Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev...
by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @09:01PM
(#7067587)
It makes no sense in that it has no physical meaning. As you say, even without deeper meaning it is a fine tool for handling Gaussian distributions.
Because of the central limit theorem, many distributions encountered in science are approximately Gaussian, which is parameterized by its mean and standard deviation. According to Wikipedia: "Height is sexually dimorphic and statistically it is more or less normally distributed, but with heavy tails."
On top of that, we have well-understood and easy to compute estimators for standard deviation. Using the sample variance is not a bad estimator at all, the only real disagreement is whether you divide by N or N-1.