News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by peter_l_downs on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:37PM (#7122563)
Great writing. Who's competing with Blackboard in the educational software space? If they're really this awful there's probably a great opportunity.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by skywhopper on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:42PM (#7122848)
Blackboard bought out most of their commercial competition (WebCT, Angel) and tried to patent-troll the rest out of business (Desire2Learn for one).

Open-source wise there's Moodle (PHP based) and Sakai (Java based).

But from my POV within higher ed IT, my impression is that many of the big guys (Michigan, Indiana, Cal, NYU, Yale, MIT, Harvard, Stanford) are desperately searching for what's next. edX (Harvard+MIT along with contributions from Stanford) has open-sourced their software, I have no idea if it comes close.

The problem with starting up is that to make anyone happy, a new Learning Management System needs to have two things working spectacularly well:

1. An online testing engine supporting both automated grading and human grading with a wide variety of question types and an easy to use test builder.

2. A gradebook tool that's easy to set up, can import and export spreadsheets, and can support any wild scoring system a faculty member can devise (and they can come up with some doozies). It also needs to integrate with any and every other tool in the system, as some faculty somewhere will want to grade every single type of activity students can perform in the system.

In addition to those two baseline elements it needs a world-class collaboration system for file-sharing, plus messaging and forum tools and online chat. It needs to support multiple class sections with unified resources, ad-hoc class groups, and student-initiated study groups. It needs to support fine-grained permission schemes based on classes, instructors, grad assistants, sections, individual students, and groups.

Every file, test, assignment, forum, and chat room all need to be able to be gated access based on student activity so that, for example, a quiz must be passed before getting access to a document which leads into an assignment followed by a forum-based discussion.

Research is also critical to support, and your system will need to be accessible in a secure way to collaborators, guest instructors, and remotely-enrolled students around the globe, in a way that doesn't make the faculty wait more than a few minutes to grant those people access.

All of this will need to be provided in a fully responsive user interface that scales well from 4k screens down to tablets and smartphones, including the testing and gradebook engines. You'll also need a free mobile app that provides all the same funcionality in a reliable native interface on iOS, Android, Windows Phone, Blackberry OS, and more.

You also need to integrate with the University's student information system, and update enrollments in courses and sections on the fly as students add/drop and courses change, and send grades to the SIS in return. You need to integrate with external tools at the university such as wikis, message boards, and eTextbooks; and outside including cloud-based calendars and document sharing tools including Google Apps for Education and Office365.

You'll also want a instructor evaluation system, electronic portfolio functionality, program-level assurance of learning awareness, institutional assessment reporting, user activity monitoring.

Oh and all of this needs to be customizable to match the traditional way of doing business at each of thousands of different universities. Business processes are not up for compromise.

Notice I've left out concerns of usability, security, performance, stability, ease of deployment and upgrading, etc. That's because those are at the bottom of the list of priorities for the people with the money.

So... good luck.

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by icegreentea on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:58PM (#7123098)
Should point out (since it's not 100% clear in your post) that they -tried- to patent-troll D2L but in the end dropped the case. D2L is still kicking and is in use in a significant chunk of major Canadian universities (including mine).
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by krapp on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:51PM (#7122881)
I've never used Blackboard but I wouldn't ever recommend Moodle as an alternative for anything (and neither would my Java professor to judge by his rants about it...)
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by Steuard on Saturday January 25, 2014 @09:51PM (#7123614)
I've used Sakai in the past, and Moodle for years now. (I think I used Blackboard once, years ago.) They're all a pain, but it would be hard to hand-code something that has even just the features that I use regularly myself.

That being said, Moodle has some serious issues with dataloss if a user's session times out (and for a long time, the default timeout delay was just 24 minutes). If someone hasn't specifically clicked "Save" or "Submit" before time runs out (even if they were typing constantly the whole time), then those buttons invisibly turn into "Throw away all my work and make me log back in and start from scratch". It's horrific. https://tracker.moodle.org/browse/MDL-11972

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by thomasfedb on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:16PM (#7123154)
My institution uses Moodle, and it mostly works. Except for the first week of term. Except if you pick up a course mid-term. Except if your course uses online quizzes.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by jeorgun on Saturday January 25, 2014 @09:53PM (#7123617)
As a student, I have no idea how Moodle is from a professor's standpoint, but from a student's it's infinitely preferable to D2L, at least. I've never used Blackboard either, but nobody seems to think that it's appreciably better than D2L, so I doubt Moodle is really that bad in comparison.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by protomyth on Saturday January 25, 2014 @06:01PM (#7122923)
We use it, it works fine.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by fivetanley on Saturday January 25, 2014 @09:14PM (#7123500)
Just wanted to note that Canvas LMS is also open source (full disclosure: I work for instructure): https://github.com/instructure/canvas-lms
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by verelo on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:58PM (#7122673)
From 2006-2008 i worked on a Blackboard compeditor. While back then, people ranging from administrators, teachers to students all hated the system, capturing their market share was a rough ride.

We landed one major university and several private training organizations,however ultimately got squeezed out and decided to move onto bigger and better things.

