News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by nostrademons on Monday July 20, 2009 @08:47PM (#715510)
It's not really - do anything in avionics or health care and you have to follow similar procedures.

The mistake is to believe that making planes fly through the air and making 140-character text messages fly through the net are the same problem, or thinking that one is "real" engineering and the other is not. I would not want your average Rails developer writing the code that keeps my flight flying. I also would not want your average avionics software developer writing consumer web software.

Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by tjr on Monday July 20, 2009 @09:24PM (#715539)
I've worked on both avionics software and web software, and you're spot-on correct... the procedures and development styles are entirely different. Avionics development is laced with simple, easily-understandable coding techniques shrouded in requirements, verification, and paperwork. And yes, real people do sign off on things. Unlike in the web world, where you can whip out changes every day, it's not uncommon for there to be a delay of months (or even years) between writing a piece of code and deployment. We were working on software for the Boeing 787 about five years ago...
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by torpor on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @05:55AM (#715987)
I work on SIL-4 systems for Rail (Transportation, not fancy web framework de-jour) applications .. the code I spent a year slaving over to ensure it is as bug-free as can possibly be rendered, won't ship to our customers until next year, and even they won't be deploying it in field for another year or so after they get done with their own tests. So, I'm looking at having to support that code from a year ago, 3 to 5 years from now.

Thats why, its good code. ;)

Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by gaius on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @04:44AM (#715952)
Interestingly making 160-char message fly through the air is pretty reliable, because that bit of the system was implemented by real engineers.
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by eru on Wednesday July 22, 2009 @06:42AM (#717650)
Though it can take a long time to get through, as it only uses spare capacity.
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by rbanffy on Monday July 20, 2009 @11:37PM (#715680)
" I also would not want your average avionics software developer writing consumer web software."

I am not sure of that part. I think I would like to be able to trust my software just a little more. Not working properly is NOT OK.

Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by nostrademons on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @01:33AM (#715778)
There's a cost to software that always works correctly. If one of the avionics software engineers I've worked with tried to write a consumer webapp, he'd work so slowly that by the time the app was done, I wouldn't need it anymore.

When Reddit was young, I sent a couple bug reports and feature requests to spez & kn0thing. Within an hour, they had the code done and up on the live site. The cost of that was that their users did the QA, which is simply not acceptable for avionics. But I'd rather have a feature done in an hour that may or may not work than wait a month for a feature that I know will work, but is probably rendered obsolete by developments elsewhere on the web.

Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by Retric on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @02:50PM (#716659)
You noticed a bug.

The system failed.

The fact they fixed it quickly is a seperate issue.

Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by gaius on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @12:52AM (#715751)
He means most people are not willing to pay for their web apps to be as well-specced and thoroughly tested and verified as serious software. That goes both for dotcom companies and end-users who votes with their dollars and simply don't care if a website crashes from time to time.
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by DougBTX on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @04:40AM (#715951)
That's fine for software that I'm not paying for - and how many web apps are worth paying for? I smell a chicken or the egg problem...
Re:Source code from Apollo 11 open-sourced by gaius on Tuesday July 21, 2009 @09:15AM (#716157)
Investors in dotcoms very much are paying for software...