>You don't like the idea of the government stepping in. Fine. What's your suggestion?
The government stepping out.
And then all is good with the world.
Edit: Fixed spelling mistake
We further deregulate the insurance market, and the private insurers of last resort in several locales move to more profitable markets.
Meanwhile, the insurers in the states with the greatest consumer protections move to the venues with the least consumer protections, producing a net decline in health care quality for the entire country. With barriers to interstate insurance removed, the industry is also free to concentrate itself through M&A.
While that's happening, the adverse selection problem with health insurance continues to fester, as our "free market", in enabling "the pursuit of happiness" for everyone, especially 20-something bachelors, cons the whole consumer market into believing they can free-ride into their 40s (or their first child) and then get reasonable insurance, while draining the entire risk pool of all the low-risk patients.
Those same 20-something bachelors show up in emergency rooms, bankrupting themselves over broken bones --- but no problem, by the time they're old enough to care about their credit rating, the only people who will care about this health event are the hospitals and doctors, who will raise rates on everyone else to cover.
At the same time, nothing is done to address the fundamental problem that even in the most consumer-friendly venues, tens of thousands of totally normal families are unable to obtain private insurance coverage at any rate because of preexisting condition coverage.
I'm totally sold.
This has nothing to do with meddling, and everything to do with the fact that self-pay health care bankrupts people, creates sick populations, and insurance is unaffordable to anyone but employers.
http://www.reuters.com/article/latestCrisis/idUSN21171999 1943: The War Labor Board rules that a wage freeze designed to keep inflation in check during World War II does not apply to health insurance benefits, creating an incentive for employers to provide health insurance as a way to build worker loyalty.
http://books.google.com/books?id=UDWZpSUR1aMC&pg=PA100&#... As a result of wage freezes in the World War II period, group health insurance became an important component of collective bargaining...
Also, it's silly to say that only employers can afford health insurance. Obviously the employer considers the total cost of employing you, including salary, healthcare, FISA taxes, etc. If employers stopped providing health insurance, it's likely that wages would increase (approximately) by the cost of that insurance. Then you'd have that money available.
In any case, I don't see how the specific motivation is relevant. The point is that the government is bad at anticipating the consequences of its actions. The initial motivation isn't what's important -- the end never justifies the means. The point is that pandering and public choice economics will always cause side effects.
fwiw, it looks like white male lifespan went up a ton in the first half of 20th century, 48 to 66, 37%! vs 66 to 74, just 12%. I'm pretty sure each 1 percent is exponentially harder than the last though.
http://books.google.com/books?id=_TRBtKwBr4oC&pg=PA261&#...
It is also illegal to buy health care insurance across state lines, so it isn't a competitive national marketplace.
We need to make health care more market oriented, not less.
Google "roosevelt wage freeze" for more on the freeze itself.
Up through the fist half of the 20th Century, medical expenses were generally paid individually, or through mutual-aid groups such as churches or fraternal societies. This began to change when the government instituted wage freezes. In that environment the only way for an employer to attract superior talent was to offer non-salary benefits, and the tax advantages of health care made that an attractive one.
Thus, American employers began to offer health insurance as a way to better compensate their workers when the government was trying to interfere with the labor market. As the practice became more common, it increasingly became a point that job hunters would look for. And the rest is history.
If you think that the results of this meddling are undesirable, then you might think twice about giving the same meddlers the authority to muck things up further.
Edit: here's a bit on FDR's wage freeze and its effect on health insurance: http://faculty.smu.edu/tmayo/health%20care%20timeline.htm