Well, as someone that quite likes the idea of things like social security and universal health care, I wholeheartedly agree that it's wrong to falsely deflate one's salary in an effort to avoid paying into FICA. But I guess it has never been argued to me that beyond the reasonable salary, it should be one's responsibility to pay excess profits as salary rather than distributions. I can't really find a good reason to hang my hat on. I think the entire reason S Corps exist are to encourage small businesses since we otherwise take on a lot of risk, no? Too bad that threads get polluted right when discussions get interesting. :-)
Not for nothing, but as an entrepreneur who has been in exactly the situation contemplated by this scheme: avoiding taxes by structuring your income as a "distribution" rather than salary is shady. I think it's unethical. People that don't happen to run S Corps don't get to do it. I'm prepared to lose the argument, so let me concede it in advance and avoid polluting the thread.