News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by sigil on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:31AM (#7107207)
Brand also worried that declaring that counterterrorism officials “have been operating this program unlawfully for years” could damage morale and make agencies overly cautious in taking steps to protect the country.

It's great to have another voice speaking up against mass surveillance. Still -- you're telling me these agencies are in all likelihood committing crimes against the American people, but we need to be careful not to hurt their feelings?

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by gareim on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:41AM (#7107223)
Well, it makes sense that she'd say that since she's one of the two that rejected that the program is illegal.

I've been reading Tim Weiner's Enemies, a history of the FBI and one thing stuck with me. That was that there was a period of time when the FBI was incredibly useless because of a previous Supreme Court ruling that wiretapping was illegal and then FBI agents all began to misunderstand what they could and couldn't do. That lead to a breakdown in communication and procedure between different offices and several terrorists that could have been caught slipped by.

I'm not saying that Brand is right, but there is reason to worry that this could happen again. What needs to be done is a clear declaration of our fundamental rights and a watchdog court that won't let the agencies overstep in their pursuit of justice. The agents have to know their boundaries, we have to know their boundaries, and we have to know that they know their boundaries. The whole FISA court stuff is ridiculous.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by malandrew on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:37PM (#7109655)
It's not hard to fix this problem without hurting morale. Change the primary thing that they should have morale about from protecting the security of the nation to protecting the values upon which this nation was founded, namely the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. Every single agent should know the Constitution back to front, inside and out, and see it as their job to protect it over all other objectives, including catching criminals (imho, we should substitute criminal for terrorist, whenever that person is within the borders of the United States and subject to its laws.). The atmosphere at the agency should be such that any subversion of the Constitution by colleagues and superiors should hurt morale among agency employees.

If you catch a criminal, but do so by subverting the Constitution, you should feel shame, not pride. When you have the power the agency has, it is of utmost importance that values be palpable in the air among staff. Power without obligation to something higher like the Constitution and Bill of Rights will always be debased in favor of achieving concrete objectives.

If we're worrying about hurting their feelings, we're having the wrong debate.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:16AM (#7107276)
> Well, it makes sense that she'd say that since she's one of the two that rejected that the program is illegal.

Per the article, what the dissenters appeared to have done is reject the inquiry into legality as beyond the proper scope of the board's review. Its a fine distinction, to be sure, but there's a difference between a 3-2 split with three finding the program illegal and 2 finding it legal and a 3-2 split with 3 finding it illegal and 2 finding "we shouldn't be looking at legality at all".

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by CamperBob2 on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:12PM (#7111669)
I'm not saying that Brand is right, but there is reason to worry that this could happen again

There is reason to worry that a great many things could happen again. An increase in the number of Zoloft prescriptions in the greater Washington, DC area is pretty far from the top of my list of concerns.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by a3n on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:21PM (#7111740)
Morale in this context is not about being happy or depressed. It's more of a technical term. It's about doing your job diligently and effectively. Low morale then would be shirking, dragging your feet, not following through, etc. "Because why bother, they don't like what we do" and then doing nothing, rather than less or different.

But, point taken.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:50AM (#7107236)
It would be wonderful if all wiretaps were ruled illegal.

It would also be wonderful if all law enforcement officers were required to wear uniforms or identify themselves when in the course of their duties.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by mercurial on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:46AM (#7107337)
What's the problem with wiretaps, as long as you have actual independent judicial oversight? I don't have an issue with cops listening to cartel hitmen. Considering everybody as a suspect, that's entirely different.

> It would also be wonderful if all law enforcement officers were required to wear uniforms or identify themselves when in the course of their duties.

I see that now. "Hello, Don Corleone, I'm an undercover police officer, but please pretend you don't see my uniform".

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:56AM (#7108903)
There wouldn't be cartel hitmen if the thing wasn't illegal and hence profitable.

