Re:Level 3 are now hijacking failed DNS requests for ad reve...
by sdkmvx on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:22PM
(#7121381)
> Yes, it can screw up caches and return unexpected content.
Then the cache is broken. Obviously not getting a response is going to confuse things, but there is a way to send back REFUSED without giving a positive or negative answer.
Take HN's authoritative DNS server and ask it for information on yahoo.com.
They are perfectly right to refuse service to non-customers, but I think it's bad network practice (legally right or not) to return incorrect information.
Then the cache is broken. Obviously not getting a response is going to confuse things, but there is a way to send back REFUSED without giving a positive or negative answer.
Take HN's authoritative DNS server and ask it for information on yahoo.com.
They are perfectly right to refuse service to non-customers, but I think it's bad network practice (legally right or not) to return incorrect information.