News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev... by coldtea on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @05:18PM (#7066583)
>I don't understand calling him a "vile idiot" is so terrible.

Then you are a vile idiot.

Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev... by tptacek on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @05:27PM (#7066649)
Super helpful comment. Thanks. Definitely, the transition from calling public figures "vile idiots" to calling individual commenters on HN threads "vile idiots" is sure to produce a productive discussion.

I started this subthread by pointing out that 'bluecalm had weakened his argument by using the words "vile idiot". But 'bluecalm also made a bunch of testable and non-obvious observations in his comment; his writing had value. Whereas you just jumped in to call someone you disagreed with a name, and nothing else; your writing had no value.

Could you stop writing comments like that?

Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev... by jessaustin on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @07:08PM (#7067160)
Did you really understand that comment to be addressed to the writer rather than what was written? Frankly I found it to be a rather more convincing condemnation of the phrase "vile idiot" than your own. FWIW, I don't think anyone here (nor NNT even) is a vile idiot.
Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev... by coldtea on Thursday January 16, 2014 @05:03AM (#7068737)
>Super helpful comment. Thanks. Definitely, the transition from calling public figures "vile idiots" to calling individual commenters on HN threads "vile idiots" is sure to produce a productive discussion.

The point I wanted to make was that "vile idiot" is problematic in itself, and by my meta-use of it, I hoped the parent would obviously see why.

How calling public figures "vile idiots" is any better than calling individual HN commenters the same?

>Whereas you just jumped in to call someone you disagreed with a name, and nothing else; your writing had no value.

Did it really seem like a called him a name just for the fun of it? Wasn't the meta-context obvious?

Re:Nassim Taleb: We should retire the notion of standard dev... by rz2k on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @06:56PM (#7067115)
Let's say it was worded instead: "... these are some reasons that he was wrong, and his style of argumentation leads me to feel actual antipathy toward him."

Maybe it is because "vile" doesn't sound like a very extreme word to me—almost like Daffy Duck saying "despicable". I suppose I would have had the same reaction, if instead bluecalm had denigrated him with a word that sounds more serious to me like "worthless".