I have an issue with letting them listen--especially if I'm on the other end of the phone, for example, taking their order for pizza or arranging a playdate for my kids or something. It's the few-hops-away rule that is very easily justifiable that creates surveillance states.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by bostonpete on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:06PM (#7109865)
If you unknowingly were setting up a playdate for your kids with a hitman, I think you'd have a vested interest in having the guy exposed and brought to justice.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:39PM (#7110613)
As long as he hasn't hurt me or mine, what's it matter?

That same logic puts the friends of drone operators in a strange place, right? They kill civilians too.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by mercurial on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:52AM (#7113974)
> As long as he hasn't hurt me or mine, what's it matter?

You don't see anything wrong with cartel hitmen? The kind who lines up heads on the side of the road and torture people to death for effect?

> That same logic puts the friends of drone operators in a strange place, right? They kill civilians too.

Not quite. First off, it's much more likely that your cartel acquaintance will catch a bad case of drive-by shooting one of these days, kid or no kid. Secondly, sure, I'd feel weird knowing a drone operator, but AFAIK, they don't torture and kill civilians on purpose, it does make a moral difference.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dllthomas on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:43PM (#7110157)
But if I was setting up a playdate for my kids from someone who ordered pizza from the same place as a hitman...
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by meowface on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:15AM (#7107275)
Just for a purely hypothetical scenario:

If the FBI identified an organized crime hitman who killed 20+ people and left no evidence other than making incriminating phone calls, is it wrong for them to place a tap on his phone line once they have probable cause that he is a hitman?

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:17AM (#7107280)
Your hypothetical makes no sense. If they have "probable cause" before tapping his phone, that means that the "left no evidence other than incriminating phone calls" must be false.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by snowwrestler on Thursday January 23, 2014 @11:16AM (#7109051)
Ok let's say they have some evidence that is sufficient to create reasonable suspicion, but probably insufficient to secure a conviction.

Why would it be wrong for the FBI, under the supervision of a court order, to tap this person's phone to see if he is the killer?

Keep in mind this is not a broad NSA dragnet here. This would be a targeted wiretap driven by probable cause and governed by the federal rules of evidence. The GP said "It would be wonderful if all wiretaps were ruled illegal," and we're exploring that idea.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by malandrew on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:43PM (#7109697)
No, it would not be as long as there was a court order and our judges have the time and sense of gravity to give each and every court order sufficient scrutiny to determine whether it has merit or is merely a fishing expedition. Wiretaps should also only begin once a warrant has been approved by a judge, any wiretap in bulk so you can retroactively get phone records and conversations from the date before the warrant was issued is unconstitutional. If the person in question kept their own records, the warrant can apply to those records, but to keep a tab on every American, innocent or otherwise, is disturbing.

Personally, I would love to see a two-factor commit with all warrants. All warrants should require two judges to sign off on them, one federal judge and one state judge where the wiretap will be carried out.

The other thing I would like to see is some sort of "cost" that the agencies must bear to be able to request warrants. It should cost each agency money to apply for warrants and they should have a limited budget each year to spend on warrant applications. At the end of each year, to apply for increases in this budget, they should present an equal number of both cases which they would have liked to pursue warrants on someone, but it was deemed outside the budget and cases where they pursued a warrant and got one, but the person turned out to be innocent. Such a policy applies market forces to limit rampant wiretapping and phishing expeditions. Instead they will adjust to only use their warrants on those people who actually should be wiretapped. This would also help prevent unilateral action by a single agent or team, without appealing to another independent group with power of the purse over warrant applications. Individual agents and teams would try to get warrants for all their suspects, but the group with power of the purse has the responsibility to dole out warrant applications according to merit so that the agency doesn't run out of them before year's end.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by arca_vorago on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:18PM (#7109953)
"under the supervision of a court order"

A court order is not a warrant. This is the heart of the discussion you are trying to get into. The 4th amendment is very clear:

"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

If we allow a court order or a subpoena to continue to be all that LEO/LEA's to need to get whatever information they want, they will stop going to the courts for warrants, and worse, they will end up doing FISA style bulk orders/subpoena's.

