News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by gabemart on Monday February 03, 2014 @11:57AM (#7171758)
It's not impossible, but it can be extremely difficult.

Consider a short story published in a literary journal last week. Allow a copyright system to exist that covers each eligible work for 30 years by default, and allows multiple extensions of 5 years at a cost of $1000 per extension per work, up to a total copyright term of 100 years.

Someone in 2047 discovers a copy of this particular journal issue, which has now become obscure. They identify that this short story, though never being given acclaim, has had a subtle yet profound cultural influence. They decide to republish the story in their own commercial magazine, but want to check if the copyright has been extended. If it has not, the story is in the public domain. If is has been extended, the story is still covered by copyright.

They can search the central registry for the title of the short story and the name of the author. But they also have to search for the names of the editors of the journal, because it isn't clear whether or not the copyright stayed with the author or was transferred to the journal as part of the submission process. In fact, the copyright might have been granted to the owner of the journal, which may be an individual or may be an institution. The entry for the copyright might be under the title of the short story, or under the title for the journal, or under the title of that particular issue of the journal.

Furthermore, the author of the story, if they retained the copyright, may have submitted the story under a pen name, and/or may have registered the copyright of the short story under a different title than the title they used to submit to the journal, or the title might have been changed by the editors.

Or, the author, after having the short story accepted by the journal, may have sold it to a publisher who published it in a short fiction anthology, the copyright for which is registered completely separately and is essentially invisible to our hypothetical future researcher.

Any of these agents might have extended the copyright. It would be extremely difficult to prove to a high degree of certainty that the story was or was not covered by copyright.

Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by VLM on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:51PM (#7173389)
How about:

Violation of a registered copyright only carries punishment if "the" UUID of the work is registered and is contained in the work (byline, front page, whatever as appropriate). Doesn't actually matter if the UUID has any relationship to the work, although it would be nice if it did.

Example, This HN post from 2014 is registered copyright UUID 12345-23-242342 by VLM.

In 2097 simply check https://copyright.example/12345-23-242342 for current status. Instead of copyright.example, I hope they can think of a more intelligent international (interplanetary?) domain name, but the general idea holds.

Don't want copyright enforced on a work created in 2015, simply neglect to list the UUID you got at registration. I see no reason a registration should be expensive other than the usual crooks trying to eliminate competition. No technological reason.

False claim (intentional random numbers instead of valid registration) equals instant public domain.

Essentially this large integer is the title - registration ID - type of concept for this copyrighted media.

Personally I think it would be awesome if the title generator also stored licensing info. My panoramic landscape photo is not only registered to me, but is CC:NC. If you messed with the system you could force all UUID beginning with 0 to be all rights reserved, all UUID beginning with 9 to be CC:SA. Just keep on generating UUIDs until you get ASCII codes for C, C, S, and A as the first 4 bytes for a CC:SA UUID. Or the first 3 bytes being ASCII G, P, and L. Better be a long/wide UUID system.

Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by mattdw on Monday February 03, 2014 @09:55PM (#7175209)
UUID "contained in the work" would be troublesome in many mediums (music recordings, film, paintings, for instance). Perhaps "travels with the work" would be manageable though.

And it's worth considering that every tweet, every photo on Flickr, every video on YouTube, every status update on FB, and so on, constitutes a new copyrightable work. Not everyone will care about the copyrights of their tweets, but some will. How do you copyright something for which you have no control of the identifiers? I assume you don't intend for people to hit up the service for a new UUID before tweeting and embed the token in their tweet?

(Obviously this problem would go away if e.g. Twitter itself signed onto this scheme, automatically registering and UUIDing your tweets on your behalf.)

Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by VLM on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:51AM (#7177059)
"And it's worth considering that every tweet"

Is taken care of by

"Violation of a registered copyright only carries punishment"

Or if thats a non-starter just reduce all the penalties by 1e6 or perhaps 1e3 for violation of an untagged work.

Retweeting being a copyright violation, but if a REGEX doesn't find a UUID in there, the legal cost would be a micropayment transaction, so probably ignored.

I would have to re-read Berne to determine if this sneaks by on a technicality, or if Berne is simply culturally and technologically obsolete. Its a copyright treaty, not an economic suicide pact... can be worked around.

Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by sp332 on Monday February 03, 2014 @06:03PM (#7174180)
Since the digits in a UUID are independent, just overwrite the first characters to whatever you want. You don't have to keep generating random numbers.
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by slyall on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:37PM (#7173293)
but under the current system we still have the same problem. We know the story is copyright to somebody but we have no idea who.
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by icebraining on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:03PM (#7171811)
Why can't you just type in a section (say, a paragraph) of the work and have a fuzzy search locate it, instead of relying on just the title and author? I think your situation is only difficult due to poor technology. Youtube can now identify even distorted sections of videos and audio against an huge catalog of works, why can't the copyright registry?
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by sp332 on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:36PM (#7172117)
It would help, but it still wouldn't be clear if the version you're holding is the one that was copyrighted.

It would also be basically impossible for anything more intensive than text.

Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by anigbrowl on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:54PM (#7173409)
Just give it a number and make protection contingent upon publication of same with the work.
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by sp332 on Monday February 03, 2014 @06:01PM (#7174165)
But then you would have to put a number on every work just in case you extend the copyright later. Otherwise you might have a 35-year-old work and have no idea if its copyright has been extended because it was not originally printed with a number.
Re:Why Games Should Enter The Public Domain by thaumasiotes on Monday February 03, 2014 @08:33PM (#7174908)
>> Just give it a number and make protection contingent upon publication of same with the work.

> you might have a 35-year-old work and have no idea if its copyright has been extended because it was not originally printed with a number

No... if protection is contingent on publication of the number along with the work, then a work printed without a number is unprotected. There is no concept of "extending copyright" on a work that isn't even copyrighted.