Re:Scenes from a militarized America
by parsnips on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:34PM
(#7181218)
If the historical purpose of the second amendment is to have a citizenry capable of defending itself from unjust government force, and the government is increasingly using unjust force; How does it follow that the citizens need to concede anything?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scenes from a militarized America
by scott_karana on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:42PM
(#7181237)
No kidding. There have been cases similar to this (but less dramatic) where the homeowners fired on the un-marked, un-announced police squad, and were (rightly!) vindicated under their states' respective castle or self-defense laws.
What a pointless waste of life. Police need to go back to basics.
> There have been cases similar to this (but less dramatic) where the homeowners fired on the un-marked, un-announced police squad, and were (rightly!) vindicated under their states' respective castle or self-defense laws.
There have? Could you please cite them? In reading the Author's book, mentioned at the end of the article, I was lead to believe that the castle doctrine has pretty much eroded to the point that one has a reasonable sense of privacy in one's own home, buy if you're suspected of illegal activity you basically forfeit that right.
Re:Scenes from a militarized America
by scott_karana on Wednesday February 05, 2014 @01:54PM
(#7185879)
Sure, here:
http://www.theeagle.com/news/local/article_549b0586-cefc-53a...
Can't see any others at the moment, sorry.
You might be right about forfeiting the right in illegal activities, I don't know.
How do those situations play out such that the homeowner lives to see themselves vindicated?
It's not a debate in a vacuum... The problems people have with the Second Amendment often arise from citizen-on-citizen shootings...both the shooting-rampage variety, and the There's-not-enough-money-to-fund-the-police-so-criminals-go-rampant kind.
I'm not saying gun rights should be abolished or limited...I guess I'm just despondently pointing out difficult (and money-based) of an issue it is.