Bottom line, if you have probable cause, get a fucking warrant, else, fuck off. (and companies should be requiring warrants for access to customer information too, not just setting up a pay portal for LEA's to peruse at leisure.)

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by jasomill on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:24PM (#7110507)
A search warrant is a particular type of court order; a subpoena is another. As far as I know, there isn't really any overlap: search warrants authorize law enforcement to conduct searches, subject to fourth amendment restrictions; subpoenas compel parties to deliver documents or testimony, subject to fifth amendment restrictions.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by snowwrestler on Thursday January 23, 2014 @05:19PM (#7111719)
Just replace the term "court order" with "warrant" above if it makes my point clearer.

The opinion that kicked off this sub-thread is that all wiretaps should be illegal. "All." That would also eliminate wiretaps that would be authorized under a warrant.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by gareim on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:25AM (#7107292)
No, probable cause is not the same thing as evidence. His hypothetical is actually how warrants are supposed to work. Law enforcement have probable cause to suspect someone of being guilty. If they can make a strong argument about why the person is probably guilty, they then get a warrant to search for evidence in homes, phone calls, emails, whatever.

His hypothetical literally described the standard for getting a warrant.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:29AM (#7107298)
> No, probable cause is not the same thing as evidence.

Probable cause is based on evidence.

> His hypothetical is actually how warrants are supposed to work.

No, its not.

> Law enforcement have probable cause to suspect someone of being guilty. If they can make a strong argument about why the person is probably guilty, they then get a warrant to search for evidence in homes, phone calls, emails, whatever.

And that "strong argument" is based on factual evidence that was either received through mechanism other than search and seizure, was the product of prior search and seizure in conditions that do not require a warrant, or was the product of prior warrant-based searches and seizures.

If there was no evidence left other than what was sought in the warrant, there would be no basis for probable cause to support the warrant.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by mercurial on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:48AM (#7107341)
>> No, probable cause is not the same thing as evidence.

> Probable cause is based on evidence.

From wikipedia, "Probable cause" is a stronger standard of evidence than a reasonable suspicion, but weaker than what is required to secure a criminal conviction.

In other word, you can get a warrant when you don't have enough evidence to secure a conviction, which in turn may lead to gather sufficient proof of guilt (or exonerate the suspect, I suppose).

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:51AM (#7107345)
Yes, and any standard of evidence -- even reasonable suspicion -- can't be met without the existence of evidence. That's why its called a "standard of evidence".

Again, if there is no evidence left by the "hitman" except the calls for which the warrant is sought, as specified in the hypothetical, than there can't be probable cause to support the warrant. There can't even be reasonable suspicion. In fact, without some kind of evidence, the only thing that could support the desire to seek the wiretap is arbitrary prejudice.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by mercurial on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:17AM (#7107401)
Fair enough. However, if we take the original premise and change it to "If the FBI identified an organized crime hitman who killed 20+ people and left no solid, non-circumstancial evidence other than making incriminating phone calls, is it wrong for them to place a tap on his phone line once they have probable cause that he is a hitman?", would you agree that wiretaps (with warrants) can be useful?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:27AM (#7108707)
Circumstantial evidence can be used for a conviction, so the absence of non-circumstantial evidence doesn't mean that there isn't evidence sufficient for a conviction.

And, even if the FBI could know that a hitman left a series of incriminating phone calls without already having evidence which could be admitted against the defendant of the content of those phone calls, a wiretap based on a warrant issued after the fact wouldn't recover those contents.

Further, I don't think anyone in the thread has argued that wiretaps aren't useful in criminal prosecution, the issue which started this was a poster expressing that it would be wonderful if wiretaps were categorically outlawed, which does not require believing that they aren't useful in certain circumstances. It could, for instance, proceed from the belief that the capacity is so likely to be abused covertly in circumstances where it is inappropriate if its existence is tolerated at all, that the usefulness it has in the circumstances to which it is appropriate is outweighed.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by ajays on Thursday January 23, 2014 @09:53AM (#7108487)
"would you agree that wiretaps (with warrants) can be useful?"