The issues people entering this market face range from Patents, that in my opinion should never have been issued, (http://www.google.com/patents/US6988138) to their insane license agreements that cost education providers a lot to walk away from.

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by ihuman on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:43PM (#7122592)
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by rattray on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:53PM (#7122656)
Canvas appears to be preparing for an IPO: http://gigaom.com/2013/06/05/with-30m-led-by-bessemer-educat...

We use it at my school and it's great. I also use their api as a developer at EmeraldExam.com and find it to be terrific. They're an open-source rails app: https://github.com/instructure/canvas-lms

EDIT: should also mention lore (lore.com), which was founded by some friends of mine and fairly recently purchased by a John Katzman company.

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by nicolethenerd on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:13PM (#7123143)
Canvas is amazing. I cannot say enough good things about it (and no, I don't work for them). Love their SpeedGrader feature (allows you to quickly flip through your students assignments).
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by 616c on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:45PM (#7122607)
Saw it recently and I am curious how it will pan out. I work for people that would never make the change.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by naiyt on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:15PM (#7122755)
My university has been using Canvas for several years now. It's actually not bad -- so much better than Blackboard was.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by binxbolling on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:59PM (#7131872)
I'm looking for the Instructure of business LMSes... does anyone have any recommendations? AFAIK Canvas is very ed-focused, but I'm still searching for a great equivalent in the business space that's playing David to Oracle or SAP's Goliath.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by proverbialdawn on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:54PM (#7122663)
Desire2Learn [0]

0:http://desire2learn.com/

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by ffreire on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:41PM (#7122580)
The only other competitor that I am aware of is Moodle[0].

[0] http://moodle.com/

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by ericcumbee on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:19PM (#7122768)
We use Desire2Learn. from what I have seen comparing moodle to D2L or even blackboard, is a bit like a space shuttle to a Cesena.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by blueblob on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:42PM (#7122846)
I went from a school that used Desire2Learn and switched to Blackboard and lost my hatred of Desire2Learn.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by ericcumbee on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:50PM (#7122877)
When I went to College we used WebCT. WebCT got swallowed by Blackboard. When I started working for that College we had just finished migrating to D2L. from my understanding its been seen as a vast improvement.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by xtracto on Monday January 27, 2014 @10:02AM (#7130579)
There's also the Clarion/Dokeos/Claroline line. About 5 years ago I had to decide on one LMS for a site, and I went with those ones (Dokeos a the time). It was simple but feature-complete enough to achieve what we wanted. To the teachers we showed Moodle, it felt like a big screen full of confusing buttons.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by thejhnz on Saturday January 25, 2014 @08:01PM (#7123300)
Another one which is based in New Zealand coming out this year. http://mepo.co
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by Edmond on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:46PM (#7122608)
I tried: http://appynotebook.com (open source)

It is hard.

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by nos4A2 on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:00PM (#7122691)
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by efnysien on Sunday January 26, 2014 @12:24AM (#7124004)
Piazza is great at what it does: enabling discussion and making have a rolling wiki where they can talk to course staff about issues with the homework. However, they're alienating me with the career-recruitment spam - especially because it's not optional. Plus, isn't this all the more alienating for humanities courses? If it bothers me, and I'm enrolled in/TA'ing cs classes, it must bother the hell out of humanities majors with classes on piazza.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by shitlord on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:33PM (#7123215)
From a student's perspective, Piazza is really nice for communicating. I have never seen any of the professors at my university use it for anything else. They mostly use Sakai, and I don't really have any complaints about it. (and on an unrelated note, they have complained about getting spammed by Piazza)
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by yeukhon on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:02PM (#7122698)
Blackboard is more than that. Last time I checked (a year ago) Piazza is just a discussion and a place to release announcement.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by rsingla on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:44PM (#7122853)
Not quite. Piazza allows instructors to post resources as well. I've taken a few courses that centered themselves around Piazza and the Piazza course page.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by yeukhon on Saturday January 25, 2014 @09:19PM (#7123513)
What about upload hw? Simple quiz automated grading? https://piazza.com/product/features

Paper comparison?

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by bphogan on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:29PM (#7122807)
Our school switched from bb to Edvance360. (http://edvance360.com).

I have no further comment to offer on this.

Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by sizzle on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:33PM (#7122816)
our school switched from blackboard to webct and all I can say is good riddance!
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by acveilleux on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:41PM (#7122844)
McGill used webct and I thought it was some of the most atrociously designed software ever. Maybe it changed in the last few years.
Re:Christ, I hate Blackboard by benched on Saturday January 25, 2014 @05:52PM (#7122888)
Not really an answer to your question anymore, but this is perhaps a little-known anecdote.

The group within Microsoft that produced Encarta had a lot of teachers in it. After Encarta was retired, that group took it on themselves to create a lean competitor to Blackboard. The effort lasted about 2.5 years. It suffered from a lot of internal political resistance, because at the executive level, competing with Blackboard was viewed as being neither a smart battle, nor 'synergizing' enough with the Windows/Office prime directive. However, what eventually killed the project was the recognition/fear of how much bureaucratic resistance there would be from schools themselves, and perhaps to a lesser degree the tangle of privacy laws. That is, overall it was decided the risk/reward didn't make sense.