News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @06:15PM (#7140533)
In addition to Thomas being right about employee wages being able to "pierce the veil" in many states, they're the people most at risk in this situation, so you owe it to them to make sure they're taken care of. It's the one circumstance where I would backstop a company problem with personal funds. (If your company was also behind on e.g. rent or hosting, on the other hand, that risk was priced into contractual terms, like Thomas said. I'd generally prefer to make vendors whole where possible but I wouldn't lose sleep over it.)

With regards to your own situation: you're in the best hiring market in the history of ever. Reach out to your incubator's network and you'll have attractive job offers starting as early as you can accept them. That isn't the whole of the solution set: Big Daddy G and the rest of the tech industry are hiring like mad, too, and they are also throwing around signing bonuses large enough to cover your last few months of salary nonpayment.

P.S. to other HNers: "And then we didn't pay ourselves salary" strikes me as something I hear from a lot of failed funded startups which magnifies the personal financial risk of doing them significantly without meaningfully increasing the chance you'll pull things through. I'd strongly consider not doing that, again, unless the alternative is missing payroll for your other employees.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by tptacek on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:24PM (#7141159)
The dumbest thing I've ever done in my career was to start a "founders don't take salary" company after earning a windfall from the sale of the last company I'd been at. Most companies fail. That company was no exception. The personal cost was spectacular.

Most HN'ers seem to be in their mid-20s. Something you'll learn when you cross 30 is that time is more valuable than money. You'll never get the years you spend chasing a doomed idea back. If forgoing a salary seems to be a make-break issue for your idea, pick a better idea.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by ghc on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @10:14PM (#7141605)
Yup, if only someone had been there to stop me from doing the same. I poured everything into a failing company because I couldn't bear the thought of failure or working for someone else.

I even put in the money I'd set aside for the IRS, telling myself I'd get it back as soon as a big contract we were working on came through. And then it didn't.

Failure is always an option. The aftermath just keeps getting worse the longer you stave it off.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by nostrademons on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:20AM (#7142079)
I'm trying to understand the context and limits of your advice, in light of the chicken-and-egg problem of getting people to invest in or buy your product before proving it out, which usually requires building something to show it's possible, which usually requires quitting your previous employer so they don't own it. Are you suggesting that forgoing salary shouldn't be a substitute for thinking about your revenue model, which I'd probably agree with? That thinking "I have money in the bank, I'm fine for now" makes you less hungry and less likely to take the actions you need to succeed? That one should know when to quit and should never let dreams get in the way of facts?

Or are you saying that forgoing salary is always a bad idea? If you are, how else are we supposed to start a product company? It seems like it's a worse idea to take investment without having done some minimal homework and prototyping to prove out the market, which usually requires at least building something you can show to customers. It's a very bad idea from a legal standpoint to do that work while you're still employed by somebody else. Consulting -> product conversions can work, but it's often really hard to make time for product development while consulting.

From my own perspective - I started a "founders don't take salary" company when I was 2 years out of college. It failed miserably, predictably - it was a terrible idea to begin with, and I folded it up once I realized I was in over my head. But I think starting it was one of the best decisions I made in my lifetime, because the skills and perspective I gained from it got me a job that paid enough that I made back that year after about a year of employment. I'm now in a position where I have a bunch saved up, and I'm trying to weigh my options rationally. I'd like to avoid making stupid mistakes, but I'm also mindful of how the #1 regret of most elderly people, on their deathbeds, is that they wish they'd taken more risks.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by 001sky on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:44AM (#7142365)
The idea that you should preserve investor's cash is a good notion, but not at the cost of forgoing fair compensation to yourself and the early founding team. In the long run, everyone is better off from this approach.

(1) Good investors run (on average) profitable portfolios, and they are not going to be made or broken by pennies on the dollar from the disposition of the firm's assets in a bakruptcy.

