News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swiss police: Screen in Tesla cars is too large by masklinn on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:43AM (#7178095)
> Smaller, difficult to read and use interfaces that require more attention are better for operating heavy machinery.

The center console display is not "for operating machinery". That's what the dashboard is for. If your eyes are on the center console, they're nowhere near the road.

And touchscreen are a horrible way to operate heavy machinery as they can't be operated by touch alone, the split second where you have to look at the screen (where good[0] physical controls would have been stored in muscle memory a long time ago) can lead to lots of damage. In fact, the article also points out to issues with this as the Tesla's touchscreen is apparently necessary to toggle fog lamps buried behind multiple screens, a completely inane proposition.

[0] not all physical controls are good, e.g. I've seen decks where all controls are small identical buttons, completely unusable and genuinely dangerous

Re:Swiss police: Screen in Tesla cars is too large by Already__Taken on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:58AM (#7178212)
I'm sorry I wasn't quite happy myself how I worded it.

"operating heaving machinery" I mean that as; While driving the car you should also use this smaller, difficult to read and use interface.

I'm not going to defend it to the death, it's almost certainly not the best implementation in the world, nothing in software is. But a massive screen lets you make input so much bigger than they ever could be in hardware. You can't take up 17" just for the radio if it were real, you can on a screen. Or have a 17" 'Object in path' warning light.

I've had my car 5 years and can't operate the radio by touch. Or the fog light buttons on the far side of the dash.

Re:Swiss police: Screen in Tesla cars is too large by masklinn on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:12PM (#7179189)
> But a massive screen lets you make input so much bigger than they ever could be in hardware.

Which does not actually matter. The problem is not the size of the control, it's 1. finding it, 2. distinguishing it from its brethren and 3. only activating it once 1 and 2 are unambiguously fulfilled.

The core properties of a touchscreen, its usual advantages of being flexible and ever-changing, become drawbacks.

And I think that's OK, use the right tool for the right job you know? There are situations where a touchscreen is not the right tool.

Re:Swiss police: Screen in Tesla cars is too large by Gravityloss on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:06AM (#7178257)
You could have a hybrid which would have good and bad features of both worlds: if you have physical buttons on the side (or all sides) of a screen, and a "reset" button or "mode" buttons. Then the button sequences after "reset" or "mode set" can still be learned by muscle memory, and you don't have to look at the screen. But the buttons can still have multiple uses and the screen can still give directions, especially in the learning or less often used features.

The positive click of a physical button is much less error prone than a touch screen (although touch screens with a vibrate function can be a bit better).

These kind of displays are used in aircraft and spacecraft.

http://astronautabby.com/files/2013/11/Astronaut-Abby-Lockhe...