News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jimktrains2 on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:16PM (#7116988)
> Stallman wants you to use Free software because it's free-as-in-ideology, not because it necessarily works well or does what you want.

Though, the point is, you can make free software work the way you want or work better. You're _allowed_ to. That isn't necessarily the case with other software; that is the point of free software.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by pmr_ on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:46PM (#7117433)
You are correct in that the license is free, but it isn't a copyleft license.

This is a purely political decision: RMS wants gcc not only to be free software but he also wants it to be unusable to create non-free derivatives thus making it an active tool in furthering free software. clang undermines this because you can create non-free software based on it thus making it a tool that can easily be used to restrict freedom.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by epistasis on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:07PM (#7117583)
> clang undermines this because you can create non-free software based on it thus making it a tool that can easily be used to restrict freedom.

It seems that implicit in this claim is that if non-free software exists, its mere existence restricts freedom. Would that be a fair statement of anybody's position in this debate, or have I gone off the rails?

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:42PM (#7119007)
When non-free software is distributed, it is done so under the threat that the recipient will be thrown in jail if they share or modify the software.

Will the threat itself restrict freedom? Yes. Can threats cause harm? yes. However, so long its not distributed, no one is threatened.

So, on your question, no, its mere existence will not restricts freedom. The restriction happens once it has been distributed.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by shawkinaw on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:26PM (#7117726)
Interesting that allowing you to do whatever you want with a piece of software (e.g. selling non-free derivatives) is considered restricting freedom.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by sparkie on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:37PM (#7117808)
Allowing you to do whatever you want is not the same as allowing everyone to do whatever they want. You can't understand free software from an egocentric view of the world. A non-free derivative will ultimately restrict someone's freedom, hence, considering it restricting freedom is perfectly applicable.

We could debate forever on the semantics of which is more free, but I don't think having the freedom to restrict the freedoms of others is going to encourage freedom.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by _Simon on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:54PM (#7117937)
It's not freedom in any sense of the word. The FSF is at best a fiefdom, but in all reality a dictatorship. Stallmans utopian future is more 1984 than any of the actors he accuses. This whole thing is bullshit.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dllthomas on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:36PM (#7118654)
Your freedom ends where it conflicts with the freedoms of others. At that point, clearly something needs curtailing and the question is what/how. The GPL is one resolution.

My freedom to swing my fist stops at the tip of your nose; my freedom to modify legalese surrounding GPL software stops when it would deprive others of their "four essential freedoms" (in the words of the FSF).

0. The freedom to run the program, for any purpose.

1. The freedom to study how the program works, and change it so it does your computing as you wish. Access to the source code is a precondition for this.

2. The freedom to redistribute copies so you can help your neighbor.

3. The freedom to distribute copies of your modified versions to others. By doing this you can give the whole community a chance to benefit from your changes.

If you don't believe that these are important and should be respected, then you shouldn't be licensing things under the GPL. If you believe these are more important than the restriction imposed, then releasing under a permissive license is not itself "restricting freedom", but all it is doing (compared to the GPL) is enabling "restricting freedom". When the only thing a change does is make a bad thing possible, it's still better not to make that change.

I find it somewhat interesting we have no viral license that protects freedom 0 and 1 in derivative works but allows adding additional restrictions that conflict with 2 and 3 (or don't, which would make it GPL compatible...).

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ZeroGravitas on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:08PM (#7118037)
That's a common misconception amongst software developers, but in fact its not your freedom that's being defended, its the users of software. So let's rephrase that:

Interesting that preventing users from doing something with a bit of software (e.g. selling non-free derivatives) is considered restricting freedom.

Kind of self evident when stated from the users point of view really.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gress on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:13PM (#7119527)
What 'users' of clang and gcc are not developers?
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 25, 2014 @11:29AM (#7121184)
I'd say more than 99.9% of them are 'using' GCC or clang, rather than 'developing' it, even if they are 'developers' using it to develop other software. So they're probably quite happy to have their rights as users privileged over their rights as developers in this particular case, particularly if it stops other developers from ruining things for them as users.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gress on Saturday January 25, 2014 @12:29PM (#7121406)
This case is about the GPL ruining things for these users - not stopping them from being ruined, which is why Clang is rising in popularity.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by NAFV_P on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:40PM (#7119746)
> What 'users' of clang and gcc are not developers?

