News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by crazygringo on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:02PM (#7121301)
Using the example in the article, how is it technically possible for me to Skype with someone, while dividing the stream between two IP addresses (of the two different routers)?

I mean, Skype's going to be sending my conversational partner's audio to a single IP address that represents me, no? How could that be divided among multiple people's bandwidth, technically speaking?

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by dangrossman on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:08PM (#7121329)
It probably doesn't. It can still take advantage of the pooling by, for example, routing your Skype call through your neighbor's connection because yours is already busy streaming Netflix in another room.

My concern would be my neighbor downloading movie torrents on my connection while I'm asleep. We'd need a really strong legal precedent that the person paying for the connection isn't responsible for what others do on it before this kind of thing could catch on in most countries.

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by kaoD on Saturday January 25, 2014 @01:00PM (#7121562)
P2P is not illegal in Spain, so feel free to download torrents in their spare bandwidth ;)
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by gingerlime on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:23PM (#7121385)
Shouldn't this (in a better world), be the opposite however? We'd need a really strong legal precedent that the person paying for the connection IS responsible for what others do on it
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by dangrossman on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:32PM (#7121421)
Should cafes be bankrupted because a customer downloaded some music on the store's wifi hotspot? If you lend someone a hammer and they use it to smash someone else's window, you're not liable for that so long as you didn't know that's what they were borrowing the hammer to do. I think, generally, you should never be in a situation where you're liable for crimes someone else committed without your knowledge and assistance.
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by mbreese on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:28PM (#7121405)
If it's done by routing, then potentially, the final IP address would still be that of your torrent downloading neighbor.

But, the devil's in the details.

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by andreasvc on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:08PM (#7123127)
No, you typically get one publicly routed IP address from your ISP. The local IP address that initiated the connection is not visible to the internet from behind NAT.
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by mbreese on Monday January 27, 2014 @12:49PM (#7131812)
But it could be conceivable that your public IP is being routed through some one else's public IP/mesh router. I'm not sure how the actual packet flow in this case works, and with a mesh it's unclear how the packets get back to the original router. Everyone can't just be connection g to the same wireless ssid or you wouldn't be able to avoid local faults. So, the mesh would likely be able to distinguish which packets came from which subscriber.

Again though, without knowing more about the protocol/mesh they are using, it would be impossible to know.

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by andreasvc on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @06:59AM (#7136565)
Not really. Consumer ISPs hand out specific IPs to their clients and will only route traffic for those clients. If they'd start accepting arbitrary internet traffic from you you could simply start your own ISP ...

So the mesh stuff has to happen behind NAT, on local IPs.

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by mbreese on Tuesday January 28, 2014 @05:20PM (#7140205)
This isn't your typical consumer ISP. Since they control the hardware, they could setup the mesh in some interesting ways. I'm not suggesting that they would accept arbitrary internet traffic, but you could see the routers accepting traffic from other peers in the mesh.
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by brk on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:15PM (#7121359)
The article is very light on technical details, and tries to imply some advanced things with the whole "mesh network" terminology.

In almost every product like this I've seen, it's not load-sharing a single session (like a Skype call) across multiple Internet connections, but instead sharing/routing particular sessions to particular networks.

Skype for instance is relatively low-bandwidth, but latency sensitive. Downloads are high bandwidth, and less concerned with latency (within reason). The router can make decisions, most likely based on the protocols and/or ports of the session, and route each session to the most appropriate outbound Internet connection.

You can aggregate multiple pipes into one larger "bonded" connection, but this would generally require equipment on both ends of that connection. Technically, feasible, but most likely not in this case.

They could also use the mesh network to route some packets, or segments (eg: bunch of packets in a row) to the best outbound pipe, which would be selected based some continuous ping tests (in essence). You could probably make that happen with transparency to the end user, even in Skype.

In the end, from the very limited info, this sounds like the next rev of basic multi-homed "load sharing" routers that have been around forever, just with a new twist.

Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by ballard on Saturday January 25, 2014 @09:01PM (#7123470)
Yeah. Free mesh networks like Mt View Google WiFi perform badly because they're constantly reforwarding to a tiny, low-bandwidth pipe. It's tragedy of the commons also, it only takes one jerk on a poorly QoSed network to hog up all the donated bandwidth.
Re:BeWifi lets you steal your neighbor’s bandwidth when they... by p1mrx on Saturday January 25, 2014 @08:49PM (#7123445)
If you assume that datacenter bandwidth is cheap and the last mile is expensive, then this problem can be trivially solved by tunneling all of your traffic through an IP address hosted at a nearby datacenter.

Unfortunately it's difficult to achieve this sort of innovation on a large scale, because we don't have enough IPv4 addresses, and everyone's dragging their feet on the IPv6 upgrade.