to actually be a loan.

Everyone seems to hate this article, but I found it useful. It is an interesting data point that a fairly highly regarded VC thought so little of Zappos that they opted not to convert a convertible round. It's up there with Battery turning down Facebook.

Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by jacquesm on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @08:04PM (#718799)
The title says 'lost big', not 'lost out'.

It is my understanding of the use of convertible debt that the industry uses this as a means of recouping part or all of the money in case an investment doesn't fly but doesn't tank either.

If it flies convert otherwise demand your cash back and treat the investment as a regular loan.

Wait too long with converting the debt and you'll find out that the knife cuts both ways.

What I really don't get in all this is why after such a spectacular exit this founder would go and pick up such a small investment on a convertible loan basis.

Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by req2 on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @10:31PM (#718937)
If you use 'winning' and 'losing', the usage 'lost big' works well for the situation.
Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by ErrantX on Thursday July 23, 2009 @05:10AM (#719254)
It depends how you read the title - in fairness to jacquesm it does read like they have actually lost something. Which isnt technically true - they missed a great opportunity sure, but there is no loss, purely a failure to gain (IMO that's a huge distinction).
Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by gizmo on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @06:55PM (#718729)
The situations are very different.

The investors faced a dilemma, they had to make a decision. They made a poor choice (perhaps only in retrospect), and missed out on a bunch of money because of it.

The RIAA doesn't decide whether people pay or download. The people face the dilemma: download and possibly face consequences, or pay. Since the RIAA doesn't have a decision to make, there is no missed opportunity either.

Or take a poker analogy. Suppose you have the best possible hand at show down. If you then muck your cards regardless, you forfeit the pot. This is a missed opportunity, and definitely also a loss.

Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by jacquesm on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @07:10PM (#718744)
A 'loss' would have been if they had to write off that money instead of recoup their loan. That it would have earned them more in the long term is not a loss, that is stretching the definition of the word loss beyond the breaking point.

The RIAA makes a similar argument, they count every mp3 downloaded as a lost sale, whereas it remains to be seen if a sale would have been made.

In both cases the word 'loss' is used in ways that suggest that in some alternative universe the 'loser' would have been better off, but that is one of those things that you'll never get to check, you can only live in one universe at the time...

Poor choices in retrospect are fantasy, you make your choices in real time to the best of your ability and you hope that you make them well. If you're going to second guess yourself (or be second guessed by third parties such as techchrunch) after the fact then you are engaging in deception. For all you know the whole thing could have gone south and then everybody would have have been saying 'wow, look at how much money they saved'.

Hindsight...

Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by pyre on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @07:31PM (#718767)
There is a difference between learning from your mistakes and 'second guessing' yourself.

They should probably revisit the deal and the information that they had at the time. It's possible that there was some information they viewed as 'worthless' which would have changed their mind had they given it more weight. This could possibly help them out in similar situations in the future.

Saying "we can't go second-guessing ourselves" is a sure way to keep repeating the same mistakes over and over again. _Especially_ if they are subtle mistakes with large consequences. That said, they shouldn't devote millions and millions of man-hours pouring over what they could have done different either.

Re: Guess Who Lost Big on the Zappos Deal? by jacquesm on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @07:36PM (#718771)
You're absolutely right about that, and I'm sure that this is a 'learning moment' for them. I never meant to give the impression that you shouldn't learn from your mistakes.

If there is a clear reason why they wanted their cash back - and nobody seems to have a clue why they did that - then all this is is speculation.

Money in the bank in the short term is sometimes more important than a great payoff at some distant point in the future (if it happens).