I use gcc, and I work as a treesurgeon.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gress on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:25PM (#7119849)
Do you not develop software with it?
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by NAFV_P on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:42PM (#7122015)
I compile my C source code with it, or other people's. I don't sell the programs that I write, or get paid for writing them - for those reasons I don't consider myself to be a software developer, most of my peers think I am wasting my time.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:11PM (#7117625)
Exactly, if you read the whole thing it sounds like George Bush

> They have been supported by Apple, the company which hates our freedom so much that its app store for the ithings _requires_ all apps to be nonfree.

> The only code that helps us and not our adversaries is copylefted code. Free software released under a pushover license is available for us to use, but available to our adversaries just as well.

> If that enables GCC to "win", the victory would be hollow, because it would not be a victory for what really matters: users' freedom.

> The existence of LLVM is a terrible setback for our community precisely because it is not copylefted and can be used as the basis for nonfree compilers

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:46PM (#7119017)
Let me just say that your comment sound as Hitler, and we can be done with Association fallacies altogether.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_Hitlerum

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_fallacy

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:47PM (#7119288)
I must thank you, I'm kind of flattered you think I'm that charismatic.

Sorry about the charismatic way I presented my views, perhaps I should have mentioned my penchant for eating the raw uncooked flesh of freshly slain animals to make it more clear as to whether I was intending to advocate views similar to Hitler.

You may want to look into these links: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modes_of_persuasion

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:55PM (#7119782)
Im sorry, my subtle way of apparently was too subtle. I was not comparing you to Hitler, but rather made an association fallacy in order to create an irrelevant association.

If there was any persuasion in it, it was to not use irrelevant association since it do not add anything beyond a appeal to emotion, spun around a fallacy. Hitler, like George Bush, creates a guilt by association while the association is irrelevant tied to the subject matter.

The result thus becomes a polite discussion around the more creative ways of eating meat.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:22PM (#7117110)
If this were true than clang would be considered free software by RMS...

There is more to RMS's version of 'freedom' than just being able to modify the code, the AGPL is a great example of this.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by drcube on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:39PM (#7117367)
Clang IS free software, and RMS agrees. The difference is that GCC discourages proprietary extensions and subsequent lockdown.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:00PM (#7117545)
> I would guess they describe their work as "open source" and do not talk about freedom.

Actually he doesn't....he considers Clang/LLVM to be open source and not free, Clang/LLVM does not restrict users from developing their own extensions and licensing them as they see fit which ironically makes the software not free (according to the RMS ideological software freedom purity test).

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by drcube on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:08PM (#7117599)
Open source and Free software are essentially equivalent when it comes to licensing. The difference is in their motivation.

So when RMS says that, he's saying Clang/LLVM opened up the source code in order help their software perform better and see wider usage. Whereas RMS's goal for GCC is to ensure freedom for its users. Technical superiority is great, but it is not the goal, and may be sacrificed if necessary to achieve that goal.

He's not saying Clang isn't free software, he's saying their ultimate goal is not freedom, as contrasted with the FSF.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:27PM (#7117735)
There's a couple claims here:

1) Free means freedom in the copyleft sense.

2) Free means freedom in the open source sense.

3) Free means free as in beer.

In the article RMS appears to be using definition 1, elsewhere on the FSF site the FSF uses 2.

"In the free software movement, we campaign for the freedom of the users of computing. The values of free software are fundamentally different from the values of open source, which make "better code" the ultimate goal."

It's very clear that "free software" in the article is definition 1, since MIT/BSD falls clearly in category 2, LLVM/Clang is NOT free software according to the definitions used in the article, and therefore the position RMS is advocating in the article is that LLVM/Clang is not free software, but rather open source software.

