News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by aresant on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:08PM (#7148413)
I disagree that people will become comfortable with Google Glass - the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you (that may or may not be recording).

To which the analogy vs. headphones is not relevant.

I anticipate, however, that Google (or somebody) will find a way to make this product largely invisible to anybody but the wearer in the near term future.

Through more discreet projection / camera placement, or future-tech incorporation with a contact lens.

So for a company in the business of printing money, investing in BETAs at this stage to understand UX, function, etc is wise.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by tikhonj on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:33PM (#7148508)
And yet most people don't have that reaction to pervasive CCTV. Which, in some places, is virtually omnipresent and constantly recording. "Smile, you're on camera ☺"

And many people have no qualms sharing pretty much everything on Facebook and the like.

I don't know which way it will really go, but it is really not obvious a priori that everyone is that concerned about privacy, or that society will not adapt to make things like constant filming more acceptable.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by wpietri on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:49PM (#7148969)
The difference for me is that we've learned that CCTV basically never has a direct impact on our lives. I'm sure I'm caught on security cameras 20 times a day for the last 10 years, but not one of those 73,000 recordings has ever come to my attention or mattered at all.

The same isn't true of handheld cameras. When people take a picture of me, it could go places, and I know that. If you're snapping pictures of people, you'll get reactions.

Right now, people definitely treat Glass like a handheld camera. And I suspect they will, at least up until the moment they start wearing one themselves.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by jfoster on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:17AM (#7149572)
I thought your comment was going the other way. The same generally is true of handheld cameras. Can you recall a situation where a stranger snapping a photo that had you in it caused a problem for you?
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by probably_wrong on Thursday January 30, 2014 @03:42AM (#7149643)
Here's such a case: a website [1] dedicated to taking pictures of girls in public transport without asking for permission before nor after [2]. Quoting from the opinion piece,

> “Well, when I saw that I was in a posted photo, it scared me… and then afterwards, blah! But maybe there isn’t the need to post these photos online… I feel like I’m in a catalog for rapists or other sick people. It was quite shocking…”

[1] http://www.argentinaindependent.com/life-style/thecity/chica...

[2] http://www.adiosbarbie.com/2012/05/21st-century-street-haras...

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by jfoster on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:13AM (#7155717)
There are cases, but they are not the norm. CCTV has been abused too, but abuses are also not the norm for CCTV, either.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by wpietri on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:46PM (#7152896)
I regularly see tagged photos of myself come up on Facebook and think, "Christ, that's annoying." Enough other people do that they have built a lot of special controls around tagging.

I've also occasionally ended up in the newspaper in crowd shots. That can be fun or irritating, but either way it definitely matters to me.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by Crito on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:56PM (#7148595)
I don't have face-to-face conversations with CCTV cameras.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by maldeh on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:19PM (#7148695)
CCTVs are accompanied with the assumption that some authoritarian figure is responsible for the recordings, and will follow reasonable and legal guidelines to distributing the feed. Even IP Cameras with live streams to the internet are subject to township / state / federal laws and cannot record near bathrooms, hotel rooms or anywhere where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy.

A closer analogy to Google Glass might be handycams and smartphones, and these face plenty of pushback even without the always-on criterion.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by audeyisaacs on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:02PM (#7148632)
If you're sitting down to have coffee with a friend, it's the difference between a camera watching over you from afar and having a camera essentially in the middle of the conversation.

A pretty big difference if you ask me.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by randallsquared on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:49PM (#7148781)
It seems far less a difference than not having a camera watching you at all.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by rld on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:57PM (#7148602)
It's not the same to be observed by some invisible or unknown entity than to be observed directly by a person. Someone pointing a digital camera at a person is usually more disturbing than a CCTV camera doing the same thing.

Also, Google Glass may be constantly recording in private places usually without CCTV: homes, dinner tables, meetings, etc.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by droithomme on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:15PM (#7148684)
In my opinion, both are equally disturbing. CCTV often though we don't notice, don't have a choice, or can't as easily express, "WTF is your problem" towards the obnoxious person recording us without consent and clearing exactly what they plan to do with these recordings. When buying stuff at the store, the store does not offer my the option of consent regarding their ubiquitous camera systems. However, the hope is that the camera systems in this context will not be used to exploit, ridicule, or manipulate my very thoughts. With a person I am interacting with, the odds are not as good, but consent of interaction is also easier to withdraw without seriously affecting my ability to survive. I can choose to interact with people who aren't constantly recording me, if I prefer.

