1) In New Zealand there isn't really any incentive to become homeless, because a case worker takes you through an assessment process. This ensures that houses are only given to people who are truly homeless. Furthermore, I suspect you might underestimate the negative social image associated with living in state housing. If you need it, no-one really looks down on you (our current Prime Minister grew up in state housing), but if you're a young 20-something with a job, state housing is certainly not 'cool'.
2) The housing projects I have witnessed have not turned into centres for crime. It probably helps that these housing projects are really just clusters of 5-20 individual houses on a common plot, in the middle of some suburb. They're not segregated and concentrated.
EDIT: rXoX and im_a_lawyer, it looks like you've both been shadowbanned.
This is the biggest problem with American housing projects. They tend to be high density apartments in the cities, with thousands of poor people living together, segregated from everyone else. This is the result of the massive hypocrisy of American suburbanites. The county where my parents live in northern Virginia voted for Obama 60-40, but everyone would flip the fuck out if anyone built public housing in the suburbs near them. To them, public housing means segregating all the poor blacks and hispanics into the inner city so they don't run across them at the local shopping mall.
Ironically [or cynically depending on your point of view] LIHTC projects in particular saw increased funding in the rush to fund 'shovel ready' projects as housing cratered due to oversupply.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOPE_VI
I'm pretty sure in the USA, state housing would be very cool in the right groups, because you are getting free housing and also "sticking it to the man". Shit, I could totally see a future where only people with state housing are "hip".
Something tells me you've never had to deal with the homeless. If you did you would know you can't simply declare yourself homeless.
Here are all the ways a typical college dropout isn't homeless, when you show up to a shelter they'll ask these questions:
Do you have family you can stay with? Do you have friends you can stay with? Do you have assets you can use to stay in a sublet or studio?
Can a typical college studio say no to all of these?
The counselors job at the homeless shelter is to get you into housing as fast as possible, hopefully within the same night, sometimes it can take a week. Any longer than that and you start to mentally break down. They'll go through your entire phonebook and family tree to find a place for you to live that isn't the shelter.
> Public housing projects perpetuate poverty and crime and this will end no differently.
Public housing are a victim of their own success. People need help to emerge from poverty, move into the projects, and once they have built up enough resources they buy a home, or rent privately, and move out. After a while only the most indigent are left in the projects. So only the very poor are left in these places, the marginally poor have moved up and out. Projects don't start out a shithole, they get that way through neglect.
Do some people take advantage of welfare? Sure. But if you're doing pretty ok making $30k a year, would you drag yourself into unemployment just so you can take food stamps? Doubt it.
In fact, I see it completely reversed. It's a short term problem, with a long term solution. If you look at Maslow's hiearchy of needs, people who have their basic necessities met (housing, food, friends, etc) will naturally strive for higher living standards. In the short term, people will become homeless to claim free apartments, but in the long term strive for higher living standards.
We can be sure addicts are going to get their drugs, and they're going to get the drugs whether they have a place to live and food on the table or not. The question is whether they're going to be committing other crimes that put society at risk in order to do so. I'd rather they spend my tax money than break into my house.
The problem we want to solve is that these people don't have food and shelter - or from a more selfish perspective, that these people are costing us money on prisons and emergency services. Now, would giving these people money solving these problems? Would giving them money be more effective at solving these problems than housing projects and food programs? Like I say, I'd like to believe giving them money works, but I want to see the evidence.
Not exactly. I'm assuming SOME people will take advantage of the system. Some people ALWAYS take advantage of a system with bad incentives.
Lots of people don't want to work, which is fine. However we don't want to reward people more for doing less.
Even though a third of Vienna's population (2.4 million) lives in public housing [1] today, Vienna has one of the highest standards of living in the world. [2][3]
There're a lot of things that I don't like about Austrian policy, but not having masses of homeless people roaming the streets is certainly not of them.
> 2) This creates classic housing projects problems which inevitably turn into centers for crime, over time deteriorating neighborhoods and creating tension that is bad for everyone.
Depends on how well it is implemented. Here they are distributed across the whole city thus preventing concentration of the poor in one neighborhood.
There are still parts of the city where more poor or rich people live, but there is no part where you'll find only one type precisely because there is public housing everywhere.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemeindebau
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercer_Quality_of_Living_Survey
[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World%27s_most_livable_cities
Common Ground is one example running in Australia, I think inspired by a project in the US: http://www.commongroundadelaide.org.au/
1) This creates an incentive to become "homeless." Now any kid can drop out of college, declare himself homeless, and get a free apartment. While it takes time for such incentives to kick in, this WILL happen.
2) This creates classic housing projects problems which inevitably turn into centers for crime, over time deteriorating neighborhoods and creating tension that is bad for everyone.
Every generation, we forget how terribly housing projects work out.
The solution is a basic income, possibly phased out slowly with earned income increases. This allows for a mobility and rational incentives housing projects can not provide.
Public housing projects perpetuate poverty and crime and this will end no differently. It's great that some homeless people have a place to sleep today - just wait 10 or 20 years and see how it turns out. Look at projects and low income housing in every city across the world.