Re:The Death Of Expertise
by badman_ting on Saturday January 18, 2014 @02:39PM
(#7081948)
I think I have read too much Taleb to be able to agree.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Death Of Expertise
by bayesianhorse on Saturday January 18, 2014 @04:23PM
(#7082284)
Taleb strikes me as entirely too prone to refer to himself as an expert. For that matter I can barely stand references to ancient literature when discussing an extremely modern subject which should be understood through mathmatics, not conjecture, however fancy the latter was constructed.
Taleb's writings do not contradict this article, as the experts are often right; (my take on) Taleb's criticism of experts is that being right most of the time is not good enough when there are long-tailed distributions.
Re:The Death Of Expertise
by badman_ting on Saturday January 18, 2014 @03:06PM
(#7082050)
In "The Black Swan" he does talk about the importance of experts' error rate, but the larger point is that only fields which do not rely on prediction of the future, or "do not move" as he phrases it, can have true experts. Medicine, hard science, games, accounting, agricultural stuff.