There is no such thing as flat out wrong.
Troubleshooting other peoples servers I need to work around many different situations. A '--ignore-dependencies" is nice, but won't cut it as it depends greatly on the situation at hand. Perhaps sshd also has a dependency not just on networking but also on slapd or something. Perhaps I do not want networking, but I do want slapd to be running.
systemd having a better memory than me is, well, true. It doesn't solve my problems for me though. The Windows Registry also has a better memory than me, but I prefer my configs in a textfile I can parse, grep and maintain with any tool I choose. Same with systemd: better memory than me, but I do not really need a better memory than me. My memory is good enough.
But meanwhile the world has made up it's mind and in all likelyhood Debian will be using systemd. So I might as well start the learning curve and be done with it.
So once in a blue moon you want to run systemctl with "--ignore-dependencies"? That's a much different argument than "would prefer to do my own thinking, not have the computer try to outsmart me."
You're right, it's not smarter than you—but it does has a better memory than you. To want things dumb for the 1% case seems stupid to me and an untenable position to take, hence my initial sarcasm.