(2) Good founders should have enough 'skin in the game' that the signalling behaviour forgone by avoiding this strategy should not be the make-or-break between succusseful outside investment (or not).

(3) Following up, if (1) and (2) are in place, everyone is best served by having the founding team fully solvent. Preferably before and after the company succeeds or fails. All of the principal founders, investors, and employees want each other to be thinking clearly, rationally, and open-mindedly...with well-understood motives.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by nostrademons on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:54AM (#7142394)
I can easily see paying yourself living expenses, once you've taken investment (or have paying customers), as a good thing. That's basically "ramen profitability", and getting to there as fast as possible is important.

I'm wondering about the part before taking investment - when you don't have any money coming in, are still building out a product (or even a prototype), and have cash in your personal bank but none in the corporate bank. Is it appropriate to pay yourself nothing then? Should you make this phase as short as possible? (Well, obviously yes, but in practice this means a lot of different trade-offs, like picking a less ambitious project that you can complete more quickly, or doing consulting to bootstrap the business, or pivoting to a business that focuses on profit more than userbase, or not doing a startup at all. At what point should you be willing to sacrifice future possible gains to ensure that you have money coming in to cover your living expenses?)

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by NhanH on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @02:11AM (#7142453)
I'm sorry I might have misunderstood you. But if you have money in your personal bank and none in the corporate bank, why would you pay yourself (and be taxed on it) rather than just use the money (your money) to cover the living expenses?
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by nostrademons on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:14AM (#7142661)
That's what I'm trying to understand from tptacek's post. Some hypotheses that come to mind:

1.) Putting money into the corporate bank and then taking it out as a nominal salary keeps you really honest with yourself. You can't say "There's money in my bank account, there's not much need for urgency", instead you see the corporate bank account dribbling dry just as if it were someone else you were paying.

2.) It reduces personal risk in case the startup goes bankrupt.

3.) It makes accounting & record-keeping easier for when the startup actually does start making money, since you already have systems setup.

4.) Minimum wage laws require it. I talked to a (Massachusetts-based) lawyer once that suggested this may be an issue. But then, if it is, how does that square with all the tech company CEOs that take $1 salaries?

5.) It lets you take advantage of certain personal financial products that are only available if you have earned income in a year, eg. Roth IRAs.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by tptacek on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @07:42PM (#7148281)
It's (1). It does more than keep you honest with yourself; it also protects the value of your time.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by dragons on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:16AM (#7144263)
FYI minimum wage laws do not apply to execs: http://www.dol.gov/compliance/guide/minwage.htm#who Massachusetts is similar: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXXI/Ch... "This section shall not be applicable to any employee who is employed...as a bona fide executive, or administrative or professional person or qualified trainee for such position earning more than eighty dollars per week.."
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by mattlutze on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @08:35AM (#7143675)
Re: 4, my understanding has been that the owner of a company does not have to necessarily be treated like an employee of the company, and that salary issues may be different for them. Also, most of those $1/year CEOs are usually earning many, many dollars in options, which I think count for the compensation rules.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by beachstartup on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:43AM (#7142946)
if you take someone else's money, you work for them. and if you work for free, you're a fucking fool.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by danbmil99 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:53PM (#7146791)
The only time a founder should forego salary is before anyone else has invested a dime. And in that case, the paperwork should specify that you are earning a salary but it is deferred, ie you are lending that money back to the company.

Once a real investor enters the picture, if you can't pay yourself even a reduced salary (say 60% market rate), you're not raising enough money and/or you have a sucky investor. Add to the 60% salary with some of that back pay you are owed, or convert the back pay into equity at a favorable (to you) valuation.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by herdrick on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:03PM (#7146862)
I haven't seen anyone negotiate for unpaid back salary in a situation like that. Have you?
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by danbmil99 on Thursday January 30, 2014 @12:02AM (#7149162)
Typically, investors don't like it, and it tends not to be paid out in cash. However, I believe setting your books up that way gives you a better negotiating position when it comes to how low your salary will be, and possibly in relation to equity issues. It's a matter of having that sacrifice (no salary for X months) on paper so it can be respected as a real contribution with a concrete value, rather than just a giveaway that is somehow expected of a founder.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by unclebucknasty on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:30PM (#7147080)
Indeed.

