But DHL is trying an alternative in Germany at the moment: it's a box you buy from DHL and install on your property. DHL has a key so they can drop parcels in there and they will take returns with them. They send an SMS when they open it. You can even share a box with your neighbours. Of course the box has a limited size but for me that size would cover 95% of the parcels I receive.
See http://www.paketda.de/dhl/paketkasten.php (german)
Do we trust our drivers so much we tell you, the customer, that you must be lying?
Do we trust our customers so much we fire (or caution) the drivers with no physical evidence?
Do we fit all our drivers with wide-angle all-around body cameras? Will drivers object to that, like some developers (myself included) object to using screen capture software? What if for any reason the camera wasn't functioning? Do we fit cameras in customers' homes?
I can tell you for sure that in an operation as large as Amazon there is some fraud by customers and some fraud by drivers.
Your comment is easy and throwaway and I think you probably already what I'm about to say but life is a balancing act between security and utility.
The web and history are littered with examples of things that a "hacker mentality" would have baulked at in theory. AirBnB, Facebook, Twitter, Foursquare, Uber. All of these things would have triggered the line "Identity/Physical security means nothing to you does it?". And yet, for many people, they are more than worth the risk involved.
We live in an age where it's accepted that perfect strangers should rent our house or drive our car and yet it seems odd that we should allow a liveried delivery man access to our house. How bizarre.
I'll give you three guesses as to where I go when I do want physical security. Hint: it rhymes with "my own goddamn house".
>Your comment is easy and throwaway and I think you probably already what I'm about to say but life is a balancing act between security and utility.
And as far as I'm concerned, I've reached my balancing point. Well, that may not be entirely true (the local lockbox thing sounds groovy), but giving some dude from Amazon a literal key to my home unbalances that.
>The web and history are littered with examples of things that a "hacker mentality" would have baulked at in theory. AirBnB, Facebook, Twitter, Foursquare, Uber. All of these things would have triggered the line "Identity/Physical security means nothing to you does it?". And yet, for many people, they are more than worth the risk involved.
I don't know about all you hip SV folk, but I almost never use any of the things you've mentioned above, though I realize that specifics aren't really the point here. If you'd like to go ahead and give Amazon your home key, by all means, go ahead. I've opted out of Facebook (shadow profiles notwithstanding) and I'd likely opt out of this as well. If this were an opt-in sort of agreement (and I won't assume that it would be), then it's A-OK with me. And by the way, the "baulked at in theory" line doesn't really do anything for your particular argument. I could say that about anything, really, but it's not terribly convincing.
>We live in an age where it's accepted that perfect strangers should rent our house or drive our car and yet it seems odd that we should allow a liveried delivery man access to our house. How bizarre.
Perhaps you live in that world. I own neither a house nor a car, and if I did I'm fairly certain there would be minimal stranger activity within either of them.
Well, no. We live in an age where a vanishingly small percentage of the population does these things.
As for the renting house/car bit...that's far from widespread (for better or worse).
I literally want Amazon to go directly into my home and leave the goods in there. I want to order groceries on my phone and find them in my flat. Frozen items don't matter - I won't order them, it doesn't matter if they sit for a while. I want to leave a return package in my hallway and have it taken back by someone who collects it.
I know that this sounds entitled but I also know that Amazon's already got the chops to support this and that if they did I would buy a lot more from them (like maybe £50/week more from them). Combined with Prime it would mean I would never want to order from any other merchant either.