News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Put.io by Nursie on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:07AM (#7175797)
I understand the ethically shady bit but... how does it weaken the case against DRM? Surely it just continues to demonstrate how useless it is as a strategy?
Re:Put.io by gcb0 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @02:34AM (#7175993)
As someone who just got his daily 40min of "TV" interrupted by amazon error AMZP-9, right in the middle of an episode... i'm now regretting not having downloaded a torrent ilegaly. The whole thing with torrent is not about saving money. I already have access to the content for free for paying amz prime. it is all about convenience. I was lied to that instant streaming was more convenient. Well, that until AMZP-9 popups in the middle of an episode and there is not way to watch it for the day.

With torrent, at least i'd know beforehand when setting my 40min* aside, that i will press play and see the damn content. So yeah, it does not weaken the case against DRM. i will agree that it strengthen it. Any engineer worth its salt would CACHE the damn stream. They can't because of DRM and silly contracts out of touch with reality.

(* and that is not counting the 5min that it takes to GET to the content on amazon player... piece of @!#)

Re:Put.io by TallGuyShort on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:20AM (#7177928)
In theory what you say makes sense, but then why is there still DRM? There's been strong evidence that it's useless for a long time already, and companies are still implementing it. What do you think will actually convince people to stop that hasn't happened already? I say it weakens the case because more piracy just inspires the knee-jerk reaction of "we have to do something to protect the children from pirated software!" It's like the TSA. Is it actually effective? I don't think so. But the more attacks we perceive the more the average joe and politicians think we need more TSA.
Re:Put.io by Nursie on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:28AM (#7177988)
Thanks for responding.

What you say makes sense as well, I guess we're really talking about two different arguments. One logical/reasoned (look, DRM has basically failed) and the other emotional (OMG piracy! We must have more DRM!). They're kind of orthogonal to my mind.

>> In theory what you say makes sense, but then why is there still DRM?

For a whole complex of reasons, some of which boil down to exactly what you say. Maybe if nobody ever pirated anything it would go away, but I doubt it. It's too useful for other purposes - market segmentation, multiple resales for new formats or devices, preventing reasonable backups etc etc.

Re:Put.io by TallGuyShort on Wednesday February 05, 2014 @11:03AM (#7184488)
>> I guess we're really talking about two different arguments

Right, and while I completely agree with your logical reason, my fear is that the emotional one is more prevalent and thus, the only one that will really determine future behavior.

I haven't considered "market segmentation" as a purpose of DRM - that's certainly interesting. I think the concept of market segmentation is unfair and manipulative, so I think this lends more weight to the commenter who suggested they feel a moral obligation to violate what copyright has become. Personally, I still prefer to pay for what I'm getting, and I just avoid products from companies who make that more difficult then it needs to be. But I see the viewpoint better now.

Re:Put.io by Nursie on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:06AM (#7178261)
I should say that for market segmentation it appears to work - those that stick to the rules are limited to media from their region. But this is another driver piracy.
Re:Put.io by pikachu_is_cool on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @02:21AM (#7175952)
He never said it was unethical.

He said that doing illegal things with these torrents will only give the corporations/ones in power more leeway into getting politicians to pass laws that require DRM, violate our privacy, etc.

Re:Put.io by Nursie on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @02:34AM (#7175992)
No he said it would weaken the case, I was wondering how.

If piracy stops people will say DRM works and they need more powers to really cement it in place. If piracy continues then people will say they need more DRM to stop it.

I cannot see how the existence of this site (or other torrent services) weakens the case against DRM.

Re:Put.io by aragot on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @03:20AM (#7176150)
If there is piracy, more laws will be passed, possibly ending up axing every category of Internet usage.
Re:Put.io by Nursie on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:52AM (#7177062)
But that's nothing to do with making any case, simply practical consequences. Much like the drug war, DRM and its legal environment are basically self perpetuating now. I don't see.how continuing piracy has any impact at all.
Re:Put.io by pikachu_is_cool on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:01PM (#7180549)
Maybe because you agree with McAfee? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DM51_LXblYk
Re:Put.io by tomp on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @04:52AM (#7176472)
But that is making the case against such laws stronger!