I think this has quite a bit more to do with the good ol' boy network and less to do with Yale's ability to produce leaders.
But the GOBN is part of leadership. I don't mean this sarcastically and, though I started to write that sentence with "unfortunately" I took that word out since I am not sure whether it's unfortunate or not -- even though I am not a GOB myself.
Are you saying that the ability to network is a part of leadership? Perhaps I'm a dullard but could you clarify what you meant?
"Ability to network" is not sufficient -- I am well networked into an infrastructure of nerds. But by declining to go to Harvard for university and instead choosing to go to MIT, I cut myself off from that network. ⅓ of my graduating class (13/39) did choose to go to Harvard and they all landed on their feet one way or another.
The whole point of scholarships was to try to inject some meritocracy into this network.
Look at many of the most successful tech entrepreneurs and you'll see this same GOB phenomenon. Bill Gates' mother was on the United Way board with the CEO of IBM. Chad Hurley (at Youtube) was the son in law of Jim Clark. etc etc. These connections are not usually mentioned in the hagiographies.
By the way here's another example: my high school and harvard university are about the same age and there is a lot of interlinkage between the institutions. So it's not surprising that a large proportion of its graduates go there. The high school is super aggressive about not admitting kids of the GOB network since they'll do OK anyway. But sadly it wasn't alway so.
That's kind of what I was getting at. The people who are already in charge generally get to pick the next generation of leaders. While this is the way things are done in our current reality, it doesn't give current leaders, future leaders, or the institutions that prop them up a legitimate claim to natural leadership ability.
Basically, all our democracy has managed to accomplish lately is to prove that monarchies don't necessarily depend on blood-relations to function.
As an example, to help myself get into college I was in the boy scouts and got eagle scout (that was the only reason, I hated it.) The idea there was that by teaching other kids how to use an axe without dismembering themselves, I demonstrated leadership skills that would prove valuable in computer science... Of course that is rubbish, that stuff doesn't even have anything to do with leadership, it is just going through the motions. Paying lip service to the idea of leadership because the idea of leadership, not actual leadership, is something that we are all addicted to.
I've gotten use to it though. My personal theory? Leaders overemphasis the importance of everyone being a leader. Just as tech people get behind "everyone should be a coder" initiatives, leaders get behind "everyone should be a leader" initiatives.
Even if you're not actually in charge, the related skills of leadership are useful.
The problem is when things like college admissions start believing that these skills are best demonstrated in "leadership positions".
Of course, this is the same phenomenon on a larger scale. Nowhere tries to be "normal". Visit the website of any college or university: it will claim to be exceptional.
But is that such a bad thing? I for one, want to be around the sort of people who push others, the organizations they belong to, and themselves. And I aspire to be such a person as well.
Implicit? I'd say it's pretty explicit. Harvard, Yale, etc. aren't trying to be "normal" colleges, they're explicitly trying to produce the next generation of world leaders. Admissions make very clear that intellectualism/learning on its own is not enough.
And rhetoric? It's reality. Our most recent 6 terms of presidents, and 9 out of 9 current Supreme Court justices, all have degrees from Harvard or Yale. So the whole leadership thing appears to be working, whether or not you think that's a good thing.
I don't think Harvard, Yale, or anybody else is arguing that most colleges need to, or should, focus on leadership. But they're certainly within their rights to want to -- it's one of the things that makes Harvard and Yale what they are.