(That said, good luck to the GP's business disruption plan which will involve paying a lot of money for renting or owning real estate in the most expensive places on the planet, in order to let people who don't want to buy anything use it.)
[1] http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0399.p...
I agree that there has to be some sort of disruption, especially since the trend signals towards a lot more elderly and other people with idle time.
Maybe some civic-minded startup, NGO or other kind of nonprofit. I hope someone wealthy funds such ideas, I'm annoyed that at least in my country much of those services are hijacked by "churches" that are very opaquely run, but give people a sense of community and things to do. I hope for similar secular services (think televangelists).
Example (in Spanish):
http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%A9ctor_An%C3%ADbal_Gim%C3%...
Or VFW halls, Shriners/ELKs/etc halls, rotary clubs, bingo halls, the food court of a shopping mall. I'm not a religious person either but like you pointed out many churches provide space to solve this sort of problem. There actually are a lot of options, for those willing to compromise at least a little.
<= 2 blocks from home
Bathroom facilities
Enough room for tables and chairs to accommodate ~5-15 people
Free or close to it
Completely enclosed, some form of A/C preferred
All that in a high density/high land value urban area. Like the old song goes, something's gotta give.