If you ever watch Shark Tank (which has become remarkably redundant), you'll note that each shark has a certain style (no doubt born of his/her own experience/personality).

Cuban is always harping about sacrifice, breathing the dream, not taking a salary, etc. The story goes that if you want it bad enough, you'll make the sacrifices. This has become a common belief that is propagated about entrepreneurship.

I've come to believe that it's absolute nonsense. Engaging in self-destructive behavior does not have to be a core tenant of entrepreneurship nor some proof of passion or dedication. And, at what point is the entrepreneur just a slave to the investor? Some will say, "well, the investor is risking her money". Sure, but she is only doing so because, presumably, she can afford it. In other words, it is a discretionary "luxury" for the investor to invest, whereas it can be a subsistence-level sacrifice for the entrepreneur to go without a salary.

Whether it's a failing bootstrapped company or funded venture wherein investors require an unreasonably small salary or none at all, this is not good. And, for people who go the entrepreneurship route for "freedom", the effect can be the opposite. Not having an income introduces stresses and risks that represent anything but freedom.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by skunkworks on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @10:28PM (#7141652)
I'm not a huge fan of Rich Dad Poor Dad and the cult of Kiyosaki, but that was the first place I heard about the adage "pay yourself first".

I think a lot about that, not just in financial terms, but emotional as well. If you can't take care of yourself, you won't be able to sustain taking care of other things, no matter whether those other things are businesses, employees, personal bills, or loved ones.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by johnjlocke on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:32AM (#7142324)
That philosophy is also in The Richest Man in Babylon and every single book written on finances ever. If you can't pay yourself first, you will never save anything.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by windexh8er on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:53PM (#7141298)
This.

I've been on the fence for years about a few ideas. As time marches on and more risk acrues I feel in an exponential trap of not having the time to make a mistake. In lieu of this I've set myself up to break financial headwind and offer up the position at my, estimated, last opportunity in time (at least for now).

Thanks for the insight. Always appreciate your comments and insight. Although, the credit piece, has to be a royal PitA at times. Luckily I have no issues there at present time.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by ItendToDisagree on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @07:01AM (#7143321)
100% true that you never get those years back. You owe it to yourself to see something out of them.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by ThomPete on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @07:07PM (#7140786)
Agree.

Not paying yourself is fooling yourself into believing you have a sustainable business.

What you have is a source of revenue (not income) and it should be mentally in the "side projects" category. I.e. you should probably have a job and do this on the side.

The stories about people who didn't pay themselves but finally made it are far between and is not recommended IMHO.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by adambenayoun on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @07:56PM (#7141021)
Not paying yourself is bad since it constantly makes you worry - which in turn is really bad for your company. Figure out a fair and low salary you can pay yourself and be 100% emotionally invested in your company without worrying.
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by dclara on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:48PM (#7141280)
Agreed. I guess you mean "worrying about family" at the end.

With investment equity in place, why the cofounders and employees are not paid? How to calculate? They must be paid and reload as owner's paid-in later if the company is running out of fund. If they don't like to follow business rules, then how can we help? Just like there is a wall, you'd like to hit it by not walking around it.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by jeremyjh on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @09:07PM (#7141348)
Isn't not paying yourself simply an amortized investment of your own money into the business? As long as you are getting a good equity deal on that, and you could make that same investment at the outset, but don't HAVE to - why not?
Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by patio11 on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @10:44PM (#7141717)
You're not making the same investment at the outset: you're doubling down after the business has already demonstrated "I'm failing quickly, unlike the median funded startup, which is failing marginally less quickly." [+] In return for assuming that extra risk, you get no marginal gain in equity.

