News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by yetanotherphd on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @11:45PM (#7068123)
It's great that someone is finally disrupting the squatting market.

The contracts that these so called guardians have seem strange though. Are they standard rental contracts, because the conditions described wouldn't be legal where I live. I wonder if courts will at some stage decide that there people really are renting, and are therefore entitled to all the legal protection of renters.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by citricsquid on Thursday January 16, 2014 @12:23AM (#7068219)
Tenants in England do have a lot of rights (for example a tenant can only be evicted by a court) but these aren't tenants, they're "licensees" who do not have any of the legal protections afforded to tenants. You raise an interesting point though, and according to this article there are potential conflicts between these arrangements and the law that may eventually lead to court involvement: http://www.landlordlawblog.co.uk/2013/03/11/property-guardia...
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by Pxtl on Thursday January 16, 2014 @09:34AM (#7069566)
Defining them as licensees instead of tenants strikes me as something that won't stand up in court. They're tenants in every function other than name.
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by darkr on Thursday January 16, 2014 @03:13AM (#7068578)
> It's great that someone is finally disrupting the squatting market.

You mean _anti_-squatting market?

These kind of companies have thrived in Europe over the past few years due to a wholescale clampdown of squatters rights, with the Netherlands and England* making it outright illegal in 2010 and 2012 respectively.

*In England, the term "squatting" is defined in legal terms to mean "the act of knowingly entering a _residential_ building as a trespasser and living there". Entering a non-residential building without permission is still not illegal, provided you don't cause any damage.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by blueskin_ on Thursday January 16, 2014 @04:50AM (#7068687)
Squatters' rights? What's next, muggers' rights?

I'm glad to see a turn back from punishing the victims of crime to punishing the perpetrators. Perhaps now the government can do something about prosecutions of people for attacking burglars in their own home, another longstanding victim-punishing law.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @05:13AM (#7068768)
Mugging is an act of violence. It violates the victims freedom of action and causes great damage.

Squatting is a non-violent act. It provides shelter to someone who didn't have it before. The owner of the shelter can be unaware of the fact that his property is being used for several months, emphasizing the lack of damage by the act.

Evicting a squatter, on the other hand, causes damage to the victim in fact, it removes a shelter from someone.

So mugging and squatting are two very different acts

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by mseebach on Thursday January 16, 2014 @05:39AM (#7068842)
Squatting violates the victims freedom of action and causes great damage. Squatting is non violent, so it's more comparable to burglary than mugging, not that that moves is far up the scale.

Defences for squatting typically hinges on arguments around that the squatters need the building more than the landlord who leaves it empty. As a moral argument, that would carry more weight if squatters were known to leave when the landlord was putting the building to productive use, but they don't. So on that angle, squatting is mere theft, too, but of a much higher value item than any regular burglar or mugger could ever hope to make off with.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @08:00AM (#7069093)
No. In case of burglary, the victim looses its possession. In the case of squatting, the possession is still theirs. It is only the status of the property that changes from "vacant" to "in use". Note that the change of status is temporary and reversible (as opposed to burglary).
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by marrs on Thursday January 16, 2014 @08:30AM (#7069236)
Keen to have an argument today? Someone I know had to move in with his family because squatters effectively made him homeless. It took months to get them out. It was a very stressful time for him. They also stole all his property before they left.
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @09:18AM (#7069476)
again squatting != theft. Those are sepperate issues. Just because there are evil squatters out there, it doesn't make squatting evil.
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by blueskin_ on Thursday January 16, 2014 @12:09PM (#7070683)
Property theft is theft.

Intention doesn't come into theft. "I stole his car but only for a day" doesn't change the fact that a crime was committed; neither does it for houses or offices.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @12:44PM (#7071006)
Funny you should say that since "property is theft!" is one of the earliest slogan in the anarchist literature and is often quoted by squatters advocates :-)

What you have to consider, though, is the fact that not all property is equal. There is a difference between owning a toothbrush, and owning slaves. Equalling all property would be identifying a policeman's action of emancipating a prostitute from her pimp as theft of property, which of course is nonsense.

