What makes it so good is that it is only available in a couple of dozen cities in 16 states (almost all coastal states), within any city focuses on wiring up affluent areas first,[1] is a premium product that starts at $60/month (averaged over 2 years), and is relatively unregulated compared to POTS or cellular.
[1] Check out the FIOS map for Baltimore (within 15 miles of 21217): http://fios.verizon.com/fios-coverage.html. That reverse-S shape is more or less a map of the higher-income corridor of the city. The pinned addresses are generally luxury apartment buildings. Also check out the coverage map of Philadelphia (within 20 miles of 19106). Zoom in note good coverage in Center City, particularly in Rittenhouse Square, no coverage in North Philly, South Philly, or West Philly, but decent coverage in the wealthier western suburbs. Follow Lancaster Ave westward from poor West Philly; note the lack of any coverage until you get to Lower Merion Township, one of the historically wealthy suburbs.
They certainly are targeting big cities and the wealthier areas thereof, but I don't see why that would make it better than services from other providers in the same place.
A $60 minimum subscription price is definitely premium compared to the $15-$20 minimum service price typical for a cable provider. Remember, it costs more or less the same to wire up a customer whether or not they buy the more expensive packages, and cable companies are often required to offer very cheap basic service at a regulated rate (e.g. $13.50 for basic cable where I live).
> They certainly are targeting big cities and the wealthier areas thereof, but I don't see why that would make it better than services from other providers in the same place.
If a company is allowed to focus on dense, wealthy areas, it can concentrate infrastructure spend on customers who can pay premium prices for premium service. That's what Verizon can do with FIOS. But cable companies usually do not have that freedom. Their agreements with municipalities require them to wire up a much broader cross-section of the population, which means their infrastructure dollars are spread thinner.
To be fair, the guy clearly doesn't think it's a big deal either. From the article: "I don't mind upgrading to business if that's really all the problem is," houkouonchi told me. "It just surprises me they would bother going after people just to get them to pay a little bit more per month."
I've been a FiOS customer for about a year and I still wonder what's going on with it to make it so good. By all rights, nothing sold by Verizon should be this easy, high-quality, and free of problems. Yet here we are.