If you absolutely must shoot your own foot, clean the wound after doing so, because gangrene sucks even more than gunshots (though that is not an argument for gunshots). Continue taking a salary. Loan your take home pay back to the company. Get a written IOU. In the unlikely event that the company goes on to thrive, the company can repay that IOU like it repays any other debt.

This is a really stupid lending decision by any objective measure. You're loaning money at a ridiculously below-market interest rate to a company which you know to be failing and where you know that you have zero ability to meaningfully collect from the principals (because moving money from your left pocket to your right pocket doesn't help you). You are not getting additional equity for this loan, like e.g. a convertible note would entitle you to. ("Why not make it a convertible note?" Because your existing investors will go apeshit if you self-deal. Founder equity only ever goes down, never up. That's as close to an iron law as the Valley has.) But it's less stupid than simply forgoing your salary for a while, because there's less downside with the taxman (whether the company succeeds or fails) and the possibility of you being made whole again if the company succeeds.

[+] Not making fun of anybody here. You care about your burn rate and cash on hand for a reason. Cash on hand divided by burn rate equals how many months you have until the business fails, absent an injection of extra capital.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by a8da6b0c91d on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @11:41PM (#7141924)
I still don't get why it's a bad idea to forgo salary in a venture where you retain majority ownership. It sure seems like there are loads and loads of people who spun up successful businesses on sweat equity. Way more than have ever taken funding.

If it's not a capital intensive business and your cost of living is low, why on earth wouldn't you minimize investors to the extent possible? If you've got $300k in savings and cheap digs, your percentage ownership of the upside is the concern, not getting a check for $3k every month.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by patio11 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @01:56AM (#7142401)
We're talking past each other, I think. I don't have any problem with bootstrapping (as my biography probably makes pretty clear) and understand that, under many business models, bootstrappers will go cash-flow negative early on. Not a problem.

At a funded startup, though, you've already committed to "We either grow big or fail ingloriously." If your personal paycheck is the difference between solvency and insolvency, you've already failed ingloriously. That's fine and expected, but don't put your family's financial situation at further risk by deferring the paycheck for the final few months.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by clarky07 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @12:31AM (#7142122)
There were a lot of "ifs" in that comment. Unlikely he has 300k in savings, if he did he wouldn't be scared. Also unlikely his cost of living is low if he lives anywhere near the valley and has a wife and/or kids.

If you have tons of money in the bank and have a really low cost of living, and your business isn't capital intensive, sure you can skip a few paychecks. Even then, the small salary you are taking likely isn't meaningfully impacting the startups runway. Maybe extend it just slightly. And as you are doing it you are lowering your own savings and personal "runway".

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by Swizec on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:20PM (#7141144)
I ran my first startup as a "We don't pay ourselves" kind of thing. Actually mostly me, the other founder was side-jobbing as a freelancer.

I'm not sure how big a factor it was, but being dirt poor did not help that startup. And it just hurt all that much more when it all came tumbling down.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by dclara on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @08:55PM (#7141310)
I think your problem is not because you don't have a side job. It's all about how to deal with partnership type of business.

If you don't have external funding, cofounders may choose to bootstrap the company, but you must have written down contracts about how the partnership will go, and register it with city/county or the State of Secretory. If you don't, you may hurt all of you no matter you all have income or even if you are rich. And the partnership cannot last long without such kind of contract and agreement. Some startups failed even before the fund pending because the partners cannot agree on the equity distribution.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by MortenK on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:49AM (#7142772)
I'm surprised that both you and tptacek seem to think it's much less of a deal to pay back vendors. Say the vendor is a startup or otherwise small company who's survival is hinged on getting paid what you owe. It's okay to stiff them, because we can get away with it legally?

I think it's downright dishonorable to leave vendors hanging like that.

