News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by tptacek on Sunday January 26, 2014 @04:48PM (#7127114)
I don't understand. Richard's point doesn't depend on an Amazon bug that transposes tracking codes. But your point does depend on the NSA redirecting packages to Alexandria in such a way that anyone who checked their order status would notice.
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by dchichkov on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:10PM (#7127225)
Why do you think NSA cares much about hiding their activities from you?

I can tell you a story. Some years ago, back in Russia, as a [naive] kid, I've developed a surveillance system for Telrad telecom exchange [ultimately for FSB]. Do you think anyone cared to do that project in secrecy? I can give you the answer. Nope.

As far as I understand NSA can legally intercept packages and can legally install undetectable surveillance devices. As long as they are not using collected surveillance data, legally they are fine and they do not absolutely have to hide their activities at all costs. Hiding large scale operation is difficult and plugging every information leak is expensive. So they are not necessarily prioritizing that. So, yes, there is a change that we simply see their activity. And yes, it could be just an Amazon bug.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by jonhohle on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:07PM (#7127492)
During the cold war (and shortly after), this type of activity would be exactly what red-blooded Americans would say differentiated us from Russia (not hiding it, but doing it at all). Americans have constitutional protection against unreasonable search and seizure by the government.

These days you could probably drop the country and year and have trouble differentiating tactics used by the US and Russia.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by ewoodrich on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:57PM (#7127451)
It would be pretty stupid for a spy agency to give a target clear warning that their electronics were tampered with.

Isn't the whole point of this program to capture information that the target wouldn't otherwise broadcast publicly?

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by tptacek on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:40PM (#7127374)
Gee, I don't know what gave me the impression that NSA was secretive.
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:57PM (#7127450)
It's going after low-hanging fruit to say this and while the link I'm providing is not the NSA, our government agencies seem to have a real hard time keeping secrets lately.

http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20131220/10200525651/fbi-ag...

Apparently keeping secrets is hard. Human error and all.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @04:57PM (#7127164)
And why Alexandria?

Part of this discussion seems based on a lack of understanding of the geography of the DC area. Alexandria is near these agencies, omg! But the fact is that there isn't much government in Alexandria. USPTO is there, and otherwise it's charming old houses, quirky shops, crappy strip malls, cookie-cutter suburbia, smallish high-rise apartments, railroad facilities, light industry, and other such similar things.

It's roughly like seeing your Mac get misdelivered to Richmond, CA and deciding that holy crap it's been intercepted by Apple on its way to me.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:05PM (#7127202)
The NSA does rely heavily on outside contractors though.

Maybe this page is of interest?

https://www.ida.org/aboutus/organization/hpcc.php

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_for_Defense_Analyses

Spy the address down at the bottom.

And if you wanna get really crazy or are just interested: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbia_University_protests_of...

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:09PM (#7127223)
I don't get it. Why is an administrative non-profit at all interesting here?
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by gojomo on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:17PM (#7127546)
You're using public sources of information to refute theories of where a highly-secret and officially-denied program might operate. That makes no sense.

Whatever office, department, or contractor does the NSA's package intercepts, all public sources will describe it as something innocent and unrelated.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:35PM (#7127623)
The guy I responded to is using that some information to try to support the theories. Either the info is good, or it's not.

I have no particular objection to saying, "this stuff would be secret so of course there would be no information on it". Oddly, nobody has actually tried that.

However, that still goes back to the point I raised: why Alexandria? It's not particularly convenient to the NSA. It's not convenient to shippers. It doesn't have anything special in the way of infrastructure. So it would be quite an odd choice. Possible, but it's not the smoking gun the article makes it out to be.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:43PM (#7127669)
I specifically stated that I was just trying to point out that, despite your claim, there's something interesting in Alexandria.

There's no point in debating speculations beyond that because we don't have any information for or against.

It's just me stating "hey, it's possible" and refuting your suggestion that there isn't anything in Alexandria that could cause concern. I'm only answering a question you asked.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:12PM (#7127237)
Did you actually read the three paragraphs on the first linked page?
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:19PM (#7127263)
The ones that say their research activities occur in California and New Jersey?
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:25PM (#7127298)
Yes, one part of what they do is in NJ/CA. Alexandria is where they're based. I'm not leaping to any conclusion; it just seems remotely possible and they're based there. You're the one saying there's nothing interesting in Alexandria.

