News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Immunity Project (YC W14) succeeds, they'll offer AIDS... by derefr on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:13PM (#7112139)
Hmm. I see an opportunity here for something that combines taxpayer pay-in with crowdfunding-style pay-out. Imagine if the NIH set some percentage of their budget aside for matching "donations" to crowdfunded science projects, at an extreme ratio, like 100:1 -- so $30k of demonstrated public interest would be matched with $3MM of NIH funding.

That seems, to me, to be within the spirit of representative democracy: for every 1 person who knows enough about X to put their money on the line, there's probably 100 people who would if they had X explained to them.

Re:If Immunity Project (YC W14) succeeds, they'll offer AIDS... by yid on Thursday January 23, 2014 @07:51PM (#7112663)
> so $30k of demonstrated public interest would be matched with $3MM of NIH funding.

This sets up a perverse incentive: the researchers who can best pander to a layperson crowd will have the highest chance, regardless of the technical merits of their proposal (which the general public almost certainly isn't qualified to judge).

Re:If Immunity Project (YC W14) succeeds, they'll offer AIDS... by _delirium on Thursday January 23, 2014 @08:46PM (#7112882)
Yeah, the first thing I thought of with this proposal was: this sounds like a great way to direct $$$ of NIH funding towards researching "why vaccination causes autism". For every $100k that Jenny McCarthy puts towards antivax research, the NIH would be compelled to match $10m...