News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by bane on Saturday February 01, 2014 @11:55AM (#7162130)
I'm really into emulation and retrogaming. One thing that concerns me is how these works of art will become unplayable and "die" once their life expectancy is over. The body of work of video games is pretty large now, but I'm worried the body of games we can continue to enjoy 20-30-40-50 years from now will grow at a very slow rate from now on out. This is very different from the movie industry, where films from 60-70 years ago are still very enjoyable.
Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by jowiar on Saturday February 01, 2014 @01:20PM (#7162616)
We still listen to and perform the music of 300 years ago (Bach), read and perform literature of 400 years ago (Shakespeare), and the look at the paintings of 500 years ago (Leonardo, Botticelli, etc.).

Sure, a bunch of the games produced today are semi-glorified slot machines, but most movies of 60 years ago were crap. Most Baroque music was crap. Most Elizabethan drama was crap. Most Renaissance Art was crap.

Quality lasts, and if quality managed to survive a time when conveying information across the world took decades and when literacy rates were basically nil, then given modern literacy, and storage and communication technology, it's crazy to say the quality media of the present day isn't going to last.

It's going to require some work, but if the media matters to people, people will do what it takes to make it last.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by ANTSANTS on Saturday February 01, 2014 @08:28PM (#7164359)
I think the parent's point was not that modern games are not worth preserving, but that the way they are implemented requires an enormous effort to preserve them far beyond the cost of just copying media, that may not be warranted for anything but the most important and well-loved of games.

Most of these mobile games are continuously upgraded, and more importantly, reliant on an external service to implement purchases and access restrictions and such. You cannot just load such a game up in an emulator if the server containing half the code (yes that's hyperbole, it's a smaller but no less important amount) no longer exists.

People have reimplemented the servers for very important online games in the past. Off the top of my head, Phantasy Star Online (one of the first MMOs) and Vanilla World of Warcraft both have fanmade reverse-engineered recreations of their server software that allow people to play the original game as it was when they were released, even though Sega and Blizzard respectively have long since shut down their official servers. To reiterate, they did this with only information from the game client, neither the source nor binaries of these games' server software were ever made available. I can only imagine how tremendous of an effort this must have been for the fans, but they did it out of love for these games and the time they spent playing them.

Now imagine that one of the various free to play IAP games gets shut down tomorrow. Game binaries that worked fine yesterday are now useless. Chances are, no one cares nearly as much as the aforementioned MMO fans (it's a hell of a lot of work, and I'm going out on a limb and saying that skilled reverse engineers are more likely to be interested in MMOs than cow clickers), and the reverse engineered replacement never gets started. The game disappears from history, except as a Youtube video and a memory.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by bane on Saturday February 01, 2014 @02:12PM (#7162923)
Good point. 90% of everything is crap. But that last 10%...that 10% contains everything from "Big Trouble in Little China" to Bach's "Magnificat" (BWV 243).

Same for games, in that 10% we get everything from Super Mario World to Skyrim.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by richy_rich on Saturday February 01, 2014 @03:51PM (#7163351)
Yes, but it took something like 100 years after Bach's death before people generally believed it to be awesome IIRC. There were doubtless composers who were more popular at the time that we've never heard of.

I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just thinking that it'd be better to keep everything and let the future decide.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by coldtea on Saturday February 01, 2014 @12:16PM (#7162229)
>This is very different from the movie industry, where films from 60-70 years ago are still very enjoyable.

They are to us, but the average movie goer would need restraints to sit and watch them.

With the BS emphasis we had for over 2 decades on special effects, fast editing, CGI, and teenage-fantasy kind of material, the adult oriented movies of yesteryear are only left for cinephilles.

For the average 15-25 year old today, they'd be unbearable to watch, whereas back in the day they watched them just fine.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by nitrogen on Saturday February 01, 2014 @01:01PM (#7162504)
So? Who cares if the average 15-25 year old does something? The average 15-25 y/o may not visit a museum, attend an orchestra, or have a tenured professorship, but all those things still exist. Plus, 20 years from now, those kids will be adults who might want to play the games of their youth.
Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by coldtea on Sunday February 02, 2014 @02:28AM (#7165229)
>So? Who cares if the average 15-25 year old does something?

Well, since we were talking about old movies, people who value them, and who would have liked to see them being watched by newer generations and surviving into the future, do.

>The average 15-25 y/o may not visit a museum, attend an orchestra, or have a tenured professorship, but all those things still exist.

Just barely.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by lstamour on Saturday February 01, 2014 @01:05PM (#7162530)
I dunno. I fail to see how the Marx Bros are any less entertaining today. Or the 60+ year old Nineteen Eighty Four, is that unbearable to read (well, yes, but that's beside the point). Old doesn't mean unwatchable, it means different. Hopefully future games and content won't entirely be rentals, as some things are worth keeping and replaying for free...
Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by bane on Saturday February 01, 2014 @02:20PM (#7162956)
I can see both sides of it and I'll posit this argument. 15-25 year olds of any age may never really get old media, but as they grow older, they may find an appreciation of them. I know that many movies and books and things that I loathed as a youngster I grew up to appreciate and even enjoy as I grew older.

For example, I've grown to really enjoy old classic radio shows, decades after they've stopped being commonplace.

Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by swombat on Saturday February 01, 2014 @02:48PM (#7163086)
I don't think the really bad IAPs/scams like Clash of Clans or Farmville or this Dungeon Keeper incarnation can really be considered works of art...
Re:How in-app purchases have destroyed the game industry by bane on Saturday February 01, 2014 @03:20PM (#7163213)
I don't totally disagree with you, but suppose IAP was not an avenue these could have gone. They may have been better designed games as a result.