News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by rhubarbcustard on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:31PM (#7117767)
I totally get all the snarky comments and dislike for the porn filter but as a father of a 11-year-old girl who surfs the web I am 100% behind the idea of regulating material that is not suitable for kids. The current filter may or may not work but the idea is sound and I'd like to think that the politicians who are putting the filter into place are doing so for the right reasons, i.e. to protect innocent eyes.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by sillysaurus2 on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:37PM (#7117812)
She's probably not as innocent as you'd like to believe, and she's probably tougher than you give her credit for. She also has a basic human right to access information.

Please try to see that restricting information when someone is young deforms their worldview for the rest of their life. We as parents hope that the deformation is a positive one, but this isn't necessarily so. We're biased into thinking we've made positive choices for our children regardless of any evidence to the contrary. The bias is hardwired, and unless we take conscious steps to evaluate whether our behavior makes sense then it's easy to get swept up in a "think of the children" argument.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by rhubarbcustard on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:52PM (#7117926)
Totally agree with you but I'm sure you'd agree that watching porn is not something that a 11-year-old should be doing? She is more or less free to browse what she wants, she reads Wikipedia articles, reads the news etc etc but I can't see how viewing porn would be good for her worldview?
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by Crito on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:15PM (#7118097)
If she is actively seeking it out, there really are no technical solutions that you can use to stop her (short of taking all electronics from her). She'll find a way around any filter. If that is the sort of situation that you're in, sitting down with her and having a talk is really the only workable solution.

If the concern is accidentally viewing porn... well, I have a few thoughts on that:

1) How often does that actually happen? My office does not have content filters on the internet, yet I have never accidentally viewed porn at work. I can't actually remember the last time I accidentally viewed porn at work. I strongly suspect that 95% of the "accident" cases are excuses that people make when they get caught.

2) If the concern is popups and she won't stop going to shady sites that have porn popups, use adblock. Problem solved. Also, tell her not to go to those sites, before you get the UK equivalent of a DMCA notice from your ISP...

3) Accidentally viewing a few naked people in popups is probably not going to damage her worldview. Would it be good for it? No. But I don't think it will cause any damage either.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by astrobe_ on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:36AM (#7120618)
It's the same logic as with DRM: it won't prevent anybody from doing what they want, but it will stop a significant part of them.

Right now websites have no way not to deliver inappropriate contents. The best they can do is to ask "are you 18+?" (see for instance Reddit), which a 3 years old could bypass.

A basic protection against accidental view and/or kids a bit too curious could be as simple as:

A) Have the adult sites to insert a HTTP header marking them as such. They have no reason from doing it, plus not delivering porn to kids is a legal requirement in most countries (or I guess so). This is a flexible solution for sites with mixed contents such as Reddit, because the mark is per-page.

B) Have browsers not to show these sites if the 'adult content' is not ticked in the user profile.

C) Make a tutorial that explains how to create restricted user profiles on their computers (so they can prevent their kids from using browsers that don't support this policy).

Alternatively, but it would impact too much websites I guess, is to use a "safe for kids" header and have browsers to only show such sites etc.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by BlackDeath3 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:01PM (#7117986)
>watching porn is not something that a 11-year-old should be doing

Why?

Note I'm truly not trying to start a fight here, but I do try to stay open-minded and question assumptions. To me, this:

>I can't see how viewing porn would be good for her worldview

is not only not terribly convincing, it's also not a reason to censor something.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by sillysaurus2 on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:16PM (#7118104)
For example, Wikipedia can't convey the atrocities which are being committed in Syria as we speak. Videos can. Such a video may be the spark to convince her to pursue a path of providing humanitarian aid to war-torn countries. But such a motive won't come about if her information inflow is restricted to morally neutral content.

It's admittedly unlikely, but on the other hand, it's just one example. Everyone should be free to parent how they see fit, but it's probably important to spend time meditating on the full implications of taking actions that align with our own preconceived moral systems. Such actions often have unforeseen consequences, and it's so easy to convince ourselves that the good outweighs the bad when we really have no way of knowing.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by Crito on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:44PM (#7118701)
It is kind of interesting that Wikipedia articles on war crimes and atrocities seem to typically be rather tame, while I am hard-pressed to find an article about a disease does not have photographs that make me want to vomit in my mouth.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by prawks on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:12PM (#7118064)
I think children's worldview is largely determined by how their parents teach them (usually indirectly) how to internalize information they absorb and encounters they have.

What would your 11-year-old do if she saw porn? How would she think about it? How would it affect her worldview? Would it really be negative?

How would you have reacted at that age? Would it have changed your worldview in a negative way? What kinds of information does she not have access to that she should? When should she be sexually educated?

Just some things to think about.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by DanBC on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:09PM (#7118471)
I'm uncomfortable with the idea of an eleven year old girl getting access to "bukkake bitch anal gape slut".

Can you understand how that is different from "access to information"?

This post makes you sound deranged. Unless you're just talking about pointless filtering of wikipedia articles?

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by BlackDeath3 on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:20PM (#7118559)
This topic is uncomfortable. When I suggest that maybe 11-year-old girls should have access to pornography, I feel like a fucking creep. But you know what? That doesn't make me wrong.

Often, it's the most obvious and deep-set assumptions that need to be challenged most. Above all, I'd appreciate it if you'd spend less time calling other people deranged, and more time civilly arguing your case.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by DanBC on Saturday January 25, 2014 @04:10AM (#7120332)
Many countries have age restrictions for accessing items - alcohol, pornography, tobacco, right to vote, ability to consent to sex.

Do you agree that those restrictions aim to serve a useful purpose? (We can ignore flaws in implementation here because we're just talking about the principle of restriction). You might agree or disagree on some of the restrictions but do you even agree with the general practice of restricting some things from children?