Terminate your venture in time, before you can't afford to pay what you owe. There shouldn't be any difference whether it's an employee or a vendor.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by patio11 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @04:54AM (#7142985)
I'm in favor of paying one's debts, have a credit record which would do a Lannister proud, and would not incur any obligation which I did not have the good faith intention to repay as agreed. It's just that I feel an extra special obligation to employees, on account of their unique relationship to their employer, their (presumed) degree of dependence on that relationship, and a heritage as both a Catholic and a Japanese salaryman which suggests that not paying an employee their due wages is a crime which cries out to heaven for vengeance. (For those folks in the peanut gallery who aren't Catholic or Japanese salarymen: that's a thing for both, and it is a thing called exactly that by Catholics. I'm aware many HNers don't necessarily believe in it, but that doesn't make me believe in it less.)

Vendors do not enjoy this status, although I'd make all reasonable efforts to have a business which I control pay them as agreed. Reasonable efforts includes things like cash flow juggling, taking out debts in the name of the business, or reducing the size of my distributions. They do not include my family experiencing hardship on your business' account.

Vendors are not assumed to be as vulnerable as employees. They typically have far less concentration of income and far higher savvy with regards to the necessity of, e.g., keeping a cushion against the risk of receivables going sour.

I run a small company. I work with lots of other ones. Of the entire set of them, nobody is one invoice from death. If we were, we'd be dead, because we're well aware that individual invoices go missing all the damn time. That's baked into running a business with businesses as clients.

That's also part of the reason why, when I do business with companies as a vendor and not as an employee, I charge a significant premium to what I'd earn as an employee. The possibility of your business going belly up prior to paying my invoice exists. I already priced it into my weekly rate (or your monthly rate for services or whatever). If one of my clients was unable to pay due to their business ceasing to be a going concern, as a responsible businessman, when apprised of that I'd say "Wow, sorry. OK." and write off the debt. It happens. My accountant could probably tell you how much it cost us last year.

If the business owner said "I'd really feel better paying you out of my own pocket for this." I'd literally refuse their money. It's not their family's responsibility to backstop my business' cash flow management. That's my job, and part of the reason why I "earn the big bucks", for values of big which are pretty modest.

(Prudentially speaking I'd probably treat a solo freelancer on a long term contract as an employee for the purpose of "Should I reimburse this guy out of my own pocket?", but as a former consultant, I'd advise any of my freelancing friends to structure their affairs such that they don't depend on payment of every invoice.)

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by MortenK on Thursday January 30, 2014 @01:42PM (#7152485)
A big question in this is what constitutes a vendor.

People who are experienced enough to price the risk into contracts, manage cashflow and not put all eggs into one basket won't get burned from a customers' insolvency.

But that comes from experience. Young people or the typical specialist such as a carpenter or electrician, are not necessarily this experienced in business.

In my view there's no line between such a vendor, and an individual who happens to be on the payroll. There might be legally, but they are equally entitled to payment for their work.

I'm sure neither you nor Thomas are ones to screw people over. But I think there's too much self-absolution of responsibility in startup circles, and your posts initially seemed to talk that point of view.

It boils down to being a decent person and stopping a venture before puting other people in financial jeopardy. Don't cry over the venture capitalists losses. But do make whole the people who have worked hard for you, whether employed or not.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by tptacek on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @10:18AM (#7144276)
The risk that you might not be around to pay a vendor in full is priced into your contracts with that vendor.

Patrick and I both agree with you. Don't leave vendors hanging. But don't pay vendors out of your own personal bank account, either.

Re:We're Shutting Down and I'm Scared by Spooky23 on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @09:24AM (#7143950)
If you didn't mislead the vendors, there's no dishonor in failure.

We all take risks... you shouldn't do what some retailers often do (load up on inventory, then go bankrupt) but at the end of the day, your obligation is to pay the employees and the government their due. Everyone else gets pennies on the dollar.