Nobody is arguing against that. What people are complaining about is, among other things, the bulk collection and retention of records; the gathering of records upto 3 degrees of separation from a suspect; etc.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by pyre on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:06PM (#7109864)
Most reasonable people aren't arguing against all wiretapping, but I wouldn't say nobody.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by rhizome on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:19PM (#7109960)
Couldn't they just follow him?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by idProQuo on Thursday January 23, 2014 @08:36AM (#7108023)
The issue I have with the hypothetical is: how would they know about the phone calls without a wiretap? If there was no other reason to suspect the guy, they'd have no basis for probable cause, and thus no way to get a wiretap.

Now if someone tells the police that they've been getting incriminating phone calls, well then that seems like more reasonable probable cause, and doesn't strike me as morally dubious.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by meowface on Thursday January 23, 2014 @07:56PM (#7112691)
Depends on how you interpret "probable cause."

What if they hear this guy's name uttered by multiple mafia thugs on the street, as a top hitman? And they find the guy is friends with some mafia members? That doesn't warrant real evidence he killed anyone (random hearsay + just being friends), but it definitely creates some suspicion.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:52AM (#7108873)
several terrorists that could have been caught slipped by.

To what effect? Was it really that big a deal?

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by gareim on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:42PM (#7111060)
It really was. At least once, known al-Qaeda terrorists did a trial run prior to 9/11. And for a month up to the day before 9/11, Agent Samit was desperately trying to stop Moussaoui by getting a warrant to search his laptop, but a breakdown in communication at the FBI let Moussaoui pretty much get away with it. Then we all know what happened 9/11.

This really presents an interesting problem, I think. Reading the effect of secret government surveillance from the past century, it's hard to not believe that that surveillance won't be abused. It's been abused in so many other countries and so often in this country (where we hold ourselves in such high regard). At the same time, the power to terrify and commit mass murder has become much easier as technology advances. So what to do?

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by DanBC on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:50PM (#7111094)
I think I would prefer to spend some of that security money on making transport safer or on Mental health programmes or on better energy use or etc etc. All of those things cause far more problems than terrorism has.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by gareim on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:55PM (#7111536)
Yes, I completely agree with you that security spending can be trimmed if we make it more efficient. And yes, that money definitely should go to public programs that improve on our well-being (less attacks then!).

However, I just want to state that we can't completely ignore security either. If bombs are going to go off around us (we cannot make 100% of people non-violent), it's not as if we could stand still and take no action either.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:37AM (#7107217)
> But you're telling me these agencies are committing a crime against the American people, and we need to be careful not to hurt their feelings?

Its worse than that: we have to be careful to avoid making them cautious about committing crimes against the American people, the rule of law, and the Constitutional order of government.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by codex on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:46AM (#7107230)
They're not committing crimes against the American people. Not one American has been found who has been demonstrably harmed by any NSA program. Without harm, there no criminal act. That said, something can be unlawful without being criminal.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by gareim on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:14AM (#7107272)
The Palmer raids in the early 1900s arrested more than 10,000 people. Of that, 3,500 of them were held indefinitely. Almost all of them were innocent people.

In the wake of the 9/11 attacks, 1,200 Muslims were arrested. Some were beaten (this is according to the Justice Department's own Inspector General of the time). Hundreds were held for months. Absolutely none of them were found to be with al-Qaeda.

These are just two examples of MANY. You know what's scary? The spying that the NSA, FBI, and CIA do gets people put on lists. There are lists of people to arrest in the event of an attack. Hoover of the FBI had something like 70,000 people on a list during the era of Communism fear. The vast majority of those people were innocent of any crime.

Over the past century, these lists have been kept openly and kept secretly when different administrations denounced them. But they have been kept (at the FBI at least. Hoover hid them illegally). Letting the NSA spy on us and treating us as if we were assumed criminals before innocent is a terrible way to waste away your fundamental rights.

And the scary thing is we wouldn't even have known that we were being spied on for sure unless Snowden said something.

