Re:US Army Studying Replacing Thousands of Grunts with Robots
by krapp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:17PM
(#7122973)
The devil's advocacy response would be that because robots lack the capacity for malice, racism or cruelty, they can be trusted to bring to bear the force of law more so than human cops. Also that robot soldiers, lacking fear or the clouded judgement that comes from fatigue or moral conflict, and having enhanced sensory and physical capabilities, would cause less collateral damage than human troops. This is a similar (though not the same) argument to the one employed by advocates of self-driving cars - humans are less morally capable than machines by virtue of their organic technological and logical inadequacy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US Army Studying Replacing Thousands of Grunts with Robots
by arethuza on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:33PM
(#7123023)
"The devil's advocacy response would be that because robots lack the capacity for malice, racism or cruelty"
What makes you think that a robot couldn't be programmed to show malice, racism or cruelty?
NB I am not implying that the US would actually do this, just questioning whether there are really any fundamental barriers stopping the creation of machines with such malign goals.
Re:US Army Studying Replacing Thousands of Grunts with Robots
by krapp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:49PM
(#7123069)
I suppose they could be, it depends entirely on their capabilities and AI, but it wouldn't have to be as intrinsic to their nature as it's assumed to be for human beings in that role. Why would you bother creating an immoral robot soldier or a racist robot cop?
Re:US Army Studying Replacing Thousands of Grunts with Robots
by Kliment on Sunday January 26, 2014 @03:56AM
(#7124479)
Because real-time remote control tech exists today, for drones, and it's highly likely that at least at first it will be racist immoral humans making the decisions, with no immediate risk of loss of life or bodily harm, just like it is now for drones.
Re:US Army Studying Replacing Thousands of Grunts with Robots
by ballard on Saturday January 25, 2014 @08:31PM
(#7123393)
The theory of evolution should encompass techniques, politics and non-organic tools as part of more a capable existence that is bigger than anthropocentrism and organicentrism. That the rifle and the soldier are a machine together, just as a rifle on wheels. How the rifle got there doesn't matter but what does matter is the decision process of whether it fires or not. Right now, the ROE for USM legally requires an officer to approve any kill order made remotely (drone strike). That might not always be the case going forward, especially for secret wars as well as adversaries that just want any kind of revenge.