Re:Court strikes down FCC’s net neutrality rules
by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:59AM
(#7058100)
> You're assuming that broadband networks should be a dumb pipe to begin with. Why can't Verizon just decide to get out of the "dumb pipe" business, and say that they won't sell you a dumb pipe, but a pipe with whatever restrictions they want to impose?
Why couldn't AT&T do that when they provided pre-internet landline telephone service?
Re:Court strikes down FCC’s net neutrality rules
by rayiner on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @12:03PM
(#7058127)
Because AT&T was a regulated monopoly, with all of the benefits that come from being a regulated monopoly (guaranteed rates of return, etc). The net neutrality proposals today amount to imposing obligations on carriers as if they are a regulated monopoly without giving them all the benefits of being a regulated monopoly.
You're assuming that broadband networks should be a dumb pipe to begin with. Why can't Verizon just decide to get out of the "dumb pipe" business, and say that they won't sell you a dumb pipe, but a pipe with whatever restrictions they want to impose?