These are crimes against the American people. You can't tell me that the FISA court not rejecting any warrants is a good thing. Out of tens of thousands of requests, not one gets rejected? That is a failure of the checks and balance system our founding fathers set up. THAT is definitely a crime against the American people.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by rhizome on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:29PM (#7110543)
Wow, I didn't know about the Palmer Raids. Thanks!

"In June 1919, Attorney General Palmer told the House Appropriations Committee that all evidence promised that radicals would 'on a certain day...rise up and destroy the government at one fell swoop.'

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palmer_Raids

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:59AM (#7108926)
And because of how fucked-up the system is, when they come to pick you up, any number of minor things during that encounter ("Fuck you pig, where's the warrant?", running, etc.) can escalate into resisting arrest, disturbing the peace, or assaulting an officer, and then magically you're in the system "for real" and screwed.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:55PM (#7109772)
Probably shouldn't be telling cops to fuck off then?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:38PM (#7110604)
I use the hyperbolic case because it should still be allowed--even a kinder "I'm sorry, but I can't leave with you until you've got a warrant" can trigger a "Are you resisting? taze taze taze" event, as we've seen elsewhere. There is no assurance, no safety net, no hope in the system for common sense--and that's before you even take into account informal departmental policies (HPD: "You can beat the rap, but you can't beat the ride.", Denver PD: "We get up early to beat the crowds").
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:02PM (#7110802)
Sure there are cases of abusing their power, this is normal for any industry, doesn't mean it is the norm.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:29PM (#7110978)
Very few industries are capable of as thoroughly ruining somebody's life as an abuse of power by cops--especially since they are given carte blanche to do so.

We have to look at the worst-case outcomes and make our safeguards against them; anything else is inviting disaster.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:48PM (#7111082)
There are safeguards in place unless I'm mistaken (looking at you Internal Affairs).

> ruining somebody's life as an abuse of power by cops--especially since they are given carte blanche to do so.

The mandate of law enforcement across the USA is to freely destroy peoples lives? Interesting...

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by angersock on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:08PM (#7111202)
Look, there are enough laws and regulations on the books that you can get written up (legally, strictly speaking) for almost anything. Then, it is up to you how far you wish to assert your innocence--the DA will offer to plea you out again and again, and if you make it to court they will then try to make an example out of you, using whatever tricks suit them (all legal, mind you!). There is plenty of evidence and coverage of this happening, so don't pretend it is unreasonable to fear.

That all said, going back to the very first interaction--you and the cop--we see that it becomes purely a decision on the cop's part whether or not you are going to be sent down into the machine.

Justice should not be so arbitrary, but here in the US it oftentimes is; don't pretend otherwise.

EDIT:

As for safeguards...the state can deprive you of years of freedom and set you free afterwards with an "oops". That's bullshit, even if the safeguards finally kick in. And if you end up with "resisting arrest" or just antagonizing the system or embarassing a DA, those safeguards seem to magically fail.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:57PM (#7111139)
>There are safeguards in place unless I'm mistaken (looking at you Internal Affairs).

Yes, I recall the NSA and other government agencies having such self-policing groups.

Tell me, do you really in your heart of hearts think a corrupt organization (say a police dept in a specific place.. if pressed for an example, say Maricopa County in Arizona?) has a functioning IA group?

The federal government has an IA group too. Many of them. I'm sure that if Snowden had raised his concerns with them, they would have gladly worked with him to solve those problems.......

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Crito on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:38AM (#7114103)
Internal Affairs is largely hollywood fantasy. If you have trouble with a local police department and need independant help dealing with it, the best you can really do is going to the FBI.

That "best" is pretty damn shit.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:24PM (#7110011)
1st amendment says otherwise.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:03PM (#7110812)
You are free to talk shit to anyone you want in a bar; you are also free to get your ass kicked.

Antagonizing a cop just to be a dick will probably result in those minor charges he would have ignored if you were nice, getting written up with a smile on his face. That's 100% your fault in that case.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:32PM (#7110992)
The guy in the bar isn't bound by law and ethics to be professional and respect the constitution. The cop is.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:45PM (#7111067)
Writing you a ticket that he is legally entitled to do because you are being a dick is totally professional and in line with the constitution.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:17PM (#7112162)
Differential punishment based on protected speech is not professional or in line with the Constitution.