Given what the company researches, their history and mission, it seems like exactly the sort of place where this wild theory suggested by the OP could be a reality.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:33PM (#7127334)
The headquarters of a company like this isn't interesting. Headquarters are administrative centers. It's not where you send a laptop to have a bug installed.
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:39PM (#7127367)
A bug is only one of many possibilities for what they could want with that keyboard.

The people in that building are highly trusted whereas the NSA has good reason not to trust the brilliant geeks working for their contractors.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:42PM (#7127381)
Huh? Those people are contractors.
Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:46PM (#7127406)
I'll have to be explicit since this seems hard to understand:

You're the NSA. Who do you trust more: A) (Perhaps the) CTO of a defense contractor that only works for you that you've had a 20 year working relationship with? B) The bright eyed young scientists working for that contractor in a building 3000 miles away?

Or put another way, despite the Snowden leak, I'll bet you any amount of money that the NSA is still in "really fucking tight" with Booz Allen Hamilton.

Or: duh OPSEC.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:37PM (#7127637)
You're right, it is pretty hard to understand.

In one paragraph, you seem to be saying that the NSA wouldn't trust the employees of contractors. In the next paragraph, you tell me that the NSA is still "really fucking tight" with Booz Allen. These two ideas seem completely contradictory.

But I think you might be suggesting that the NSA has given up on the low-level employees, and is now having the executives of these companies do the work directly. Which seems completely ludicrous to me, as no C-level at a company like this (even the CTO) is going to have the requisite skills, and even if he did he's not going to have the time.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by busterarm on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:49PM (#7127696)
You think along the narrowest lines of anyone of anyone I've ever held a conversation with.

Not executives specifically but somebody trusted. That's more likely to be in the building where administration is done than anywhere else. Also you want to separate research from implementation. Your narrow refusal to even consider that there might be an interesting place for an agency to ship a laptop component to in Alexandria has taken this exercise way further than it needs to be to demonstrate the point.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by mikeash on Sunday January 26, 2014 @07:00PM (#7127747)
What you see of narrow thinking is just complete disagreement on how companies like this are structured.

For example, I live a couple of miles from the headquarters of Exxon Mobil. Yet it's about the last place I'd look if I wanted to find a trustworthy person to drill an oil well or build a gas pipeline.

Also, I'm not refusing to consider that Alexandria might be a viable destination for this. I merely think it's unlikely, especially compared to the "military and intelligence belt" language used in the post.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by gojomo on Sunday January 26, 2014 @06:11PM (#7127521)
No one thinks redirection would be visible to 'anyone'. The theory is thhis could be a one-time screw-up, like a redaction failure, revealing a waypoint that was supposed to be secret. (Maybe a label that was supposed to go on the outer box went on the inner box instead?)

I'd agree an innocent screw-up is far more likely, here and in any particular case where something weird happens. Weird stuff happens with shipping all the time.

But since we know shipment interception is part of the NSA toolkit, and the NSA cares about Tor, people aren't crazy to be curious and even paranoid around remote possibilities. And if I were a Tor developer, I might buy all my hardware from store shelves with cash.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by skue on Sunday January 26, 2014 @09:25PM (#7128323)
No, he's saying that anyone who checked their order status shouldn't notice (by design), but maybe that part of the process failed this time.

Also, that failure might be technical or intentional. As I mentioned on another subthread, it's always possible this was "accidentally" exposed by an employee working at the merchant or postal service. The program would require their cooperation. After all, we first learned about the telco spying because telco employees spoke up.

As for whether it's conceivable that NSA would target a Tor developer? A few months they were spying on our close friends and allies simply because they could. If that same mindset were applied to the intercept program, then this isn't impossible to imagine. Just because the NSA and administration has finally recognized their overreach and has started backpedalling doesn't mean these programs change overnight.

Re:Did this Tor developer become a victim of NSA's laptop in... by dchichkov on Sunday January 26, 2014 @09:53PM (#7128448)
It is difficult to predict NSA actions, but opportunistically putting up inexpensive surveillance on all Tor users and nodes seems like a reasonable thing to do. As a developer she is a Tor user and also probably operates a few Tor nodes [for debugging and testing purposes]. So she would be in that group. I think this is plausible. I doubt that NSA would specifically target a Tor developer in US, without court order, as this would probably be illegal. [Although subverting some Tor developers, especially ones who build Tor binaries would be useful.]