Yes to everyone else in the world, including the FSF, Clang/LLVM is free software but according to RMS it is not.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by drcube on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:47PM (#7117895)
You're confounding issues here. RMS is in the position of a critic of the US government, rightly claiming that, while your country is "free", it installs and supports dictatorships all over the world. It is possible to be unfree, and not support other dictatorships, like Cuba.

It is possible to be both unfree, and support dictatorships, like the USSR. RMS's goal with GCC, is to be like the mythical free country that also supports freedom and discourages dictatorships elsewhere in the world.

In other words, your software can be free, and yet support and aid those who would take your freedom away. This is the claim RMS is making of Clang.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:55PM (#7119315)
Except the the claim he is making is that free software is fundamentally different than open source.

"The values of free software are fundamentally different from the values of open source, which make "better code" the ultimate goal."

Perhaps you could provide quotes where RMS in the article says that clang is 'free software'. According to RMS in the article clang is a major set back for free software. (because it's better than their piece of crap)

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by kevin_bauer on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:52PM (#7119774)
Interesting! The last time i looked, almost 100% of all compiled software of the linux-franchise was gcc-compiled, even a large portion of iOS and android software is gcc-compiled, and it doesn't stop there!

Furthermore which compiler-suite served as so long so good in the "dark" pre-LLVM ages?

Biting the hand, which feeds you comes to mind...

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by _jwo_ on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:58PM (#7119483)
https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html

http://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html

clang is "free software" according to his own definition. It is entirely possible for a specific free software program to be a setback to the goals of the free software movement. His position is that copyleft licenses (very often, and certainly in this specific case) advance the goal of freedom more effectively than non-copyleft licenses. The differing values in this case basically amounts to whether one considers it worth using a copyleft license to ensure that the software being used remains free, or whether one considers it a drawback that a copyleft license may prevent it being used in proprietary software.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jamesaguilar on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:08PM (#7117598)
Nope. The NCSA license is considered a free software license and is GPL compatible according to the FSF. http://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:18PM (#7117669)
That's fucking great, my uncle bob thinks it is too, but we're talking about RMS not the FSF.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by drcube on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:24PM (#7117702)
Do you even know who Richard Stallman is?
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:29PM (#7117755)
Yes, I just imagined that despite his polemic nature there were still other people who could put up with dealing with him who also were part of the FSF and therefore the FSF could hold positions divergent from those of RMS.

If the FSF consists solely of the opinions of RMS then I retract the previous statement and would say that the page mentioned expresses an opinion inconsistent with what is expressed in the email.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jamesaguilar on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:06PM (#7118449)
Generally speaking, the FSF and RMS agree. Nothing in the thread is inconsistent with this. RMS observes that the NCSA isn't copyleft, which is true, but that's a different dimension than free versus non-free.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:55PM (#7119320)
But not different than free vs. open source.

"The values of free software are fundamentally different from the values of open source, which make "better code" the ultimate goal."

Clang wants to make a great compiler, they chose the NCSA license to facilitate that, according to the article makes it open source software and not 'free software' rather than 'unfree software'

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by jamesaguilar on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:31PM (#7119415)
Values and the question of whether a given license meets RMS's technical requirements for being free software are also two different metrics. He even explains that in this email. OSS puts an emphasis on the practical benefit of open source, whereas free software emphasizes the principle. And RMS never calls Clang nonfree in this email, he talks about nonfree derivatives of Clang.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:16PM (#7121902)
So clang according to RMS is free as in freedom software that harms the free software movement because their unconcerned about freedom, rather than open source software that harms the free software movement because they are unconcerned about freedom.

I get you now, makes perfect sense.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by com2kid on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:52PM (#7118362)
Clang/LLVM does not restrict users from developing their own extensions and licensing them as they see fit which ironically makes the software not free (according to the RMS ideological software freedom purity test).

This restricts users freedom, that is his point.

GPL is not about the rights of the programmer, it is about the rights of the end user.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gress on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:16PM (#7119537)
The end users of gcc and clang are programmers.