Could you cite a link to the case you're thinking of, where evidence from SIGINT surveillance was used directly as probable cause for a search?
Also, could you yourself update your mental model of what's happening on HN? You obviously think I'm a tenacious foe of civil liberties causes. The opposite is true. I've done as much in the real world to support civil liberties causes as most anyone else on HN has. I contribute to candidates who I believe support a strong fourth amendment. I've canvassed for candidates like them. I donate to civil liberties causes.
What I have a problem with are batshit conspiracy theories, which is something HN is rife with. People should stop pretending that conspiracy theories are helpful when they're of the right valence. They aren't.
If you've actually followed me around HN, you know that I'm not at all unwilling to acknowledge when I'm wrong, as a cursory look at HNSearch will show. So, instead of yelling at me, why not show where I'm wrong?
Lawful stop? No. Remedy? No.
The core issue is that the judiciary's (and your) presumption of reliable and trustworthy law enforcement behavior is not valid. This is a LEO 'company culture' problem which has always existed (formerly a racial problem, but now everyone's problem now that we're not doing that any more).
I'm not sure what the answer is, other than people need to learn what has happened in the ghetto for the last 200 years, then accept that they're next.
I think it would be more plausible that he was profiled for race/location/type of vehicle/etc., rather than his name, but maybe there are more specifics?
Warrants are issued by a court. Courts are imperfect and may not have correct date of birth or other identifying information beyond a name.
I suppose it's possible the ALPS could be configured to just ID every single car, and the officer had in his mind (or using another system) the name of a specific suspect who he matched (erroneously) to the ALPS results of the victim here.
HAH!
Sorry, continue.
It seems likely there are cases of the SOD information being used to target people for abusive traffic stops (the agent in the Reuters article says And so we'd alert the state police to find an excuse to stop that vehicle, and then have a drug dog search it).
This should be illegal. It should be illegal even if something perfectly analogous has existed in that past. The extensiveness of a technique and the power that it allows matters.
I'm not going to go back and find this conversation because I shouldn't have to. It's not my job to follow you around and make sure you are being intellectually honest. It's pretty frustrating that someone as well-respected as you are here, and someone who is such a prolific poster, refuses to update his model of the world when new information is introduced into it. You are mind-bogglingly tenacious in trying to quell the outrage over civil liberties abuses and apparently go as far as selectively forgetting relevant information.