That it may be difficult for a court to unambiguously distinguish this abuse of power from legitimate application of discretion doesn't mean that it is legitimate.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:58PM (#7111145)
What ticket do you suppose I deserve for using the words "Fuck off cop"?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:21PM (#7111288)
Reread what I said above...If you are being a dick because you want to "stick it to the man", well expect the man to stick it back to you and write you up for those petty offenses he would have otherwise ignored.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:39PM (#7111407)
Problem there is often times people have recieved BS citations for "disturbing the peace" or other nonsense citations which plainly don't apply (i.e. because contempt of cop isn't a crime), but still result in court time and hassle for the accused.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by CogDisco on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:15PM (#7112147)
You have the right to free speech. You don't have the right to freedom from consequence of free speech.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Karunamon on Thursday January 23, 2014 @10:17PM (#7113168)
And what consequence should be merited for the words "Fuck off cop"?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by res0nat0r on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:29AM (#7113485)
You getting treated equally shitty in return?
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Crito on Friday January 24, 2014 @04:35AM (#7114097)
I don't think the concern is that the cop might in turn tell him to fuck off.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:05AM (#7107257)
> They're not committing crimes against the American people. Not one American has been found who has been demonstrably harmed by any NSA program. Without harm, there no criminal act.

Criminal acts, in general, don't require harm (some specific crimes may involve a harm as a required element, but that is not generally the case -- generally, crimes exist to prevent harm, but that does not mean a harm must be realized for a crime to occur), and, in any case, depriving the American people of the popular sovereignty by exercising the power of government inconsistent with the constraints in which it is granted by the people through the Constitution is, in and of itself, a harm.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by adventured on Thursday January 23, 2014 @07:10AM (#7107612)
Fortunately you're wrong. Violating my constitutionally guaranteed liberties is the harm in fact.

Eroding the protections I'm guaranteed, for example against general search warrants, is causing me immediate harm.

What is the harm? Something that belongs to me has been taken from me against my will, through the use of coercion, intimidation and force.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by amirmc on Thursday January 23, 2014 @04:11AM (#7107485)
You don't know that. There may be many but due to parallel construction, the source of investigations is obfuscated.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by skore on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:42AM (#7107323)
> Not one American has been found who has been demonstrably harmed by any NSA program.

First they came for some foreigners and I did not speak out - because I was an American.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by ajays on Thursday January 23, 2014 @09:51AM (#7108467)
"Not one American has been found who has been demonstrably harmed by any NSA program."

As an American, how would I know? It is against the law to read my mail; but if the government has been secretly reading my mail without my knowledge, then by your logic (and I use that word lightly here) I have not been harmed, since I didn't know about it?

Do you even know the meaning of the word "rights" ? My rights have been violated; I don't have to demonstrate harm.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by arca_vorago on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:34PM (#7110085)
" Not one American has been found who has been demonstrably harmed by any NSA program."

Of course, this statement heavily relies on what you mean by "demonstrably" and "harm". What is the standard of proof you would require to demonstrate harm? As you say it, it sounds like one of those terms that you can forever pushback against and say "but X didn't demonstrate harm sufficiently".

The most likely harm that I would consider widespread would be the chilling effect. For example, Chris Hedges and others tried to sue the gov for the NDAA's chilling effect, but once they got to court it was thrown out because they had "no standing". So it's pretty obvious that you can't say that a court ruling on something demonstrates harm, because the courts themselves are part of the harm occurring.

