Re:The recent “How Quantum is the D-Wave Machine?” Shin et.a...
by fidotron on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:00PM
(#7178633)
It seems quite likely that whoever turns quantum computing into something practical will face exactly that criticism from the academic quantum computing community, largely since it appears construction of what they think of as proper quantum computers doesn't seem to be too feasible. If D-Wave have managed it I must admit I'd be surprised, but the amount of venom thrown their way is curious.
Re:The recent “How Quantum is the D-Wave Machine?” Shin et.a...
by CJefferson on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:06PM
(#7178680)
The venom is understandable in any competition (and the battle to build a working, useful quantum computer is a major competition between both companies and universities) where just about every knowledgeable person is convinced someone cheated.
The short answer is: "They aren't really doing quantum computing. They're essentially cheating."
But, I'm no quantum mechanic PhD, so it's not first hand knowledge as to why.