Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by amichail on Thursday July 16, 2009 @06:46PM
(#708951)
The probability that you are human given that you are human is obviously 1.
That's not what I am asking.
Is there some plausible (possibly metaphysical) explanation besides that you were extremely lucky?
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by tdoggette on Thursday July 16, 2009 @06:58PM
(#708967)
There is no "me" that ever had a non-one probability of being human. There is no great lottery from which each entity is chosen to be one thing or another.
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by frossie on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:11PM
(#708986)
plausible (possibly metaphysical)
Sorry, you just blew my fuse by using plausible and metaphysical in the same sentence. Maybe somebody else can help you with that.
To repeat, luck has nothing to do with it because there is no consciousness allocating lottery. It's like saying "the universe is 99.9[...]9% empty space, ain't I lucky to be on a planet?". Luck does not apply, as the chance of you being born in empty space is exactly 0.
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by Retric on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:09PM
(#708981)
Think of it this way, if you and 100 million other people all buy a lottery ticket and you win the jackpot you might ask why me? Yet, assume the odds someone would win was 90%, and the odds that the winner would ask the question was also 90%. Now what's unusual about the person asking the question?
nothing
And what's unusual about someone winning?
nothing
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by mbrubeck on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:09PM
(#708982)
It's even more likely that you are a rock. Or a star. Or an electron.
Except it's not, because you can't be an electron, if "you" means "someone contemplating this question" (or any other non-trivial, relevant meaning of "you").
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by amichail on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:13PM
(#708993)
You don't need an entity that is capable of contemplating this question to be conscious/self-aware.
Re:Ask HN: What is the probability of being human?
by nostrademons on Thursday July 16, 2009 @07:08PM
(#708980)
If you weren't extremely lucky, you wouldn't be asking the question.
Seriously it doesn't work like that. The probability of me being an insect is 0 - in fact the probability of me being anybody else besides me is 0, unless you are in metaphysical territory (eg. reincarnation), in which case please stop using Gaussian probability theory as its warranty only covers use in the physical world.