News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by octo_t on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:46PM (#7116611)
Is it bad I just don't care that LLVM has enabled non-free software? Because it has done a h*ck of a lot for opensource software. New languages, new compilers, new optimisers, new IDEs have sprung up around an impressive framework.

I also don't understand how LLVM enables non-free software any more than binutils does. I can do:

  binutils/cat my_file | my_incredibly_none_free_program | binutils/grep my_pattern
which is essentially how LLVM works.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by thinkpad20 on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:54PM (#7116669)
You feel the need to censor "heck"?

Seriously though, I agree. Stallman here seems to be adopting almost a religious argument, not a pragmatic one. He even announces a refusal to use Skype because it's not free software. If he prioritizes freedom over everything else, then more power to him, but to me talking about who "wins" and "loses" on some kind of arbitrary scale of freedom does not make a compelling case against the use of excellent tools like Clang/LLVM.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by pachydermic on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:25PM (#7117200)
Dude. rms founded the freaking FSF. If he doesn't support free software, then what the hell is he doing? I think what he wrote here makes total sense, even if I use tons of nonfree software myself. I value convenience and performance more than rms does - to him, freedom is much more important.

I think his argument is just that the whole point of GNU and the FSF is to make free software - if they compromised on that, then what would they stand for? And I think that argument makes perfect sense.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by thinkpad20 on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:04PM (#7117567)
I understand that he needs and wants to support the cause of free software, but you can do that without making the hyperbolic statements he is making. Being as ideologically rigid as he is can be counter-productive, as people like me are less likely to take his arguments seriously if they seem to be founded more on dogma than sound arguments.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gtirloni on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:02PM (#7117554)
You've got to admire RMS for that. In the previous email, ESR is essentially saying "GCC is doomed if it doesn't change, it will be legacy" and RMS response is one of no compromises.

I respect that, even though I disagree almost completely and have no alignment with what the FSF proposes.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by zwieback on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:04PM (#7116756)
I think that's the function of Stallman and what he will be remembered as: an absolute that's useful to measure your own position against.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by smrtinsert on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:42PM (#7117398)
I agree. Also it serves to be notable so people keep talking about it.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by vezzy-fnord on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:07PM (#7116792)
He even announces a refusal to use Skype because it's not free software.

Which is a valid complaint given the nature of Skype. There's also tons of other reasons, though. Primarily technical ones.

Either way, software freedom is an important goal and even though I don't necessarily agree with RMS in this case, I understand where he's coming from. So many people seem to have some phobia of accentuating the ethical, freedom and community contexts that the term "free software" implies, preferring the more bitterly pragmatic "open source".

That and this is a very typical RMS rant. This is probably the umpteenth one of the same variation, only with $SOFTWARE being Clang/LLVM in this case.

For the record, I love Clang/LLVM and support BSD licensing. For a lot of software, having an open source development model without the deeper freedom contexts is good enough.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ygra on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:47PM (#7117443)
Re Skype: He also suggests just making a normal phone call. Which has pretty much the same problems: It's an opaque, closed system with pretty much the only difference that there are multiple companies controlling it instead of just one.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ochs on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:48PM (#7117903)
I don't think that's true. Phone systems are standardised. There is also free telephony software (like asterisk). The cell phone stuff is more secretive, but it's still more open than Skype, which is completely obfuscated, proprietary and centralised.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:31PM (#7119212)
I would only add that I can own my phone. I can not own my own skype client.

The complaint about using phone would be much better suited for 1950 where "the phone company" owned the phone. You called, was asked to choose between 3 different colors, and then a few days/weeks later they came and installed a phone with the clear label that said "property of the phone company".

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by lmkg on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:20PM (#7117092)
> Is it bad I just don't care that LLVM has enabled non-free software? Because it has done a hck of a lot for opensource software.*

This presents an interesting (to RMS) quandary. I take it as a given that he prioritizes the freedom of software over its technical merits (as discussed in other threads). But, even just from the freedom perspective: LLVM increases the amount of proprietary software produced, and also increases the amount of free software produced. Does RMS consider this a worthwhile trade-off? Or does he think that less software overall, and less free software in particular, is favorable to more free software existing and also some proprietary software.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dragonwriter on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:24PM (#7117191)
RMS appears to believe that the creation and distribution of non-Free software is a categorical and unscionable evil, such that anything that anything that encourages it (whatever other benefits it provides) is categorically morally wrong, and anything that discourages it is categorically morally obligatory.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by belorn on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:38PM (#7119247)
In the context of compilers, the harm of non-free compilers are not just speculations. The EU came down with large fines against intel when they did anti-competitive behavior in their compiler. If the intel compiler had been provided with source and under a free license, this anti-competitive harm could not have happened.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ZeroGravitas on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:17PM (#7118877)
There a bunch of facts that contradict this, e.g. the exstance of the LGPL, RMS supporting BSD licencing of Xiph codecs etc.

