Re:Data Structures in Clojure: Singly-Linked Lists
by Anderkent on Friday January 17, 2014 @01:23PM
(#7077453)
`deftype` only lets you implement functions that match an interface, protocol, or override Object. It's meant to narrow down the meaning of a type, and usually any non-interface methods would just be clojure functions that take an object.
It does play weirdly with the fact that mutable fields are private, I agree. But that is a very rare case, and in general you'd usually create a type to implement an interface or protocol.
"AOT deftype vs gen-class touches on the same Clojure semantics vs Java/ host semantics, with the objectives from before - support implementing interfaces but not concrete derivation. So, no concrete base classes, no super calls, self-ctor calls, statics, methods not implementing interface methods etc."
It does play weirdly with the fact that mutable fields are private, I agree. But that is a very rare case, and in general you'd usually create a type to implement an interface or protocol.
Quoting Rich Hickey: (https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/clojure/pZFl8gj1lMs/qV...)
"AOT deftype vs gen-class touches on the same Clojure semantics vs Java/ host semantics, with the objectives from before - support implementing interfaces but not concrete derivation. So, no concrete base classes, no super calls, self-ctor calls, statics, methods not implementing interface methods etc."