News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salesforce CEO Benioff on How to Fix San Francisco by waterlesscloud on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:50PM (#7154762)
They could both make money and live in the city, which would make the city a better place.

Turning the city into a bedroom community is bad for the city. It works in suburbs because suburbs are designed that way. Sprawl, low density, distribution of goods and services. Cities are not designed that way.

High density produces higher rents, for homes and for businesses. Businesses with high rents can't survive when the neighborhood is only occupied at night and on weekends.

What you have here are people who want the advantages of this city, but aren't around enough to make it worth providing those advantages.

The medium term outcome of this is pretty clear- many businesses in SF are going to go under. Most of what makes SF unique is going to be driven out by cost. What you'll be left with is some sort of bizarre bedroom city that no one really enjoys any more.

And then what?

Re:Salesforce CEO Benioff on How to Fix San Francisco by tptacek on Thursday January 30, 2014 @08:58PM (#7154780)
What advantages are they supposed to be providing to the city? They pay taxes in the city. They are customers for the city's businesses. The eat in the city's restaurants. They have a stake in the upkeep of the city's properties.
Re:Salesforce CEO Benioff on How to Fix San Francisco by waterlesscloud on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:07PM (#7154810)
You mis-read that.

The point is that they don't make it worthwhile to businesses to provide those advantages. They aren't there 12+ hours a day, only at night, when people spend less money anyway, so how could they?

They aren't sufficient customers for the city's businesses and restaurants. Later at night, a bit. On weekends, some. During the work week? Not at all.

And that works in bedroom communities where rents and other costs are lower. It doesn't work in cities.

Re:Salesforce CEO Benioff on How to Fix San Francisco by prostoalex on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:18PM (#7154844)
Wait, wasn't it a few months ago that San Francisco was battling with too many people working in the city, but not enough people living in the city, which prompted the tax hikes on tech companies, which Twitter then has been able to avoid by agreeing to locate an office in an undesirable neighborhood?

Couple thousand commuters to the Valley are not going to turn a million-resident city into sleepy bedroom community with only soccer Moms driving occasional minivans.

Re:Salesforce CEO Benioff on How to Fix San Francisco by waterlesscloud on Thursday January 30, 2014 @09:27PM (#7154876)
Let's check back in 7-8 years. By then it's too late, of course, but the situation will at least be obvious.