His approach is a lot more nuanced and tactical than it is often portrayed.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by dragonwriter on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:16PM (#7119151)
> There a bunch of facts that contradict this, e.g. the exstance of the LGPL, RMS supporting BSD licencing of Xiph codecs etc.

Those don't actually contradict it in any way that I can see.

> His approach is a lot more nuanced and tactical than it is often portrayed.

Sure. That doesn't mean that the long-term goal isn't as I've described it (and, in fact, RMS has pretty explicitly said it is for him, though that may or may not be true of the FSF.)

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 25, 2014 @11:21AM (#7121156)
The LGPL is explicitly designed to allow non-free software to be created that uses the code under that licence, and it was created by RMS.

He supported BSD licences for Xiph codecs because he recognised the impact of network effects,

You claim that both these thing are considered "evil", "unconscionable" and "categorically wrong" by him regardless of whatever benefits they create. Clearly RMS disagrees, and is happy to use them as tools to achieve his long term goals in specific circumstances.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by ygra on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:53PM (#7117483)
He even touches that directly:

> The existence of LLVM is a terrible setback for our community precisely because it is not copylefted and can be used as the basis for nonfree compilers -- so that all contribution to LLVM directly helps proprietary software as much as it helps us.

... which pretty much is the answer to your last question.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by thinkpad20 on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:00PM (#7117547)
He assumes that helping proprietary software is a bad thing (well, more accurately, he asserts this axiomatically). However, proprietary software can have many benefits. Many if not most successful software businesses have made great contributions to open-source and the development of free software. I know for a fact that a huge amount of linux development is driven by for-profit companies. If a company can make a profit, make an excellent product, and pay it forward by contributing to open projects as well, it sounds like a win-win to me. This might violate RMS's axiom that only free software is good, but as Hitchens says, "What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence."
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by lmkg on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:02PM (#7117550)
You're right, I had missed some of the implications of that statement. Basically, he considers the additional free software created to be a negative rather than a positive, because it gives an even bigger benefit to proprietary software.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by gillianseed on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:26PM (#7117718)
>Or does he think that less software overall, and less free software in particular, is favorable to more free software existing and also some proprietary software.

You can create proprietary software _with_ GCC just fine, and he has never proposed any measures with which to impose any restrictions on the final output binaries you create with GCC so I don't really follow your reasoning.

The 'problem' with LLVM from his view is that it is easy to incorporate into proprietary software, as well as easy to use in conjunction with proprietary software (through plugins for instance), which means that there is potentially much less incentive to contribute your code back when it's easy to maintain it in proprietary form, which then leads to less 'free' software.

His cynicism has a tendency to come true, so it will be interesting to see if LLVM open source development will continue to flourish or if we will see a slow but steady transition of 'real improvements' happening in proprietary plugins or forked versions rather than contributed back to the open source project.

In some ways we might be seeing it already, last time I heard (which was in september IIRC), Apple had not contributed their A7 support to the open source versions of Clang/LLVM, and are instead keeping it proprietary and only available on the Clang/LLVM versions they ship with XCode on their OSX platform.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by vezzy-fnord on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:27PM (#7117230)
RMS is a proprietary software obscurantist in general and goes as far as opposing that proprietary software even be mentioned as an alternative.

He makes a lot of good points and is very aware, but his extreme ideological dedication is what drives people off. Which is a shame, because he's done a lot to convince and further adoption of free software in government and education, plus there's plenty of things one can learn from him.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by fleitz on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:13PM (#7116920)
RMS has a ideology of what free software is that ignores how much 'free' software actually gets delivered to users. As an example XCode is not free but since Apple can make an ecosystem around LLVM/clang it creates the profits necessary to pay developers to put lots of work into LLVM/clang that people can use under a BSD/MIT license.

RMS has a kind of natural law approach to freedom while most 'free' countries have a limited amount of freedom that people give up in order to have an organization that guarantees the remaining freedoms. RMS is much more concerned about maintaing ideological purity than implementing a less ideologically pure system that may or may not benefit users more.

Fundamentally once GNU code supports clang, GCC dev stops because it's codebase a horrible mess.

Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by themoonbus on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:49PM (#7116635)
No, it's not bad. Stallman is an ideologue.
Re:Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software by mempko on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:28PM (#7117745)
I am glad you don't care. I do care. good argument. cats are over there ----->