About as much good as an un-shortened link to a dead site, which is what it turns into after the redirect.
I guess my problem here is I still haven't seen an actual argument to back up the sorts of "behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Digg, and Twitter followed with him" hysteria that's been going around. Yeah, sometimes links die of old age; we've been dealing with that for years and it's not a new or unique problem. And yeah, sometimes people hide nasty things behind redirects; again, we've been dealing with that for years and it's not a new or unique problem.
So what's with the gloom and doom?
That's exactly my point; you were the one who pointed to TinyURL outlasting some of the sites it stores links to as though that were a good thing.
Yeah, sometimes links die of old age; we've been dealing with that for years and it's not a new or unique problem.
Yes, but this introduces another failure mode, where the end target could be fine, but it could be the shortener service that dies. That sure is awesome if it's your content being linked, and you have no way to fix it, huh? At least with regular links, if a link goes dead, it was your own fault, and you can fix it if you want.
And yeah, sometimes people hide nasty things behind redirects
So why would you want to create more opportunities for this to happen?
We've been dealing with that for years and it's not a new or unique problem
But not on the scale that we're starting to see now. You seem to be operating on the premise that things we've seen used in moderation without too much trouble are automatically safe for heavy use, but the Digg thing shows how ripe for abuse these services really are.
If you're going to the trouble of serving up content from your site, why would you disallow the content they came to see anyway? Maybe the concept could work if you had support from higher-up in the redirection process (from url shortening services themselves), but to effectively re-direct from your own page to another "you an't access this content" page on your site will only make end users confused and disinterested, driving traffic away.
I agree that URL shorteners are bad and acknowledge you're trying to do something about it, but this isn't the way to solve the problem.