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by BlackDeath3 on Saturday January 25, 2014 @07:23AM (#7120601)
>Many countries have age restrictions for accessing items - alcohol, pornography, tobacco, right to vote, ability to consent to sex.

I'm aware of that. That fact alone (that some restrictions are widely-adopted) doesn't justify them.

>...do you even agree with the general practice of restricting some things from children?

First, I think that "children" needs a more rigid definition. And of course my response varies depending on the particular restriction (as you've already acknowledged). But it's not terribly difficult for me to imagine some situation involving some child which I would find undesirable in some way.

And because I can easily see your vague, unfocused question leading a bit more off-topic than I'd prefer to stray, I think I'll leave it at that.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by king_jester on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:27PM (#7118598)
Having the possibility to access something doesn't mean someone will go find it or come across it. The flip side of this is that the filter, by being imperfect, will probably block something non-pornographic that may be relevant to her as 11 is getting close to the age where solid, factual information about sex and development are helpful.

> Can you understand how that is different from "access to information"?

There is no difference. Access to undesire-able or icky information is no different from access to desire-able information when it comes to filter software, what is blocked is blocked.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by MichaelGG on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:47PM (#7118319)
I've got a daughters aged 7 and 5. They've had unfettered connectivity all their lives. I'm far more concerned about them finding crap material that "suitable" for kids, such as most of Netflix's kids category. I'm much more worried that they're drawn into watching crappy cartoons or playing dumb Flash games. Companies invading their privacy is far more a threat than some random porn site injecting an ad somewhere.

My 5-yr-old says she's looking forward to playing Go online with her own account. I'm not in the slightest bit worried that she's at risk by being in the chatrooms on KGS. Both girls like Reddit (/r/roomporn and /r/aww and stuff like that).

My kids don't need the government protecting their innocent eyes. They need intelligence on how to understand what they're doing, and the drive to inquire and be open about things bothering them.

It's like parents that worry about their kids going somewhere because of "pedophiles", yet have no problems driving them many miles each day, which is absolutely a higher risk to their safety. These parents are not acting rationally, they are not improving safety, they just feel like they're doing something.

What's the real threat model that I'm trying to prevent as a parent? Kids viewing porn? Really? As my kids age, if they decide they want to start watching porn, I hope we're able to speak intelligently about it. Sexual maturity can be difficult for people, and porn is only one small aspect of the whole thing.

So what's the real threat? People attacking them? But retarded URL filters won't help. And teaching them general savvy and critical thinking will help more against that threat, and in life in general.

I'm not sure what threat a stupid filter is supposed to address. In 3 decades, I haven't accidentally run into any life-scaring materials on the Internet (or BBSes), and if I actively wanted to find something, I'd find it regardless of restrictions.

The only filters I've wished for is to remove "dumb" content, but that's just my failing as a parent to get my children engaged with more intelligent stuff.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by scott_karana on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:44PM (#7117874)
Okay, so install a filter yourself. Alternatively, opt IN to a filter.

Why impose your choice as the default on an entire nation?

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by a-priori on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:50PM (#7117908)
I get that concern, and it's your prerogative as the parent to limit what your daughter can access on the Internet.

What I don't get is delegating this to the government rather than using something that's under your control.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by vfclists on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:21PM (#7118141)
If you don't want your children to watch porn you are supposed to subscribe to a service which keeps lists of websites which offer or are believed to offer porn and block them in your router, without your ISP or the government's involvement. These services have existed for a long time, but it looks like the governments want to get involved for surveillance purposes.

It is your router which is supposed to be doing that, not your ISP. What you are essentially doing is giving the government and the ISP an excuse to monitor the your interests and communications and those of your family, which they would in any case, only in this instance you have given them your explicit permission.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by SixSigma on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:47PM (#7117887)
Shouldn't you be paying for a cleanfeed connection for your home broadband then instead of having the govt. back hand it onto everyone?
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by NAFV_P on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:40PM (#7117831)
> I totally get all the snarky comments and dislike for the porn filter but as a father of a 11-year-old girl who surfs the web I am 100% behind the idea of regulating material that is not suitable for kids.

Does the filter protect children from "cyberbullying"?

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by Adirael on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:39PM (#7118986)
It protects them from learning about sex. That will work wonders for teen pregnancy rates.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by NAFV_P on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:20PM (#7119390)
Back in my day the best place to learn about sex was the school canteen.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by k-mcgrady on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:58PM (#7118791)
I can understand why you feel that way - but how about taking responsibility and regulating your daughter's use of the internet? It doesn't seem that difficult to me. Monitor her browsing on the home computer (an 11 year old doesn't need their own private PC); if she has a smartphone disable the browser and app store (same applies on a tablet) and take advantage of the parental controls. This is probably also going to be a lot more reliable than trusting our incompetent government to do a good job.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by wvenable on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:48PM (#7118332)
You should be regulating that material and there are many ways of doing it from limiting access to the computer to when you are physically present to all kinds of software solutions. There is no reason for the government to be involved nor should they be determining what is blocked. You should be doing that.
Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by IanCal on Saturday January 25, 2014 @08:02AM (#7120668)
> There is no reason for the government to be involved

They aren't.

> nor should they be determining what is blocked

They aren't.

> You should be doing that

He is.

The government has pushed the ISPs to offer a software filter for free to all customers. When signing up you get the choice to either have or not have it. BT for example have two buttons, one for "yes please, free filter thanks" and one for "nope, I'll handle this". It can also be turned off at any time by the account holder.

Re:UK porn filter blocks League of Legends update by JackpotDen on Monday January 27, 2014 @11:03AM (#7130999)
Then buy a netfilter. They're about £20.