Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T...
by jblow on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:02PM
(#7079862)
To my recollection, most people disagreed with said statement. The thought was that any kind of quantum coherence would not hold for a nonnegligible time, because hey, decoherence. This was before we started seeing proof of quantum effects biology at all.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T...
by marcosdumay on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:23PM
(#7079911)
People can not disagree that there are "quantum effects" at the brain because this term has no obvious meaning. There is a completely deceptional "evil sister" of that theory, that defines "quatum effecs" in a completely different way from what's on the paper, it normaly only appears when there isn't a chance for peer review, and yes, people are fast to torn it apart.
The usual answer to this one theory presented at the paper is along the lines of "yes, that's quite possible. It may be quite important for discovering how the neurons work, but even if it's right, it does not mean that our current models are wrong", coupled with a "why did you get the idea that this can be in any way more powerfull than other kind of expected phenomena?"
For the record: Almost nobody would have disagreed with this statement. What people may have argued about is if quantum activity in the microtubules correlates to anything to do with the function of the brain, esp. memory, or cognition.
This article shows no direct in vivo evidence of such a thing, just a simulation that shows exactly what "quantum activity" is possible, and a tenuous, hypothetical connection to how that may deal with cognition.
FWIW, I have long believed in penrose's microtubule hypothesis (wrt to cognition, but not necessarily consciousness), and I find this finding to be encouraging to my belief, but in the article there is some obfuscation of just how much (or how little?) has been found here.