Re:Dispelling Backblaze's HDD Reliability Myth
by fatrachet on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:31PM
(#7119593)
A third option other than hit-piece or vendetta would be just page views.
A lot of tech writers and bloggers just write counter pieces to popular articles in the hope to get read, spread and shared by whoever dislikes or disagrees with the original article. It's become very common to see articles like "Why [insert yesterdays top HN post] is wrong/will never work/is flawed/..." on HN and reddit.
Re:Dispelling Backblaze's HDD Reliability Myth
by nkurz on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:51AM
(#7120212)
I'm willing to believe that page views are his and his employer's intent, and I'm willing to believe it would be titled as it is, the level of vitriol in the content makes me think there must be something more.
Re:Dispelling Backblaze's HDD Reliability Myth
by notacoward on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:33PM
(#7119733)
Data-storage stickler, indeed. He has been in the storage industry for barely over a year, with no achievements of note. Before that he was a restaurant manager. He's not just making an appeal to authority, but an appeal to risible authority. Whatever the flaws in Backblaze's data might be, it's still data and that wins over completely empty blathering.
Here's the article's conclusion:
The data from Backblaze should not influence a purchasing decision by any consumer, regardless of what type of drive they are purchasing. The innumerable variables, and lack of documentation, ensures the results are unreliable. Even for the winners, the results aren't good; the failure rates are exponentially higher than those observed in the real-world. One should question whether these companies could survive financially with the massive warranty return rates in real-world scenarios.
And here is some of the logic:
It is the release of the data, in handy charts and graphs that encourage misrepresentation, which brings out the data-storage stickler in me. HDD manufacturers spend billions of dollars in R&D, and their labs are designed to characterize and measure the reliability and endurance of their storage solutions.
This last line converted from to "undecided" to "paid propaganda", as I doubt that vendettas come with such clearly presented "suggested talking points". It's worth reading if just to see such a stunning example of the art form.