Re:What is "news", and what is "unethical"?
by skmurphy on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @05:57PM
(#706685)
So if TechCrunch paid someone to break into computer systems and steal those documents that would be illegal. Seems like they could choose to help twitter identify who did break in and gained unauthorized access to their computer systems. Clearly TechCrunch is advancing someone's agenda who wants to harm Twitter given the description of the information that was provided to them.
IANAL, but it's unlikely that publishing the documents would be illegal. Unethical and sleazy, sure. But what law would they break?
Re:What is "news", and what is "unethical"?
by shpxnvz on Wednesday July 15, 2009 @04:19PM
(#706466)
If the documents can reasonably be classified as trade secrets, the aggrieved party may be able to seek damages from the "informant" and an injunction against the continued publishing of them by the "press."
Of course, once the cat is out of the bag there's no putting it back in, so there's really not much benefit beyond punishing the party who stole them in the first place.
Ethics have little use in a group discussion over something so trivial because no-one can agree on the boundaries. Is Fox News's treatment of stories "journalisically ethical"? A popular view is that it's not, but is what they're doing illegal? It doesn't seem so - so a lot of people just avoid Fox News. Likewise, if TechCrunch's ethics jar with you, don't read their stuff and just trust the law to deal with any transgressions they make.
Michael Arrington seems like a new, tech equivalent of Kelvin MacKenzie (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelvin_MacKenzie) to me - a good thing in my book. He might not be loved, but he knows how to be a damn good editor and get people reading - that's what media's all about.