Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by jusben1369 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:47PM
(#7058451)
Before we get too carried away. All the Supervisor needed to say was "for someone coming from India" and suddenly the context is non racial and hugely illuminating. Perhaps they terminated the guy because he showed he was too emotional and incapable of dealing with the way the company worked globally when hiring and promoting and transferring employees etc.
So hard to know if he was just making a fair assessment of the realties of different regions or saying Indian's deserve less than Caucasian's simply because they're Indian.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by walshemj on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:32PM
(#7058768)
Country of origin is considered the same as ethnicity for discrimination terms and national origin is considered a protected class under US law.
Saying they where referring to the country and not the race is "not readily believable" to use a politically correct term.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by fennecfoxen on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:59PM
(#7058547)
Doubly so if the company is considering providing any sort of relocation assistance, sponsorship, or other similar things which may help the employee realize his move from India to the US -- a move which may offer well over $10k/yr worth of benefits to his overall personal well-being (and his family's).
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by bonemachine on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @01:07PM
(#7064910)
Perhaps they terminated the guy because he showed he was too emotional and incapable of dealing with the way the company worked globally ...
If so, then evidently they're the kind of company that seems way, way more concerned with employees who get "emotional" about discriminatory practices... then about the discriminatory practices themselves.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by piyush_soni on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:14PM
(#7061637)
No. It is still discrimination, howsoever euphemistic you make it. He was not to work in India. He was coming to the US and needed to have equal salary as any other employee working there.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by AJ007 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:26PM
(#7058721)
Based on the article, he didn't blow any whistle, he complained to his manager and asked what to do to give the guy a higher offer. Then a few weeks later he was fired.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by bonemachine on Wednesday January 15, 2014 @12:58PM
(#7064840)
They shot the messenger. That's the main point.
Re:Lawsuit: Oracle called $50K 'good money for an Indian'
by gaius on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:45PM
(#7058440)
Maybe, but there's not enough info in the article to conclude that. The Indian guy was already an employee remember. I simply don't know what the relevant laws are on inter-company transfers.
It's not about the Irish guy, or the Indian guy.
EDIT: for "internal allocation", above.