News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peelian Principles by cstross on Sunday January 19, 2014 @06:02AM (#7084104)
So kindly explain what's wrong, in principle, with defining book ideals and then using these as criteria to evaluate the success of organizations?

The Peelian principles have been largely obscured or ignored in recent decades, and arguably they were always a bit hollow -- but the history of British policing since the 1830s has had significantly less emphasis on raw offensive firepower than other police systems: even today the vast majority of British cops do not ever carry guns, and per a 2006 poll of members of the Police Federation, 82% of officers don't want to routinely carry guns:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19641398

This demonstrates, if nothing else, that even after 170-180 years a high-minded book ideal can have a long term effect on an institution (even though we as a species seem to be extremely bad at keeping institutions on track on any time frame longer than a human working lifespan).

And, if I may editorialize a little, being aware that it is possible to constitute a police force along radically unfamiliar lines should free us from the tyranny of low expectations that leads us to assume that current abuses of police powers are inevitable and unexceptional.

We can do better, and we deserve better.

Re:Peelian Principles by rjknight on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:20AM (#7084230)
Indeed, I think there's something a bit too fatalistic about the idea that the police must automatically be bad because the very nature of authority is corrupting. It's somewhat similar to genetically-deterministic evo-psych, or arguments that group X will behave in a certain way because of their privileges or sufferings. There might be a tendency toward that pattern of behaviour, but tendencies can be overcome. In social science there are rarely any iron rules of behaviour.
Re:Peelian Principles by cstross on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:23AM (#7084340)
The real question is how we design robust institutional cultures that don't deteriorate over time, and adhere to the original mission goals. (And also how we free ourselves from the tyranny of low expectations, so that we can set good goals rather than accepting bad outcomes as inevitable.)

Note that Peel's Principles were in no small part to address the public order aftermath of the Peterloo Massacre:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peterloo_massacre

Prior to the huge wave of policing and justice reforms of the 1830s, in the UK not only were there no real organized police forces, but what policing there was relied on local bailiffs, freelance for-profit thief-takers (google "Jonathan Wilde" for an extraordinary example of just how wrong for-profit policing can go!), and in extremis, the army (who, at Peterloo, sent a cavalry charge into a large crowd who were demonstrating for electoral reform: many dead, many hundreds injured).

Some sort of reform was clearly necessary, and the drawbacks of a military style of public order enforcement was glaringly obvious: hence the attempt at re-inventing the entire concept of policing.

Re:Peelian Principles by icegreentea on Sunday January 19, 2014 @10:07AM (#7084589)
Kinda ironic that you describe the problem as "military style of public order enforcement", since one of the hallmarks and necessities of the very reforms was the centralization of policing, and the imposition of various military-like organization on the police in an attempt to increase visibility, accountability, and legitimacy.

In fact, I don't think the question isn't so much how to design robust cultures that do not "deteriorate over time", but how to design systems that are amenable to reform despite "deterioration". Basically, I'm making the claim that that on the micro-level, that every day, or year to year life of an institution, negative effects will tend to out-weight positives. And I'm going to argue that from the standpoint of entropy. So in other words, sure, we want to create systems that are robust, as in they can maintain their culture at some set level, but it's even more important to ensure that we can "reset" the system at relatively low cost.

Re:Peelian Principles by cstross on Sunday January 19, 2014 @12:35PM (#7085083)
In your country, are the Fire service, Ambulance service, or Coast Guard, necessarily military? Because they were uniforms, have rank structures, operate heavy equipment, and are government employees.

(Yes, this is a trick question. In some countries these are paramilitary organizations and services -- or provided by private corporations. But in the UK, they're civilian government agencies that are explicitly non-military. It's possible to have a centralized, hierarchical uniformed state agency that isn't militaries and isn't there to point guns at the public. That's the point I'm trying to make here.)

Your secondary point about systems needing to be amenable to reform is a good one. Too much rigidity and inflexibility makes reform hard: but it may also help prevent corruption. Which aspect wins out probably has something to do with the type of people the organization recruits -- are they dedicated to public service, or are they attracted to a role where they get to carry a gun and wear a uniform and are feared by the public? My gut feeling is that authoritarian followers (per Altermayer) are a really bad fit for community policing ... but unfortunately uniformed armed services are attractive to such personality types.

Re:Peelian Principles by icegreentea on Sunday January 19, 2014 @02:59PM (#7085720)
I readily accept your first point. I guess I messed up my delivery of the first point. It wasn't meant so much as a rebuttal or counterpoint, but something of a "random aside". The point wasn't that they "militarized" the police, especially in the way militarized is often used today in the context of American law enforcement (with the implications of increased use of aggressive force), but rather that its kinda funny that their solution to trying to back off on the level of violence was to impose aspects of military like control.

Of course, in the long view it's pretty obvious why that happened. Consider why modern western militaries are structured and organized the way they are. The state has a monopoly on force, which requires not just the owning the army, but to be able to control the application of force down to the level of individual soldier. Obviously the control can never be perfect, but I think its pretty clear that it typically works well enough.

I guess my point is that especially in the context of the 19th century, militarization has two orthogonal aspects, the first being the nature and quantity of force to apply, and the second being control of force, and that when faced with the problem of overly aggressive police action, they sought to apply control by applying aspects of military organization - aspects which the military could claim to "own" first, just because they were only groups around with that type of organization at that time.

Re:Peelian Principles by midas007 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:10AM (#7094047)
The only way is if police are held to account. That there is some sort of oversight committee, separate from the police force, that can fire officers.

For example, Mountain View PD has this female police officer that is just plain nutters in a dangerous way (aggressive and crazy with a gun).

Re:Peelian Principles by midas007 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:01AM (#7094016)
How many police officers have you interacted with?
Re:Peelian Principles by threeseed on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:04AM (#7084204)
UK police officers don't want to carry guns because they really don't need to. The most likely threat they are going to face is from a youth carrying a knife (gangs are an issue in outer London boroughs). And since police officers are wearing protective vests a knife attack isn't going to be hitting major organs.
Re:Peelian Principles by watmough on Sunday January 19, 2014 @01:43PM (#7085395)
If you notice though, everywhere, including the UK, now has vans full of armed SWAT-type cops, ready to roll at a moments notice.

Un-armed my foot! (pun intended)

Re:Peelian Principles by andyjohnson0 on Sunday January 19, 2014 @03:20PM (#7085818)
Armed response vehicles do exist in the major cities in the UK, although the number of incidents in which they are used is declining. In England and Wales for the year ending March 2012, the police discharged firearms at a total of five incidents [1]. That's for a population of 56 million.

[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/statistics-on-police-...

Re:Peelian Principles by maxerickson on Sunday January 19, 2014 @12:19PM (#7085030)
I like that you called them ideals.

A lot of what I consider weirder political thought seems to come from treating some set of principles as inviolate. It's harder to make that mistake of thought with an ideal.

(and any system involving more than 1 human seems likely enough to require compromise somewhere)

Re:Peelian Principles by midas007 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:12AM (#7094051)
Yeah, it's usually the inexperienced and the privileged that take on a meritocratic, neat-and-simple worldview. It's the intellectual equivalent of sticking one's head in the sand.

"Shit happens" isn't a bumper sticker for no reason.

Re:Peelian Principles by midas007 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @03:05AM (#7094030)
Because it's divorced from reality for one.