Myself I like making field recordings of nature sounds. I've noticed though that a lot of people are concerned when I pull out my Zoom field recorder and start recording them during conversations. They generally don't like it. I don't blame them. I don't like it either. So I either record discretely (which is illegal in many states) or not at all. I don't blame them for not wanting me to record their private conversations though, because their concerns and their desires to have a private conversation are completely legitimate.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by coldtea on Thursday January 30, 2014 @02:05AM (#7149411)
>And yet most people don't have that reaction to pervasive CCTV. Which, in some places, is virtually omnipresent and constantly recording.

That's because they don't see those recordings posted around and embarrasing them or affecting their future lifes.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by ama729 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:15AM (#7149720)
In addition to what everyone has said, CCTV are also low-resolution most of time, without sound and a such an angle and a distance that most of your actions are "invisible" to the camera (like knowing what kind book you are reading for example, or even you are reading a book at all).
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by aestra on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:24AM (#7151476)
Most people I believe (rightly or wrongly) think that CCTV are a presence that isn't a threat because the footage doesn't usually live forever, and usually is only used for when something negative happens (such as a crime).
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by doktrin on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:23PM (#7148466)
> I disagree that people will become comfortable with Google Glass - the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you (that may or may not be recording).

A core assumption of this argument is that people won't eventually become accustomed to the idea of being recorded consistently, often without their knowledge or consent.

I can't see why that would be the case. Video surveillance is nigh-ubiquitous in London, and this appears to be both accepted and tolerated. Closer to home (US), I was probably recorded on camera 10-12 times today alone - anywhere from office buildings, retail stores, gas stations, etc. Moreover, I understand that I'm being monitored or recorded in some fashion during the majority of my waking hours (internet usage in the workplace, mobile apps with access to my current location, etc.)

Why do you feel people will forever resist this particular loss of privacy, when we already take some measure of persistent surveillance & recording as a given?

NB : This does not mean I feel comfortable speaking to someone wearing glass. It's unsettling. However, the very crux of the OP was that what we currently consider unsettling or strange is subject to change. I can't find a good reason to disagree with that conclusion.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by tzs on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:58PM (#7148804)
> Video surveillance is nigh-ubiquitous in London, and this appears to be both accepted and tolerated. Closer to home (US), I was probably recorded on camera 10-12 times today alone - anywhere from office buildings, retail stores, gas stations, etc.

Are any of those London cameras, or the dozen cameras you suspect record you in the US, in public restrooms?

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by doktrin on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:25PM (#7149066)
Instead of asking a rhetorical question with an implied conclusion, it might be worth addressing the actual argument.

You're implying that there is a certain threshold past which society will not tolerate its actions being potentially recorded.

That may be the case, but I haven't heard it argued convincingly.

If we are to take any lessons from history, it is that accepted social norms are subject to radical change. What was once utterly unthinkable has in many cases become hum-drum or even the social norm.

Why should this (glass) be the hard line in the sand that human civilization draws?

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by jff on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:58PM (#7152122)
BREAKING NEWS, HN USER TZS CAUGHT URINATING IN PUBLIC RESTROOM URINAL, SHOCKING FILM OF HIS CLOTHED BACK!

Are you expecting Glass wearers to suddenly start leaning over urinal partitions to film you pissing? Or poking their heads over stalls? Both of these are pretty goddamn unacceptable where I'm from, Glass or not. If someone is so weird that they want video evidence of themselves going to the bathroom, and they happen to capture me standing at a urinal, who gives a fuck?

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by tzs on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:43PM (#7152487)
I take it you have never encountered a trough urinal?
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by TheZenPsycho on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:38PM (#7148527)
London had the IRA. Ubiquitous surveillance in london is more socially acceptable than the very real possibility of being exploded by a terrorist.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by MetaCosm on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:31PM (#7149082)
> I disagree that people will become comfortable with Google Glass - the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you (that may or may not be recording).

When personal cameras first came on the scene -- the newspapers tried to inflame hysteria -- ANYONE COULD TAKE PICTURES OF ANYONE! There were pushes for regulation, banning, and people where ATTACKED for using cameras in public. Google for "Kodak Fiends" and "The Camerist and the Squaw" -- these were the old version of "Glassholes".

Society creates social norms to deal with this stuff. See again camera phones... a lesser for of "Kodak Fiends" trended in the press, then we adapted, and now no one even worries about it. It will happens for Google Glass over time, history tells the tale.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by dmm on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:20PM (#7148449)
I've found that in my own experience that depressed people focus on and recall negative details moreso than the good.

