News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by Aaronn on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @06:31PM (#7180961)
FiftyThree just posted this on Twitter:

.@daringfireball please don’t take the bait. Paper by miSoft V1 was launched Sep 20th 2012, 5 month after us.

https://twitter.com/FiftyThree/status/430845528805756928

Re:Paper, by MiSoft by k-mcgrady on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @06:41PM (#7180998)
Wasn't their point that they registered the name Paper with Apple before anyone else? You can register an app name and have it held for a couple months I think before actually launching.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by bennyg on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:24PM (#7181180)
You have 180 days after registering the name to use it - and then you can never register that name again under that developer account.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by rbritton on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:41PM (#7181235)
There's a loophole. If you register it, submit a binary, and then reject the binary you get unlimited time.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by bennyg on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @08:32PM (#7181398)
That's actually awesome to know. I've lost an amazing name because of this - and wish I still had it.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by gorner on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @08:09PM (#7181313)
That doesn't make a difference for trademark rights though. Priority for trademark rights would be based on the first date the name was actually used on an available product/service – or, at the very least, the date an intent-to-use trademark application was filed (which MiSoft does not appear to have done) – NOT the first date it was thought of or worked on.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by hrktb on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:10PM (#7181110)
If someone registers the name but it appears nowhere on the store, the name + some string is OK and an existing app can change to the same name and get published in the meantime, it's basically as if there is no name registration.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by Greenisus on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @06:59PM (#7181069)
That's interesting but I'm not sure launch date should be the date that determines when it's fair for you to have a name. FiftyThree's Paper is no doubt the better one (I was at WWDC and applauded them when they won their ADA), but some apps take a very long time to build. While you're building your masterpiece, some bozo could start and finish a lesser app and use your name before you have a chance to do anything about it.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by rikf on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:07PM (#7181099)
If your apps biggest selling point is that its named after a commonly used noun then I think you have problems. Its a similar concept to idea vs execution. We saw the same thing at the start of the internet revolution with domain squatting.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by gorner on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @08:19PM (#7181350)
If they (MiSoft) had filed a trademark application for "Paper" around the same time they reserved the name with Apple, they might have a case. But reserving a name with a retailer – without actually using it, and without anyone (other than Apple) knowing you were planning to use it – would not to my knowledge have any legal effect with regards to usage rights.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by interpol_p on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @08:10PM (#7181315)
I remember when Paper by FiftyThree first came out, I went to the App Store and searched for "Paper". The first result was some other simple drawing app called "Paper" (not miSoft's). There was definitely a "Paper" app in the App Store, for drawing, before Paper by FiftyThree.
Re:Paper, by MiSoft by julianwa on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:36PM (#7181910)
Disclaimer: I'm a co-founder at FiftyThree

Just a few facts:

1. "Paper", an app from developer "Contradictory", has existed in the App Store since October 27, 2011. This is presumably before miSoft registered their Paper. (https://twitter.com/FiftyThree/status/430873195097632769) Contradictory is clearly a name squatter.

2. miSoft's Paper launched ~5 months after Paper by FiftyThree. (https://twitter.com/FiftyThree/status/430845528805756928)

3. miSoft renamed another of their apps "Kid Paint" to "Paper Express" on 12/20/2012 after FiftyThree won App of the Year (https://twitter.com/georgpetschnigg/status/43091631900616704...)

Re:Paper, by MiSoft by interpol_p on Friday February 07, 2014 @05:48PM (#7199301)
Thanks for your reply. I have no problems with your name (and I'm in love with your app, Paper). But on your release day I did come across another app called "Paper" that I actually downloaded by mistake because App Store search is so bad it hadn't indexed "Paper by FiftyThree" yet.

I can't find it anymore, but the icon was very simple, a plain white A4 piece of paper on a blue background. I assume this app existed on the store before yours because I managed to accidentally download it on your release day.

When a name is generic like Paper I think it's okay to have multiple apps on the App Store.