To give an example. Imagine you go to a country where slavery is legal, disgusted by their treatment you join some activists that emancipates slaves. Now you are stealing the slaveholders property and therefor committing a crime. Are you going to hold that crime at par with stealing someones money, or someones bicycle?

Now this is an extreme example, but a few hundred years ago it wouldn't be so far out, and slave emancipators, now considered heroes, were then considered criminals? Same may hold a few hundred years from now in case of land. Land hording is criminal, it keeps other people of it. It could and should be used for the great of the community. Squatting a few hundred years from now may be looked at as land emancipation, even though now it is as criminal as stealing a bike.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by blueskin_ on Friday January 17, 2014 @04:52AM (#7075027)
>Funny you should say that since "property is theft!" is one of the earliest slogan in the anarchist literature and is often quoted by squatters advocates :-)

As said by massive hypocrites from within their safe homes. Most first world anarchists would likely be murdered and robbed within days if there was actual anarchy, and no police to get help from then.

>slaves

Property doesn't have free will.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:27AM (#7084344)
Since when was 'free will' a criteria for property?? So you couldn't own a dog, you couldn't own farm animals? If that is not a fair comparison (since farm animals arguably don't have free will), then who is to say that slaves do?
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by blueskin_ on Thursday January 16, 2014 @08:45AM (#7069307)
...except for all their possessions that were in the property that were stolen / smashed up / ruined / sold for crack.

Not to mention their money and time in getting the squatters evicted, which usually involves courts, the hiring of security people, etc, followed by the cost of repairing the damage they did to the property.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @09:22AM (#7069497)
again. Squatting != theft/vandalism.

plus I have no empathy towards folks that have property they don't use, and then actively engage in preventing others from using it, and then finally complain about how difficult it is to prevent other people to use their property they don't use in the first place.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by blueskin_ on Thursday January 16, 2014 @05:28AM (#7068810)
Not always though. There are cases where people have gone on holiday and had their homes invaded and damaged, their possessions stolen (and often sold for drugs), and have been stuck with long and costly legal battles to regain what is rightfully theirs. Squatting violates the victims' freedom of property. If insulting someone verbally can be referred to as violent, so should stealing their home and possessions.

I'm less concerned with invasion of business properties - while it should still be illegal, there is less loss to a business, who also typically have the legal staff and expertise as well as funds to get rid of them more swiftly and easily.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by runarberg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @06:12AM (#7068921)
May I note that theft, invasion of privacy, and vandalism are all violent crimes that causes harm to the victim[1]. Those crimes can follow almost any human acts, such as partying (party people mug), alcohol consumption (drunk people steal), protests (politically opposing people vandalize), but you wouldn't say those things are equal, you would look at these marginal cases as a subset and to be treated as separate acts.

In short. Squatting is sometimes, but rarely followed with more violent and damaging crimes. But squatting in it self are not those crimes.

--- [1] with exception, of course, in the case of vandalism, if no the "owner" is oblivious of its value, or when vandalism acts to prevent further vandalism, like the destruction of military tools and weapons.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by tfgg on Thursday January 16, 2014 @06:04AM (#7068906)
"had their homes invaded and damaged, their possessions stolen (and often sold for drugs)"

Sounds like burglary and criminal damage, not squatting, is the issue here. The problem is that those are hard to prove and it's easier just to have a catch-all crime for squatting.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by yetanotherphd on Thursday January 16, 2014 @09:58AM (#7069677)
No I meant the squatting market, although I was using the term market ironically.

The existence of the "right" to squat is a historical accident, and this legal right should be eliminated entirely.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by Joeboy on Thursday January 16, 2014 @02:58AM (#7068534)
> It's great that someone is finally disrupting the squatting market.

It's good that there's a more legit way that empty properties can provide homes for people. The fact these properties are no longer providing homes for other people is not the best thing about this.

Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by wanda on Thursday January 16, 2014 @02:41AM (#7068493)

  "finally"
This has been going on for a while now. It's nothing new.
Re:In London 'Guardians' live in empty office buildings by nwh on Thursday January 16, 2014 @01:01AM (#7068307)
They certainly wouldn't be legal in Australia, we have a pile of protections for renters that by the sounds of things these places don't fulfil. No hot water, no power?