Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @05:20PM
(#706603)
This is incoherent. I literally don't know what you're responding to. Charity? Subsidizing others?
It really sounds like you're arguing against the entire concept of insurance here. The idea of managing risk by pooling it dates back to the 14th century; if you want to argue against it, consider time travel.
As to your second graf --- again, what are you talking about? Oil changes don't mitigate the risk of car accidents, which is why your insurance company will give you a break for not getting tickets or driving a safer car, but won't give you a break for changing your oil.
Re:Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to s...
by dantheman on Thursday July 16, 2009 @10:59AM
(#708059)
>>Under our current system, any insurer can refuse to cover you for any number of reasons, or assign calamitously high premiums to you.
If you can't afford insurance, then you rely on charity. To force lower insurance prices than their risk demands is subsidizing them.
Yes the oil, example isn't the best. How about getting the breaks fixed.
Insurance shouldn't cover preventive care, it should be insurance. You don't have car insurance that covers getting your oil changed, why should your health insurance cover your doctor visits?