Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by alexeisadeski3 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:07PM
(#7058993)
Antibiotics do constitute a violent outbreak, or at least direly threaten to release one.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
An antibiotics tax won't solve anything.
About the only effective thing you can start doing is MSRA wards in hospitals and a system of rotating antibiotics. Developing new antibiotics would probably also be a good idea, no idea what the situ looks like there.
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by alexeisadeski3 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:22PM
(#7059091)
A tax won't solve anything, agreed, unless it's on the order of 10,000% or more.
Restricting antibiotics (further than they are currently) may or may not help, but is certainly within the purview of a limited libertarian state.
Restricting most (all?) other medications is not.
Antibiotics are used in commercial farming because they increase weight. The tax simply needs to be enough that (weight(antibioticked cow) - weight(non-antibioticked cow))*(price of beef) < (cost of antibiotics). Maybe that's "on the order of 10,000% or more", but I'd like to see numbers.
Re:The case for an antibiotics tax
by alexeisadeski3 on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:51AM
(#7062025)
Antibiotics are overused outside of commercial farming too.
Yes, but commercial farming is the single largest use of antibiotics. Cutting out that use would significantly improve things. We should continue to address other issues (educational campaigns hammering home the fact that antibiotics do nothing for viruses, and encouraging completion of the full course when you are taking antibiotics).