This form of selective memory, remember the good things and forgetting the bad, is a primary tool that ordinary people use to stay sane. Something that records everything you do forever has the potential to serious mess with that.

Wikipedia calls it the negative triad http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memory_errors#Depression

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by wpietri on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:54PM (#7148990)
That's interesting!

But at first blush I'm not seeing how it would matter. If I recall rightly, what you remember is partly a function of what you think about. If you're thinking about negative experiences, then you'll retain them. If you think about the positive ones, you'll retain that.

People already have a lot of digital archiving going on in the form of photos, emails, Twitter, Facebook, and the like. Mostly, people just ignore that vast historical trove. I would expect adding more detailed recording not to change the balance much; if people use their archives at all, it will be to seek out the things that they already are inclined to remember.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by hangonhn on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:20PM (#7148445)
Totally agree. I refuse to talk to anyone with one of those on. It's not only creepy but also really unfair. It also throws the whole concern of private conversations out the door. Get rid of the camera but keep the glass. Maybe then we will be more comfortable.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by kibibu on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:02AM (#7149163)
Pull out your smartphone and record them through it while talking
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by 72deluxe on Thursday January 30, 2014 @04:25AM (#7149746)
Haha I think I'll do that if I ever meet someone. That's really funny, it'll keep me chuckling all day. Thanks!
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by hangonhn on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:05PM (#7151729)
That my friend is both brilliant and hilarious.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by aestra on Thursday January 30, 2014 @11:31AM (#7151518)
Weirdly, when I was in 7th or 8th grade I thought it would be a neat idea to put an audio tape recorder (the cassette type, remember those?) in my bookbag and record the audio of my entire day at school. I have no idea why I thought this was a neat idea. I don't believe I still have this tape, and if I recall the audio wasn't very clear.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by sillysaurus2 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:22PM (#7148712)
the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you (that may or may not be recording)

Google should put an LED light on Glass that turns on whenever it's recording, just like MacBooks.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by honestcoyote on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:40PM (#7149106)
People are funny. Probably most do not want to be recorded without their permission, but many of them will think of situations when they want to be the one silently recording. And some of those situations would actually be valid, recording cops for example.

So, unless there is a law, I can't see forced LED for recordings. If Google tries, then one of the most popular apps for Glass will be a hack which deactivates the light.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by colanderman on Thursday January 30, 2014 @05:45PM (#7153879)
Or Sharpie sales will spike.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by gone35 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:54PM (#7148583)
The analogy vs. headphones is not relevant.

I agree. It seems like a false analogy to me.

Perhaps a better comparison would be wearing a lavalier/lapel microphone. They have been around for a long time --yet people still find them unnerving and will ask you if it is on if you are wearing one.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by baby on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @11:26PM (#7149068)
> the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you

What about people with cameras on their smartphones? Every time you see someone on the phone or playing with their phone and their camera is pointing at you, there is a chance they're filming/taking pictures of you.

We got used to it. Things change so fast. It's not because right now we're thinking about privacy that we'll still think about it tomorrow.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by orr94 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:08PM (#7148656)
> the primary negative reaction is the voyeuristic-rejection of having a camera always pointed at you (that may or may not be recording). To which the analogy vs. headphones is not relevant.

That isn't the theme of the article, though. The author was just addressing whether Google Glass would stop looking dorky, not whether we'd be comfortable with the voyeurism. So I think the analogy is valid, and I suspect will be proven true.

Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by blah32497 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:44PM (#7148552)
How about how when people use their smart-phones and the lil camera points at whoever is opposite them? It always kinda weirds me out and I wonder if they're taking a picture. But I think people are more or less okay with it now and 99% of people don't notice and don't mind.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by sthomas1618 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:37PM (#7148526)
I think that is a fair criticism of Google Glass. But I'm worried about my privacy in regards to governments, not fellow citizens. In fact, I think wearable computing like Google Glass could be a game changer in keeping governments accountable. It could be really convenient in recording what you believe to be police misconduct here in the States (instead of blatantly fumbling for your mobile). Or, provided it is affordable, it could be powerful tool to be handed out to people in the Sudan.
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by krapp on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:14PM (#7148680)
But then again, there's a good chance governments will be using Glass to watch us us just as we use it to watch the watchers (and each other).
Re:A 33-Year-Old NPR Story Convinced Me Google Glass Will St... by syntaxfree on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:02PM (#7152164)
Somehow I think the government in South Sudan would just rip these off people's faces.