As a matter of fact, I bet I could have a pretty good claim that the NSA program has harmed me. I am an Iraq combat vet with PTSD, and happened to be someone who has talking about the NSA doing this stuff since the early 2000's. At my last meeting with the VA, I specifically stated that I was concerned at the confidentiality of my talks due to their being entered in an electronic system that I suspected the NSA and other three-letters would have access to. Therefore I quit my PTSD treatment because I felt I could not trust the VA system or any claims of doctor-patient confidentiality. I actually asked the doc to make sure she typed that into the system so that in the future I could use it as evidence if the need ever arose. I'm doing fine now mostly of my own volition, but what I think about is how many other vets had the same gut feeling and kept their problems hidden and suffered greatly for it?

This is only one example that I think is pretty concrete.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by thinkmassive on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:02PM (#7109359)
They've been providing tips to the FBI for years: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/01/new-documents-nsa...

They've also been providing tips to the DEA: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intel...

How is subverting due process by engaging in parallel construction not a crime against US citizens?

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dchichkov on Thursday January 23, 2014 @01:57AM (#7107246)
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by ewoodrich on Thursday January 23, 2014 @02:01AM (#7107252)
How was Snowden harmed by an NSA program? He's admitted to committing a federal offense and therefore cannot return to the US or countries with an extradition treaty without appearing in federal court. That's pretty "standard" judicial proceedings, no need for NSA powers.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by dchichkov on Thursday January 23, 2014 @03:02AM (#7107376)
If not for NSA program Snowden would very likely still be living happily and productively, with his family, here in the US.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by malandrew on Thursday January 23, 2014 @12:56PM (#7109784)
They've undermined the Constitution and Bill of Rights. I'd argue that they've harmed every American by doing so. Harm doesn't just have to be physical or economic. They can harm the liberties of Americans granted by those documents.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by Shivetya on Thursday January 23, 2014 @06:52AM (#7107550)
Well, yes.

Think about it. Your doing what your told over and over is good for the country. You really don't understand all the ins and outs but suddenly what you have putting all your effort into is declared criminal by some. If your a mid/low level worker how are you supposed to feel? Brush it off and blame those above you? Hang your head in shame? There certainly are enough people out there; if not posting here; who would excoriate you for not knowing what any one one with a brain should have known/etc/etc

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by aragot on Thursday January 23, 2014 @07:29AM (#7107678)
This is what happens for all wars after reddition: Suddently all local soldiers who did lawful things can be charged for having done illegal crimes. Humans are responsible for their actions, perhaps in the limit of the constraints they were held under. Blame the US for using the vocabulary "war on terrorism" and the NSA for being a military branch. If power turns over and it is deemed illegal, there can be a mixed between penalty and pardon for those involved until the country heals.

The upside is, it's most probably democracy which is winning today.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by rayiner on Thursday January 23, 2014 @07:16AM (#7107631)
Constitutional violations aren't "crimes." E.g. Nobody went to jail for attempting to enforce the unconstitutional election law in citizens united.
Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by bediger4000 on Thursday January 23, 2014 @11:03AM (#7108963)
By which "touchstone", "Three-pronged Test" or "Most Holy Doctrine" are we supposed to know this? That is, you just wrote a very lawyerly thing that doesn't translate well to what everybody knows and feels.

Mass surveillance is a crime, dude. Somebody needs to be punished to set an example so that civil servants don't overstep their bounds again. Somebody needs to be punished to stop what will certainly turn into an instrument of repression.

Re:Watchdog Report Says N.S.A. Program Is Illegal and Should... by rayiner on Thursday January 23, 2014 @11:22AM (#7109091)
It's not a "very lawyerly thing" nor is there any problem translating to what "everybody knows and feels." People have a pretty intuitive grasp on the idea that the recourse for Constitutional violations is almost always for the government to stop doing whatever was unconstitutional. When Brown v. Board ruled segregated schools unconstitutional, nobody was thrown in jail. When California unconstitutionally suppressed free speech through its violent video games legislation, nobody was thrown in jail. When limitations on the use of birth control were declared unconstitutional, nobody was thrown in jail. The line between constitutional action and unconstitutional action can be quite subtle in ways only lawyers can appreciate, and because of that we don't punish constitutional violations (on their own). And normal people grasp that reality, and the percentage of people who think a crime has been committed that warrants jail time for anyone is a polling margin of error.