Maybe, but your counterexamples don't seem particularly convincing.
Where does Python fit?
Originally, a readable scripting language.
More recently, a language for back-end web development that doesn't ram OO down your throat.
Also carving out something of a niche as a general purpose scripting language embedded in other applications instead of a custom macro language, like Lua but many more people have prior experience programming in it.
C#
Similar strengths to Java, but with a lot of useful extra features, without most of the limitations that should have gone away a decade ago but didn't, and with a runtime environment that is available by default on Windows.
The reasons [Lisp] never took of is a combination of little advertising/pushing ... and highly fragmentary communities ... leading to no corpus of code.
Also, a highly uniform and generic structure is not always an advantage in a programming language. Sometimes it's better to have things that are different obviously look like they're different.
That assertion's got more holes than emmental. Where does Python fit? C#? Javascript and Objective-C don't really "solve one problem really well", they're the only fucking option in their space. Java was not and has never been "C with garbage collection", the syntax is the only thing it got from C.
The language being great at solving a specific use case is definitely a boon and increases its chances (witness PHP or Lua), but it's nowhere near sufficient (Tcl lives in the same niche as Lua — lightweight, extensible, multi-paradigm language for embedding in and scripting of native codebases, predates Lua, and is considered by many of its lovers better than Lua, yet it's dying its slow and protracted death)
> The reason it's never taken off is that there is no one big problem that it solves that other languages can't solve easily enough.
The reasons it never took of is a combination of little advertising/pushing (compare with java), and highly fragmentary communities (the community unit of Lisp, as those of mages, is 1) leading to no corpus of code.
> The bad news for a lot of the better, smaller languages
And yet there's never been more uptake in new languages.